在蒙特卡洛系统PRIMO中使用瓦里安dynalog文件进行治疗验证
本研究在PRIMO系统中实现了从瓦里安dynalog文件重建治疗计划的方法,并以前列腺和头颈部容积旋转调强放疗临床病例评估该方法对多叶准直器叶片位置误差所致剂量偏差的敏感性。结果显示,叶片位置误差主要沿单方向时,所用方法对均方根误差≥0.2 mm的dynalog敏感;误差为双向时,仅均方根误差>1.2 mm才产生可检测的剂量偏差。PA和α/Δ对叶片位置误差比GPR更敏感,作者认为GPR 3,3不推荐作为dynalog文件所捕获误差引入剂量偏差的唯一评估指标。
要点
- 从dynalog文件重建计划与从治疗计划系统导入计划模拟所得剂量分布一致性良好。
- 误差主要沿单方向时,方法对均方根误差≥0.2 mm的dynalog敏感;双向误差时仅均方根误差>1.2 mm产生可检测剂量偏差。
- PA和α/Δ对叶片位置误差比GPR更敏感,作者认为GPR 3,3不推荐作为唯一评估指标。
核心结论
- 本工作在PRIMO系统中实现并验证了利用瓦里安dynalog文件记录信息验证放疗治疗准确性的方法。
- 作者认为可基于PA和α/Δ的值建立耐受限值。
- 作者认为GPR 3,3不推荐作为dynalog文件所捕获误差引入剂量偏差的唯一评估指标。
研究设计与样本
- 在PRIMO系统中实现从瓦里安dynalog文件重建治疗计划,并使用PRIMO快速蒙特卡洛引擎DPM估算剂量分布。
- 以前列腺和头颈部容积旋转调强放疗临床病例评估所实现重建方法的准确性。
- 通过比较从治疗计划系统导入计划模拟所得剂量分布与从dynalog文件中记录的预期叶片位置重建计划模拟所得剂量分布来评估准确性。
- 通过比较从预期叶片位置重建计划与从实际叶片位置重建计划估算的剂量分布,评估叶片位置误差对剂量的影响。
- 比较采用Gamma通过率(GPR)、本文引入的一致百分比(PA)和具有给定系统差异的体素百分比(α/Δ)进行,并向叶片位置引入误差以研究这些量的敏感性。
主要发现
- 从治疗计划系统导入计划与从预期叶片位置重建计划模拟所得剂量分布获得良好一致性。
- 对于增加控制点数以近似匹配dynalog记录数的导入计划,未获得显著更好的一致性。
- 当引入误差主要沿一个方向时,本工作所用方法对均方根误差≥0.2 mm的dynalog敏感。
- 当误差为双向时,仅均方根误差>1.2 mm才在剂量中产生可检测偏差。
- PA和α/Δ对叶片位置误差比GPR更敏感。
关键数值与推荐
- 误差主要沿单方向时,本工作所用方法对均方根误差≥0.2 mm的dynalog敏感。
- 误差为双向时,仅均方根误差>1.2 mm产生可检测的剂量偏差。
- PA和α/Δ对叶片位置误差比GPR更敏感。
- 作者认为可基于PA和α/Δ的值建立耐受限值。
- 作者认为GPR 3,3不推荐作为dynalog文件所捕获误差引入剂量偏差的唯一评估指标。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为可基于PA和α/Δ的值建立耐受限值。
- 作者认为GPR 3,3不推荐作为dynalog文件所捕获误差引入剂量偏差的唯一评估指标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The PRIMO system is a computer software that allows the Monte Carlo simulation of linear accelerators and the estimation of the subsequent absorbed dose distributions in phantoms and computed tomographies. The aim of this work is to validate the methods incorporated in PRIMO to evaluate the deviations introduced in the dose distributions by errors in the positioning of the leaves of the multileaf collimator recorded in the dynalog files during patient treatment. METHODS: The reconstruction of treatment plans from Varian's dynalog files was implemented in the PRIMO system. Dose distributions were estimated for volumetric-modulated arc therapy clinical cases of prostate and head&neck using the PRIMO fast Monte Carlo engine DPM. Accuracy of the implemented reconstruction methods was evaluated by comparing dose distributions obtained from the simulations of the plans imported from the treatment planning system with those obtained from the simulations of the plans reconstructed from the expected leaves positions recorded in the dynalog files. The impact on the dose of errors in the positions of the leaves was evaluated by comparing dose distributions estimated for plans reconstructed from expected leaves positions with dose distributions estimated from actual leaves positions. Gamma pass rate (GPR), a hereby introduced quantity named percentage of agreement (PA) and the percentage of voxels with a given systematic difference (α/Δ) were the quantities used for the comparisons. Errors were introduced in leaves positions in order to study the sensitivity of these quantities. RESULTS: A good agreement of the dose distributions obtained from the plan imported from the TPS and from the plan reconstructed from expected leaves positions was obtained. Not a significantly better agreement was obtained for an imported plan with an increased number of control points such as to approximately match the number of records in the dynalogs. When introduced errors were predominantly in one direction, the methods employed in this work were sensitive to dynalogs with root-mean-square errors (RMS) ≥0.2 mm. Nevertheless, when errors were in both directions, only RMS >1.2 mm produced detectable deviations in the dose. The PA and the α/Δ showed more sensitive to errors in the leaves positions than the GPR. CONCLUSIONS: Methods to verify the accuracy of the radiotherapy treatment from the information recorded in the Varian's dynalog files were implemented and verified in this work for the PRIMO system. Tolerance limits could be established based on the values of PA and α/Δ. GPR 3,3 is not recommended as a solely evaluator of deviations introduced in the dose by errors captured in the dynalog files.
引用
- Rodriguez M, Brualla L. Treatment verification using Varian's dynalog files in the Monte Carlo system PRIMO. Radiat Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31014356. doi:10.1186/s13014-019-1269-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。