文献速递头颈部肿瘤放疗放疗物理与技术

头颈癌靶区勾画的观察者间变异性

Interobserver variability in delineation of target volumes in head and neck cancer.
PubMed 文献 · Radiother Oncol · 2019-04-29

该研究通过比利时多中心调查,评估头颈癌靶区勾画的观察者间变异性。结果显示,尽管多数中心使用相同选择性颈淋巴区勾画指南,颈淋巴区选择与勾画体积仍存在较大差异;原发肿瘤临床靶区勾画同样异质。作者认为仅提供指南不足以保证勾画一致性,需加强培训。

要点

  • 各中心间选择性颈淋巴区勾画一致性中等,DSC中位数0.67–0.82,HD50中位数1.7–2.8 mm。
  • 颈II、III、IV区一致性较好,颈Ib、V、VI、VIIa、VIIb区一致性最差。
  • 原发肿瘤临床靶区勾画异质性更大,DSC中位数0.51–0.79,HD50中位数2.8–4.1 mm。

核心结论

  • 尽管几乎所有参与中心使用相同的选择性颈淋巴区勾画指南,颈淋巴区选择与勾画体积仍存在较大差异。
  • 原发肿瘤临床靶区勾画同样异质,但预期随着近期发表的指南实施会有所改善。
  • 仅提供指南不足以保证勾画一致性,需要额外针对靶区勾画的教学培训。

研究设计与样本

  • 2017年2月邀请所有比利时放射治疗科参加在线调查,并提交5例头颈癌参考病例的临床靶区。
  • 比较各中心间原发肿瘤临床靶区(CTVp),并将选择性颈淋巴临床靶区(CTVe)与CTVe金标准(CTVeGS)比较。
  • 计算体积、DICE相似系数(DSC)和中位Hausdorff距离(HD)。

主要发现

  • 9个中心使用CTVp指南,但无任何两个中心使用相同指南。
  • CTVe与CTVeGS比较,DSC中位数范围0.67–0.82,HD50范围1.7–2.8 mm。
  • 颈II、III、IV区显示良好一致性,颈Ib、V、VI、VIIa、VIIb区一致性最差;当选择与CTVeGS相同颈区时DSC和HD50改善。

关键数值与推荐

  • CTVe与CTVeGS比较:DSC中位数0.67–0.82,HD50中位数1.7–2.8 mm。
  • CTVp:DSC中位数0.51–0.79,HD50中位数2.8–4.1 mm;仅纳入使用10 mm margin的中心计算时略有改善。

临床怎么用

  • 头颈癌靶区勾画需在指南基础上加强培训与质量保证,以减少观察者间差异。
  • 颈Ib、V、VI、VIIa、VIIb区勾画一致性最差,应作为培训与质控重点。

局限性

  • CTVp指南使用异质,无两个中心使用相同指南,影响比较。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: In the last decade precision of radiotherapy treatment execution increased, demanding more accurate delineations to fully exploit these developments. The aim of this study was to identify the extent of interobserver variability in delineation of head and neck cancer (HNC). MATERIALS AND METHODS: In February 2017 all Belgian radiotherapy departments were invited to complete an online survey and submit clinical target volumes for five HNC reference cases. Clinical target volume of the primary tumour (CTVp) and elective nodal neck (CTVe) were submitted and compared between centres for CTVp and to the CTVe 'gold standard' (CTVeGS). Volume, DICE similarity coefficient (DSC) and median Hausdorff Distance (HD) were measured and calculated. RESULTS: Fourteen of 22 centres (64%) completed both survey and delineations. They all used delineation guidelines for CTVe and twelve confirmed the use of guidelines of Grégoire et al. Nine centres used CTVp guidelines, although none used the same ones. Median DSC for CTVe comparing centres with CTVeGS ranged between 0.67 and 0.82 and HD50 between 1.7 mm and 2.8 mm. Good agreement was shown for neck level II, III and IV, whilst worst consensus was observed for level Ib, V, VI, VIIa and VIIb. Improvement of DSC and HD50 was observed when the same levels as CTVeGS were selected. Median DSC and HD50 for CTVp ranged between 0.51 and 0.79 and 2.8 mm and 4.1 mm respectively, which both slightly improved when calculating it for only the centres using a 10 mm margin. CONCLUSION: Although nearly all participants used identical guidelines for CTVe there were large discrepancies in neck levels selected and volumes delineated. CTVp delineations were also heterogeneous although we expect improvement with implementation of recently published guidelines. Additional teaching in target volume delineation is necessary as this paper demonstrates that availability and implementation of guidelines alone is not enough to guarantee uniform delineation.

来源:Radiother Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. van der Veen J, Gulyban A, Nuyts S, et al. Interobserver variability in delineation of target volumes in head and neck cancer. Radiother Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31048235. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2019.04.006

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。