基于自动知识计划生成剂量学指标的临床导向轮廓评估
研究让22名住院医师勾画鼻咽癌病例的临床靶区、腮腺和耳蜗,以专家勾画为金标准,用自动知识计划生成67个治疗计划并计算剂量学指标。几何指标与剂量学指标相关性弱(61%的相关性R²<0.2)且不一致,无法定义临床可接受的几何阈值;住院医师间轮廓变异显著影响剂量学终点。
要点
- 几何指标与剂量学指标相关性弱且不一致,无法定义临床可接受的几何阈值。
- 住院医师间轮廓变异显著,若用于临床会产生显著负面剂量学影响。
- 自动知识计划生成的剂量学指标宜与几何指标联合用于轮廓研究。
核心结论
- 住院医师间轮廓变异显著影响剂量学终点,凸显住院医师头颈部解剖勾画教育的重要性。
- 自动计划生成的剂量学指标在有条件时应与几何指标联合用于放射治疗轮廓研究。
研究设计与样本
- 22名住院医师对一例鼻咽癌病例勾画临床靶区、腮腺和耳蜗,以专家勾画为金标准。
- 采用经验证的知识计划流程生成67个治疗计划,涵盖不同住院医师/金标准与靶区/危及器官组合。
主要发现
- 几何与剂量学指标相关性弱,61%的相关性(126个中的77个)R²<0.2。
- 无单一几何指标始终优于或劣于与剂量学终点的相关性。
- 几何指标作为剂量学影响的分类器具有高假阳性和假阴性倾向。
- 住院医师间轮廓变异显著,无论用几何还是剂量学指标量化,若用于临床会产生显著负面剂量学影响。
关键数值与推荐
- 剂量学指标包括计划靶区最热98%体积的剂量和危及器官平均剂量,均在金标准轮廓上计算。
- 几何指标包括Dice系数、Hausdorff最大/平均/中位距离、体积差异和质心距离。
- 因几何与剂量学指标缺乏一致相关性,无法定义任何几何指标的临床可接受阈值。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Geometric indicators of contouring accuracy suffer from lack of clinical context in radiation therapy. To provide clinical relevance, treatment plans should be generated from the candidate contours, but manual planning could introduce confounding variations. Therefore, our objectives in this study were as follows: (1) determine the feasibility of using automated knowledge-based planning as an objective tool to generate dosimetric parameters for contour evaluation, (2) evaluate the correlation between geometric indices and dosimetric endpoints, and (3) report the dosimetric impact of multiple observations of head and neck target and organ-at-risk (OAR) volumes contoured by resident physicians. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Twenty-two resident physicians contoured the clinical target volumes, parotids, and cochleae for a nasopharyngeal cancer case, and expert-generated contours were defined as the gold standard for this study. A validated knowledge-based planning routine generated 67 treatment plans with various resident/gold-standard and target/OAR combinations. Dosimetric indices (dose to hottest 98% volume of planning target volume, and mean dose of OAR) were calculated on gold-standard contours. Commonly used geometric indices (Dice coefficients, Hausdorff maximum/mean/median distances, volume differences, and centroid distances) were also calculated. R2 quantified the correlation between geometric and dosimetric indices. RESULTS: The correlation between geometric and dosimetric indices was weak (R2 < 0.2 for 61% of the correlations studied-77 of 126) and inconsistent (no single geometric index consistently exhibited superior/inferior correlation with dosimetric endpoints). The lack of consistent correlations between geometric and dosimetric indices resulted in the inability to define any geometric index thresholds for clinical acceptability. Geometric indices also exhibited a high propensity for false positives and false negatives as a classifier of dosimetric impact. Finally, we found substantial interresident contour variation, whether quantified using geometric or dosimetric indices, with significant negative dosimetric impact should these contours be used clinically. CONCLUSIONS: Contour variation among resident physicians significantly affected dosimetric endpoints, highlighting the importance of resident education in head and neck anatomy delineation. Whenever available, dosimetric indices generated from automated planning should be used alongside geometric indices in radiation therapy contouring studies.
引用
- Lim TY, Gillespie E, Murphy J, et al. Clinically Oriented Contour Evaluation Using Dosimetric Indices Generated From Automated Knowledge-Based Planning. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2018. PMID: 30508619. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2018.11.048
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。