区域通气成像:CT通气成像是否为答案?验证数据的系统综述
由于验证方法异质性大,难以对其有效性做广泛结论;CTVI在肺叶或全肺水平与参考通气成像的相关性中等至强,但在体素水平相关性差。
要点
- CTVI在肺叶或全肺水平与参考通气成像相关性中等至强,体素水平相关性差。
- 验证研究在参考成像模态、成像参数、DIR算法和通气指标上异质性大。
- 需细化和标准化CTVI临床验证方法,以支持其在前瞻性试验中的应用。
核心结论
- 由于验证文献方法多样,难以对CTVI的有效性做出广泛结论。
- CTVI在肺叶或全肺水平显示合理的跨模态相关性,但在体素水平相关性差。
- 需要细化和标准化CTVI的临床验证方法。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PUBMED和EMBASE 2000至2018年英文文献,按PRISMA指南分析。
主要发现
- 研究间在参考通气成像模态(如核医学、超极化气体MRI)、成像参数、DIR算法和通气指标上存在大量异质性。
- 最常用的通气指标使用可变形图像配准评估呼气至吸气运动场雅可比行列式(DIR-Jac)或基于亨斯菲尔德单位的气体含量变化(DIR-HU)。
- CTVI与参考通气成像的线性回归相关系数平均值±标准差:DIR-Jac为0.73±0.25(n=6),DIR-HU为0.86±0.11(n=12)。
- 斯皮尔曼相关系数(SPC)平均值±标准差:DIR-Jac为0.45±0.31(n=6),DIR-HU为0.41±0.11(n=5)。
临床怎么用
- CTVI似乎与放疗计划相关,尤其适用于主要肺部损伤不是气体交换问题的患者。
- 对于有其他肺部疾病(即限制性或气体交换问题)的患者,可能需要考虑替代成像方法。
局限性
- 验证文献使用的方法多样,导致研究间异质性大,难以广泛概括CTVI的有效性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Computed Tomography Ventilation Imaging (CTVI) is an experimental imaging modality that derives regional lung function information from non-contrast respiratory-correlated CT datasets. Despite CTVI being extensively studied in cross-modality imaging comparisons, there is a lack of consensus on the state of its clinical validation in humans. This systematic review evaluates the CTVI clinical validation studies to date, highlights their common strengths and weaknesses and makes recommendations. We performed a PUBMED and EMBASE search of all English language papers on CTVI between 2000 and 2018. The results of these searches were filtered in accordance to a set of eligibility criteria and analysed in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) Guidelines. One hundred and forty-four records were identified, and 66 full text records were reviewed. After detailed assessment, twenty-three full text papers met the selection criteria and were included in the final review. This included thirteen prospective studies, with 579 human subjects. Studies used diverse methodologies, with a large amount of heterogeneity between different studies in terms of the reference ventilation imaging modality (e.g. nuclear medicine, hyperpolarised gas MRI), imaging parameters, DIR algorithm(s) used, and ventilation metric(s) applied. The most common ventilation metrics used deformable image registration to evaluate the exhale-to-inhale motion field Jacobian determinant (DIR-Jac) or changes in air volume content based on Hounsfield Units (DIR-HU). The strength of correlation between CTVI and the reference ventilation imaging modalities was moderate to strong when evaluated at the lobar or global level, with the average ± S.D. (number of studies) linear regression correlation coefficients were 0.73 ± 0.25 (n = 6) and 0.86 ± 0.11 (n = 12) for DIR-Jac and DIR-HU respectively, and the SPC were 0.45 ± 0.31 (n = 6) and 0.41 ± 0.11 (n = 5) for DIR-Jac and DIR-HU respectively. We concluded that it is difficult to make a broad statement about the validity of CTVI due to the diverse methods used in the validation literature. Typically, CTVI appears to show reasonable cross-modality correlations at the lobar/whole lung level but poor correlations at the voxel level. Since CTVI is seeing new implementations in prospective trials, it is clear that refinement and standardization of the clinical validation methodologies are required. CTVI appears to be of relevance in radiotherapy planning, particularly in patients whose main pulmonary impairment is not a gas exchange problem but alternative imaging approaches may need to be considered in patients with other pulmonary diseases (i.e. restrictive or gas exchange problems).
引用
- Hegi-Johnson F, de Ruysscher D, Keall P, et al. Imaging of regional ventilation: Is CT ventilation imaging the answer? A systematic review of the validation data. Radiother Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31129503. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2019.03.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。