头颈部放疗模拟中MRI-CT图像配准的前瞻性定量质量保证与形变估计
前瞻性纳入15例头颈部放疗患者,采集非增强CT与T2 MRI,手动分割每扫描35个解剖ROI,比较刚性配准与三种商用形变配准算法的DSC、HD mean和HD max。结果显示无任何形变配准算法在任一ROI或整体上优于刚性配准(所有p值>0.05),肌肉和腺体ROI的一致性显著优于血管和骨骼。
要点
- 商用形变配准算法未在头颈部MRI-CT配准中优于刚性配准。
- 肌肉和腺体ROI的配准一致性显著优于血管和骨骼。
- 结果质疑通过CT配准将组织电子密度信息转移至MRI的可行性。
核心结论
- 对于头颈部MRI-CT共配准,商用形变配准算法相比刚性配准未显示优势。
- 整体配准性能不佳,质疑通过CT配准将组织电子密度信息转移至MRI的可行性。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入15例头颈部放疗患者,采集标准固定技术下的非增强CT和T2 MRI。
- 每扫描手动分割35个解剖感兴趣区(ROI),共105个ROI用于分析。
- MRI分别进行刚性配准(RIR)和三种商用形变配准算法(DIR)。
- 采用Dice相似系数(DSC)、Hausdorff距离均值(HD mean)和最大值(HD max)评估配准一致性。
主要发现
- 没有任何DIR算法在任一ROI或所有ROI整体上改善分割质量优于RIR(所有p值>0.05)。
- 肌肉和腺体ROI的配准一致性显著优于血管和骨骼,但DIR与RIR仍无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 非参数Steel检验用于比较各DIR算法与RIR,控制个体ROI(n=105次检验)和所有ROI汇总(n=3次检验)。
- 非参数Wilcoxon配对检验用于评估组织类型对配准保真度的影响(n=12次检验)。
- 采用Bonferroni校正进行多重比较。
临床怎么用
- 在头颈部放疗MRI-CT配准中,不应默认商用DIR算法优于刚性配准。
- 若需将电子密度信息转移至MRI,应考虑合成CT生成或体密度赋值而非依赖CT配准。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: MRI-guided radiotherapy planning (MRIgRT) may be superior to CT-guided planning in some instances owing to its improved soft tissue contrast. However, MR images do not communicate tissue electron density information necessary for dose calculation and therefore must either be co-registered to CT or algorithmically converted to synthetic CT. No robust quality assessment of commercially available MR-CT registration algorithms is yet available; thus we sought to quantify MR-CT registration formally. METHODS: Head and neck non-contrast CT and T2 MRI scans acquired with standard treatment immobilization techniques were prospectively acquired from 15 patients. Per scan, 35 anatomic regions of interest (ROIs) were manually segmented. MRIs were registered to CT rigidly (RIR) and by three commercially available deformable registration algorithms (DIR). Dice similarity coefficient (DSC), Hausdorff distance mean (HD mean) and Hausdorff distance max (HD max) metrics were calculated to assess concordance between MRI and CT segmentations. Each DIR algorithm was compared to DIR using the nonparametric Steel test with control for individual ROIs (n = 105 tests) and for all ROIs in aggregate (n = 3 tests). The influence of tissue type on registration fidelity was assessed using nonparametric Wilcoxon pairwise tests between ROIs grouped by tissue type (n = 12 tests). Bonferroni corrections were applied for multiple comparisons. RESULTS: No DIR algorithm improved the segmentation quality over RIR for any ROI nor all ROIs in aggregate (all p values >0.05). Muscle and gland ROIs were significantly more concordant than vessel and bone, but DIR remained non-different from RIR. CONCLUSIONS: For MR-CT co-registration, our results question the utility and applicability of commercially available DIR over RIR alone. The poor overall performance also questions the feasibility of translating tissue electron density information to MRI by CT registration, rather than addressing this need with synthetic CT generation or bulk-density assignment.
引用
- Kiser K, Meheissen MAM, Mohamed ASR, et al. Prospective quantitative quality assurance and deformation estimation of MRI-CT image registration in simulation of head and neck radiotherapy patients. Clin Transl Radiat Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31341987. doi:10.1016/j.ctro.2019.04.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。