评估选择不同形变配准算法对直方图匹配增强锥形束CT的影响
该研究使用10例前列腺癌患者的计划CT与锥形束CT图像,比较1种刚性配准与3种形变配准算法结合直方图匹配对CBCT校正质量的影响。结果显示基于归一化互相关系数的形变配准(DR-NCC)结合直方图匹配所得平均HU误差最低,约为55.95±10.43 HU,并改善了CBCT的空间均匀性。结论认为在直方图匹配前选择准确的形变配准算法可实现CBCT图像的准确校正。
要点
- DR-NCC结合直方图匹配的平均HU误差约为55.95±10.43 HU,低于DR-MI的58.60±10.35 HU和DR-NMI的56.58±10.51 HU。
- 直方图匹配校正后,除软组织-空气和软组织-骨界面因配准不当外,校正CBCT与形变pCT的绝对差异减小。
- 该方法使脂肪和肌肉中pCT与CBCT的均方根差(RMSD)分别从57 HU和25 HU降至8 HU,改善了空间均匀性。
核心结论
- 在直方图匹配前选择准确的形变配准算法可实现对CBCT图像的准确校正。
- 结果提示基于归一化互相关系数相似性度量的形变配准过程可显著降低CBCT图像中的不确定性,并生成与计划CT良好一致的图像。
研究设计与样本
- 使用10例前列腺癌患者的计划CT和锥形束CT图像数据集。
- 每例计划CT分别用1种以互信息为相似性度量的刚性配准算法(RR-MI)和3种形变配准算法(DR-NCC、DR-MI、DR-NMI)配准至对应CBCT。
- 随后在形变计划CT与CBCT之间进行直方图匹配,以校正CBCT图像的HU分布。
主要发现
- 视觉评估显示,除软组织-空气和软组织-骨界面因配准不当外,直方图匹配校正后校正CBCT与形变计划CT的绝对差异减小。
- 按平均HU误差进行体积比较,DR-NCC结合直方图匹配的误差最低,约为55.95±10.43 HU,DR-MI和DR-NMI的误差分别为58.60±10.35 HU和56.58±10.51 HU。
- 按平均绝对误差(MAE)图进行组织类别比较,证实DR-NCC算法生成的校正CBCT图像MAE值最低,即使在错位更明显的区域也是如此。
- 该方法使计划CT与CBCT在脂肪和肌肉中的均方根差(RMSD)分别从57 HU和25 HU降至8 HU,成功改善了CBCT图像的空间均匀性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this work is to assess the impact of using different deformable registration (DR) algorithms on the quality of cone-beam CT (CBCT) correction with histogram matching (HM). METHODS AND MATERIALS: Data sets containing planning CT (pCT) and CBCT images for ten patients with prostate cancer were used. Each pCT image was registered to its corresponding CBCT image using one rigid registration algorithm with mutual information similarity metric (RR-MI) and three DR algorithms with normalized correlation coefficient, mutual information and normalized mutual information (DR-NCC, DR-MI and DR-NMI, respectively). Then, the HM was performed between deformed pCT and CBCT in order to correct the distribution of the Hounsfield Units (HU) in CBCT images. RESULTS: The visual assessment showed that the absolute difference between corrected CBCT and deformed pCT was reduced after correction with HM except for soft tissue-air and soft-tissue-bone interfaces due to the improper registration. Furthermore, volumes comparison in terms of average HU error showed that using DR-NCC algorithm with HM yielded the lowest error values of about 55.95 ± 10.43 HU compared to DR-MI and DR-NMI for which the errors were 58.60 ± 10.35 and 56.58 ± 10.51 HU, respectively. Tissue class's comparison by the mean absolute error (MAE) plots confirmed the performance of DR-NCC algorithm to produce corrected CBCT images with lowest values of MAE even in regions where the misalignment is more pronounced. It was also found that the used method had successfully improved the spatial uniformity in the CBCT images by reducing the root mean squared difference (RMSD) between the pCT and CBCT in fat and muscle from 57 and 25 HU to 8HU, respectively. CONCLUSION: The choice of an accurate DR algorithm before performing the HM leads to an accurate correction of CBCT images. The results suggest that applying DR process based on NCC similarity metric reduces significantly the uncertainties in CBCT images and generates images in good agreement with pCT.
引用
- Kidar HS, Azizi H. Assessing the impact of choosing different deformable registration algorithms on cone-beam CT enhancement by histogram matching. Radiat Oncol. 2018. PMID: 30404657. doi:10.1186/s13014-018-1162-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。