使用新型咀嚼肌图谱减少头颈部放疗勾画中的观察者间差异
本研究评估新型勾画图谱能否减少咀嚼肌勾画的观察者间差异。七名临床医生对5例患者的5对结构分别在不使用和使用图谱时进行勾画,比较DSC、平均DTA和COM差异。图谱降低了所有结构的观察者间差异,平均DTA在翼内肌、咬肌、颞肌和颞下颌关节显著改善,作者认为该图谱可作为教育工具。
要点
- 图谱降低了所有咀嚼肌结构的观察者间差异。
- 使用图谱后翼内肌、咬肌、颞肌和颞下颌关节的平均DTA显著改善。
- 作者认为该图谱可作为教育工具使用。
核心结论
- 作者认为,用于头颈部放疗计划中咀嚼肌勾画的新图谱可减少观察者间差异,并可作为教育工具。
研究设计与样本
- 七名临床医生对5例患者的CT扫描分别在不使用图谱时勾画5对结构,间隔≥5周后再使用图谱重复勾画,以同一批5份CT扫描上临床医生生成的勾画作为参考进行比较。
- 比较指标为DSC、平均DTA和COM差异,并按培训等级分层比较,测量均值和标准差(SD)。
主要发现
- 图谱降低了所有结构的观察者间差异。
- 平均DTA在翼内肌(p=0.01)、咬肌(p<0.01)、颞肌(p<0.01)和颞下颌关节(p<0.01)显著改善。
- 受训者使用图谱后所有肌肉的平均DTA均改善,其中颞肌(4.3±7.1 mm 对比 1.2±0.4 mm,p=0.06)和颞下颌关节(2.1±0.7 mm 对比 0.8±0.3 mm,p<0.01)的变异性降低幅度最大。
- 翼内肌和颞肌的COM距离及观察者间差异在所有方向上均降低。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE(S): Trismus is caused by injury to the masticatory muscles resulting from cancer or its treatment. Contouring these muscles to reduce dose and radiation related trismus can be problematic due to interobserver variability. This study aimed to evaluate the reduction in interobserver variability achievable with a new contouring atlas. MATERIALS/METHODS: The atlas included: medial and lateral pterygoids (MP, LP), masseter (M) and temporalis (T) muscles, and the temporo-mandibular joint (TMJ). Seven clinicians delineated five paired structures on CT scans from 5 patients without the atlas. After ≥5 weeks, contouring was repeated using the atlas. Using contours generated by the clinicians on the same 5 CT scans as reference, dice similarity coefficient (DSC), mean distance-to-agreement (DTA) and centre of mass (COM) difference were compared with and without the atlas. Comparison was also performed split by training grade. Mean and standard deviation (SD) values were measured. RESULTS: The atlas reduced interobserver variability for all structures. Mean DTA significantly improved for MP (p = 0.01), M (p < 0.01), T (p < 0.01) and TMJ (p < 0.01). Mean DTA improved using the atlas for the trainees across all muscles, with the largest reduction in variability observed for the T (4.3 ± 7.1 v 1.2 ± 0.4 mm, p = 0.06) and TMJ (2.1 ± 0.7 v 0.8 ± 0.3 mm, p < 0.01). Distance between the COM and interobserver variability reduced in all directions for MP and T. CONCLUSION: A new atlas for contouring masticatory muscles during radiotherapy planning for head and neck cancer reduces interobserver variability and could be used as an educational tool.
引用
- Hague C, Beasley W, Dixon L, et al. Use of a novel atlas for muscles of mastication to reduce inter observer variability in head and neck radiotherapy contouring. Radiother Oncol. 2018. PMID: 30420234. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2018.10.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。