混合生物力学形变配准方法在多级可重复形变物理模体上的评估
研究开发了基于生物力学模型的DIR细化方法(BM-DIR),用于改进任意基于图像强度的DIR(IM-DIR)输出的形变向量场。在多级可重复形变物理模体上,BM-DIR在较大形变阶段改善了内部尿道管的DSC和表面距离指标,Jacobian分布更平滑;在头颈部患者MR图像上,BM-DIR将腮腺内标志点的目标配准误差从0.339 cm降至0.210 cm。
要点
- BM-DIR在较大形变阶段可改善掩膜MR图像上内部尿道管的DVF精度。
- BM-DIR输出的Jacobian分布更平滑,提示内部形变更具物理合理性。
- 头颈部患者掩膜MR图像上,腮腺内标志点TRE由0.339 cm降至0.210 cm。
核心结论
- 在多级物理模体和有限患者数据上定量证明,所提出的BM-DIR可改善缺乏显著图像特征的实性器官在大形变下的内部配准精度。
研究设计与样本
- 开发基于生物力学模型的DIR细化方法(BM-DIR),对任意初始IM-DIR输出的DVF进行细化。
- 在具有十个可重复、逐渐增大形变阶段的新模体上定量评估,以尿道管作为替代结构。
- 另采用两对头颈部患者MR图像,以腮腺内专家定义标志点评估BM-DIR的TRE。
主要发现
- 内部尿道管的DSC和表面距离指标表明,BM-DIR在较大形变阶段的掩膜MR图像上可改善内部DVF精度。
- BM-DIR的Jacobian分布更平滑,提示内部形变更具物理合理性。
- 头颈部患者掩膜MR图像上,腮腺内标志点的TRE由0.339 cm改善至0.210 cm。
关键数值与推荐
- 内部DIR精度以尿道结构的Dice相似系数(DSC)、Hausdorff距离和平均表面距离评估。
- 另检查体素级形变向量差异和Jacobian正则性以评估输出DVF。
- 头颈部患者以目标配准误差(TRE)评估BM-DIR精度。
局限性
- 结论基于多级物理模体和有限患者数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Advanced clinical applications, such as dose accumulation and adaptive radiation therapy, require deformable image registration (DIR) algorithms capable of voxel-wise accurate mapping of treatment dose or functional imaging. By utilizing a multistage deformable phantom, the authors investigated scenarios where biomechanical refinement method (BM-DIR) may be better than the pure image intensity based deformable registration (IM-DIR). METHODS: The authors developed a biomechanical-model based DIR refinement method (BM-DIR) to refine the deformable vector field (DVF) from any initial intensity-based DIR (IM-DIR). The BM-DIR method was quantitatively evaluated on a novel phantom capable of ten reproducible gradually-increasing deformation stages using the urethra tube as a surrogate. The internal DIR accuracy was inspected in term of the Dice similarity coefficient (DSC), Hausdorff and mean surface distance as defined in of the urethra structure inside the phantom and compared with that of the initial IM-DIR under various stages of deformation. Voxel-wise deformation vector discrepancy and Jacobian regularity were also inspected to evaluate the output DVFs. In addition to phantom, two pairs of Head&Neck patient MR images with expert-defined landmarks inside parotids were utilized to evaluate the BM-DIR accuracy with target registration error (TRE). RESULTS: The DSC and surface distance measures of the inner urethra tube indicated the BM-DIR method can improve the internal DVF accuracy on masked MR images for the phases of a large degree of deformation. The smoother Jacobian distribution from the BM-DIR suggests more physically-plausible internal deformation. For H&N cancer patients, the BM-DIR improved the TRE from 0.339 cm to 0.210 cm for the landmarks inside parotid on the masked MR images. CONCLUSIONS: We have quantitatively demonstrated on a multi-stage physical phantom and limited patient data that the proposed BM-DIR can improve the accuracy inside solid organs with large deformation where distinctive image features are absent.
引用
- Qin A, Ionascu D, Liang J, et al. The evaluation of a hybrid biomechanical deformable registration method on a multistage physical phantom with reproducible deformation. Radiat Oncol. 2018. PMID: 30514348. doi:10.1186/s13014-018-1192-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。