喉鳞癌放疗两种勾画指南的体积与剂量学比较
本研究对4例T2或T3 N0-M0喉鳞癌患者,分别按法国指南与国际共识指南勾画原发肿瘤CTV,并行VMAT剂量优化,比较靶区体积与剂量分布差异。结果示低剂量CTV差异大、高剂量CTV差异较小,剂量分布差异利于国际指南降低OAR剂量,但合并原发与淋巴结PTV后差异减弱。
要点
- 低剂量CTV勾画差异大,高剂量CTV差异较小。
- 国际指南剂量分布更利于降低部分OAR剂量。
- 合并原发与淋巴结PTV后剂量差异减弱。
核心结论
- 两种勾画指南在喉鳞癌原发肿瘤CTV上存在较大差异,并转化为剂量分布差异。
研究设计与样本
- 对4例T2或T3 N0-M0喉鳞癌患者,由两名放疗科医生分别按法国指南与国际指南独立勾画高剂量和低剂量原发肿瘤CTV。
- 4例的GTV由一名放疗科医生勾画,淋巴结CTV由一名放疗科医生按国际指南勾画。
- 采用VMAT(MONACO 5.11版)以6 MeV光子进行剂量优化,并用DICE相似系数和均匀性指数等指标评估靶区体积与OAR、PTV剂量分布差异。
主要发现
- 两种勾画方法在低剂量CTV上差异较大,在高剂量CTV上差异较小。
- 这些差异转化为剂量分布变化,国际指南在降低多个OAR剂量方面更有利。
- 当原发肿瘤PTV与淋巴结PTV的剂量分布合并后,上述差异减弱。
临床怎么用
- 喉鳞癌放疗勾画时需注意不同指南对低剂量CTV范围的显著影响,并结合剂量分布权衡OAR保护。
局限性
- 仅纳入4例患者,样本量小,结论需更大样本验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Three methods have been recently proposed for the delineation of the primary tumor clinical target volume (CTV-P) in Head and Neck Cancers: the anatomic method popularized in the French literature by Lapeyre et al. the geometric methods proposed by the DAHANCA group, and more recently the international guidelines promoted by Grégoire et al. integrating the latter two. The aim of this study was to perform a volumetric and dosimetric comparison of the French and the International consensus methods in laryngeal SCC. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Two radiation oncologists independently delineated the high dose and low dose primary tumor CTV in four patients with T2 or T3 N0-M0 laryngeal SCC following either the so-called French guidelines or the International guidelines. For the 4 cases, the GTV was delineated by a single radiation oncologist. Nodal CTVs were delineated by one radiation oncologist for the 4 cases using International guidelines. Dose optimization was then performed with VMAT (MONACO version 5.11) using 6 MeV photons. Differences in target volumes and dose distributions in OARs and PTVs were then evaluated with various metrics such as the DICE Similarity Coefficient and the homogeneity index. RESULTS: Major differences were observed in the CTV delineation between the 2 delineation methods for the low dose volumes and to a lower extend for the high dose volumes. These differences translated into variations in dose distribution favoring the International guidelines for decreasing dose to various OARs. Such differences toned down when dose distribution on the primary tumors PTVs and nodal PTVs were combined. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated large differences in CTV delineation between the 2 delineation guidelines. Such differences translated into differences in dose distribution.
引用
- Bondue C, Racadot S, Coutte A, et al. Volumetric and dosimetric comparison of two delineation guidelines for the radiation treatment of laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma. Clin Transl Radiat Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31334365. doi:10.1016/j.ctro.2019.06.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。