深度学习自动分割与专家观察者间变异性的比较
该研究在独立数据集上比较深度学习自动分割轮廓(DC)与多位放射肿瘤科医生(RO)专家轮廓(EC)在CNS、头颈和前列腺放疗OAR及CTV上的差异。DC由单一RO用公开数据训练。结果显示OAR的DSC和95%HD差异极小,CTV差异较明显;DC分割时间远短于EC。结论认为DC精度与专家观察者间变异性相当,有望改善放疗计划流程与资源利用。
要点
- DC在OAR上DSC和95%HD与EC差异极小,CTV差异较明显。
- DC分割时间0.4–0.6分钟,EC为7.7–26.6分钟。
- 单RO训练的DC精度可与专家观察者间变异性相当。
核心结论
- 在独立数据集上,单一RO训练的DC精度与放疗计划轮廓的专家观察者间变异性相当。
研究设计与样本
- 研究比较CNS、头颈和前列腺放疗OAR及CTV的DC与多位RO创建的EC,DC由单一RO在公开数据上训练的深度学习软件生成。
- 共纳入60份计划CT,含60套CNS、53套头颈和50套前列腺轮廓,每份有2–4个EC。
- 轮廓比较采用Dice相似系数(DSC)和95%豪斯多夫距离(HD)。
主要发现
- DC与EC平均轮廓时间:CNS 0.4 vs 7.7分钟,头颈0.6 vs 26.6分钟,前列腺0.4 vs 21.3分钟。
- OAR比较中DC的DSC和95%HD差异极小,CTV比较差异更明显。
临床怎么用
- 深度学习自动分割可减少OAR和CTV勾画时间,可能显著改善放疗计划工作流程与资源利用。
- CTV自动分割与专家间差异较明显,临床使用时仍需重点审核。
局限性
- DC由单一RO在公开数据上训练,验证数据集与训练数据集的关系未在摘要中说明。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Deep learning-based auto-segmented contours (DC) aim to alleviate labour intensive contouring of organs at risk (OAR) and clinical target volumes (CTV). Most previous DC validation studies have a limited number of expert observers for comparison and/or use a validation dataset related to the training dataset. We determine if DC models are comparable to Radiation Oncologist (RO) inter-observer variability on an independent dataset. METHODS: Expert contours (EC) were created by multiple ROs for central nervous system (CNS), head and neck (H&N), and prostate radiotherapy (RT) OARs and CTVs. DCs were generated using deep learning-based auto-segmentation software trained by a single RO on publicly available data. Contours were compared using Dice Similarity Coefficient (DSC) and 95% Hausdorff distance (HD). RESULTS: Sixty planning CT scans had 2-4 ECs, for a total of 60 CNS, 53 H&N, and 50 prostate RT contour sets. The mean DC and EC contouring times were 0.4 vs 7.7 min for CNS, 0.6 vs 26.6 min for H&N, and 0.4 vs 21.3 min for prostate RT contours. There were minimal differences in DSC and 95% HD involving DCs for OAR comparisons, but more noticeable differences for CTV comparisons. CONCLUSIONS: The accuracy of DCs trained by a single RO is comparable to expert inter-observer variability for the RT planning contours in this study. Use of deep learning-based auto-segmentation in clinical practice will likely lead to significant benefits to RT planning workflow and resources.
引用
- Wong J, Fong A, McVicar N, et al. Comparing deep learning-based auto-segmentation of organs at risk and clinical target volumes to expert inter-observer variability in radiotherapy planning. Radiother Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31812930. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2019.10.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。