头颈癌放疗患者报告结局、观察者报告毒性与整体生活质量关联的大数据分析
该研究分析612例头颈癌放疗患者1273次随访中27项患者报告结局(PRO)、临床医生按CTCAE记录的观察者报告毒性(ORT)与患者报告整体生活质量(QOL)的关联。结果显示活动、娱乐/休闲和疲乏与QOL关联最强(ρ=0.51-0.60),ROC方法可识别高AUC的ORT-PRO响应阈值(最大AUCavg=0.78)。结论提示临床问卷可精简条目,并强调就诊时收集PRO以捕捉医生评估不足的症状。
要点
- 活动、娱乐/休闲和疲乏是与整体生活质量关联最强的PRO条目。
- 医生对毒性的评估能力在毒性较严重时最高,支持常规收集PRO。
- ROC方法可识别ORT-PRO关联的响应阈值,最大AUCavg=0.78。
核心结论
- PRO关联分析识别出活动、生活方式和疲乏为临床问卷应重点考虑的条目。
- 结局信息可用少于本研究27项的条目来捕获。
- 医生评估患者毒性的能力在毒性更严重时最高,强调就诊时收集PRO的必要性。
研究设计与样本
- 612例头颈癌放疗患者在三份问卷中完成27项PRO条目,共1273次随访。
- 临床医生按CTCAE标准提供ORT。
- 采用大数据方法,以Pearson(ρ)和Kendall(τ)相关系数衡量PRO间、PRO与ORT间及PRO/ORT与QOL间的关联。
- 使用基于ROC曲线的新分析方法检测响应水平中显示强相互作用的阈值。
主要发现
- 与QOL关联最强的PRO为娱乐/休闲、活动和疲乏,ρ=0.51-0.60。
- 评估共同功能结局(如口干)的多个PRO彼此高度关联(PRO-PRO),最大ρ=0.84。
- ORT-PRO最大相关性为ρ=0.61(味觉障碍 versus 味觉),ORT-QOL为ρ=0.5(口干-日间)。
- ROC方法识别出许多ORT-PRO关联的响应阈值具有高曲线下面积(AUC),最大AUCavg=0.78。
临床怎么用
- 临床问卷可重点纳入活动、生活方式和疲乏等与QOL强关联的PRO条目。
- 可考虑用更少条目捕获结局信息,而非固定使用27项。
- 就诊时应常规收集PRO,以更好理解和处理患者症状,尤其弥补医生对轻中度毒性评估的不足。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To assess associations between a variety of patient-reported outcomes (PROs), observer reported toxicities (ORTs), and patient-reported overall quality of life (QOL) for head and neck cancer patients treated with radiotherapy, in order to identify important items for inclusion in prospective patient reporting in the clinic. METHODS: 612 patients completed 27 PRO items from three questionnaires at 1273 follow-up visits, and clinicians provided ORTs according to CTCAE criteria. Using a big data approach, we measured associations among all PROs, between all PROs and ORTs, and between PROs/ORTs and QOL with Pearson (ρ) and Kendall (τ) correlation coefficients, and a novel analysis method based on receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves used to detect thresholds in response levels demonstrating strong interactions. RESULTS: PROs most strongly associated with QOL were recreation/entertainment, activity, and fatigue, with ρ = 0.51-0.60. Several PROs assessing a common functional outcome (eg. xerostomia) were highly associated with each other (PRO-PRO), with maximum ρ = 0.84. Maximum ORT-PRO correlations were ρ = 0.61 (dysgeusia versus taste), and ρ = 0.5 for ORT-QOL (dry mouth - day). The ROC method identified response thresholds with high area under the curve (AUC) scores for many ORT-PRO associations with maximum AUCavg = 0.78. CONCLUSIONS: PRO associations identified activity, lifestyle and fatigue as items for strong consideration for inclusion in questionnaires in the clinic, and suggest that outcome information can be captured in fewer items than the 27 in this study. The ability of clinicians to assess patient toxicities is highest with more severe toxicities, underscoring the need for PRO collection in patient visits to understand and address patient symptoms.
引用
- Wilkie JR, Mierzwa ML, Yao J, et al. Big data analysis of associations between patient reported outcomes, observer reported toxicities, and overall quality of life in head and neck cancer patients treated with radiation therapy. Radiother Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31128357. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2019.04.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。