模拟教学不仅是治疗计划工具:放射肿瘤学模拟医学教育文献的系统综述
本系统综述遵循PRISMA指南,检索PubMed、MedEdPORTAL及在印文章,纳入1990年1月1日后发表的英文同行评议文献,最终纳入54篇放射肿瘤学模拟医学教育(SBME)文献。仅9/54篇(17%)自我标识为SBME;SBME类型以屏幕模拟器(56%)为主,技能覆盖以勾画(54%)最多,目标学习人群以住院医师(53%)为主。作者认为该综述为未来放射肿瘤学SBME发展提供背景与指导。
要点
- 54篇符合纳入标准的SBME文献中仅9篇(17%)自我标识为SBME。
- SBME类型以屏幕模拟器(56%)最常见,模拟环境、虚拟现实与触觉系统各占13%。
- 技能覆盖以勾画(54%)最多,治疗计划(20%)、临床决策(17%)次之。
核心结论
- 该综述为未来放射肿瘤学SBME发展提供背景与指导。
- 在放射肿瘤学文献中恰当框架化SBME报告将促进SBME干预的开发、实施与评价。
- SBME资源应集中化以促进传播与资源共享。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,遵循PRISMA指南,按PICOS框架确定纳入标准。
- 人群包括本科、毕业后及继续医学教育学习者,限1990年1月1日后发表的英文同行评议文献。
- 检索PubMed、MedEdPORTAL及在印文章,共54篇SBME文献符合纳入标准。
主要发现
- 54篇中仅9篇(17%)自我标识为SBME。
- SBME类型包括屏幕模拟器(56%)、模拟环境(13%)、虚拟现实与触觉系统(13%)、模拟患者(11%)、部分任务训练器(6%)、计算机系统与人体模型(2%)。
- 技能覆盖包括勾画(54%)、治疗计划(20%)、临床决策(17%)、解剖和/或放射学(13%)、放射生物学和/或物理学(13%)、沟通技能和/或患者教育(13%)、近距离治疗(13%)、体位固定(11%)。
- 47项研究定义了目标学习人群,包括住院医师(53%)、主治医师(36%)、医学生(21%)、医学物理师(11%)、放射治疗师(9%)、护士(6%)、行政人员(4%)、剂量师(4%)。
- 32项研究报告了学习者反馈。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Simulation-based medical education (SBME) is gaining prominence as a tool to meet Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education-mandated competency-based assessment educational goals. SBME is used in radiation oncology, although the type and extent are not clear. This study reports a systematic literature review designed to clarify the type and extent of radiation oncology SBME. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The systematic review focused on radiation oncology SBME literature. The methods followed Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. The inclusion criteria were identified according to the PICOS (population, intervention, comparison, outcome, and setting) framework. The population included undergraduate, graduate, and continuing medical education learners. Studies were limited to English-language studies published on or after January 1, 1990, in peer-reviewed journals. PubMed, MedEdPORTAL, and in-press articles were searched. The PubMed search was conducted using predefined search terms. References and similar articles were examined. Medical Subject Headings terms in selected articles were reviewed to ensure relevant terms were included. RESULTS: Fifty-four SBME publications met the inclusion criteria. Only 9 of 54 studies (17%) self-identified as SBME. SBME types included screen-based simulators (56%), simulated environments (13%), virtual reality and haptic systems (13%), simulated patients (11%), part-task trainers (6%), and computer-based systems with mannequins (2%). A variety of radiation oncology skill sets were addressed, including contouring (54%), treatment planning (20%), clinical decision making (17%), anatomy and/or radiology (13%), radiation biology and/or physics (13%), communication skills and/or patient education (13%), brachytherapy (13%), and immobilization (11%). A target learning population was defined in 47 studies, including residents (53%), attending physicians (36%), medical students (21%), medical physicists (11%), radiation therapists (9%), nurses (6%), administrative staff (4%), and dosimetrists (4%). Learner feedback was reported in 32 studies. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, this systematic literature review provides context and guidance for future radiation oncology SBME development. Appropriately framing SBME reports in the radiation oncology literature will facilitate development, implementation, and evaluation of SBME interventions. SBME resources should be centralized to facilitate dissemination and share resources.
引用
- Rooney MK, Zhu F, Gillespie EF, et al. Simulation as More Than a Treatment-Planning Tool: A Systematic Review of the Literature on Radiation Oncology Simulation-Based Medical Education. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2018. PMID: 30191859. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2018.05.064
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。