脑转移瘤切除术后立体定向放射外科治疗后的局部复发模式:指导靶区勾画的定量分析
该研究评估了173例脑转移瘤患者接受手术及瘤腔立体定向放射外科(SRS)治疗后的局部失败模式。原SRS靶区与复发肿瘤的中位重叠为69.6%,包含整个术前肿瘤后增至76.8%。结论提示SRS靶区均匀外扩3 mm可大幅提高对后续复发肿瘤体积的覆盖,可能改善局部控制。
要点
- 原SRS靶区与复发肿瘤中位重叠69.6%,包含整个术前肿瘤后为76.8%。
- 复发肿瘤较对应术前肿瘤更靠近脑膜(P = .03)。
- 靶区均匀外扩中位2.8 mm可覆盖90%的复发肿瘤。
核心结论
- 定量分析提示SRS靶区均匀外扩3 mm可大幅增加对后续复发肿瘤体积的覆盖,可能改善局部控制。
- 将术前肿瘤范围纳入靶区或从脑膜向外扩展靶区获益有限。
研究设计与样本
- 评估接受手术及瘤腔SRS治疗的脑转移瘤患者,局部失败定义为病理确认或磁共振成像证据显示进展并导致进一步重叠放疗。
- 将术前及复发时T1钆增强磁共振成像与模拟CT配准,比较三个体积:术前肿瘤、原勾画为SRS临床靶区的切除腔、复发肿瘤。
- 采用重叠体积直方图量化三个体积与脑膜的接近程度。
主要发现
- 173例患者中18例在19个切除腔出现局部失败。
- 原SRS靶区与复发肿瘤的中位重叠为69.6%,包含整个术前肿瘤后中位重叠增至76.8%。
- 复发肿瘤较对应术前肿瘤更靠近脑膜(P = .03),但需从脑膜外扩中位8.2 mm才能使与复发肿瘤的重叠增至90%。
- 均匀外扩勾画的切除腔最有效增加与复发肿瘤的重叠,中位外扩2.8 mm覆盖90%的复发肿瘤。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为SRS靶区均匀外扩3 mm可能大幅增加对后续复发肿瘤体积的覆盖并可能改善局部控制。
- 作者认为将术前肿瘤范围纳入靶区或从脑膜向外扩展靶区获益有限。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: In the treatment of resected metastatic brain disease, a recent phase 3 trial by the North Central Cancer Treatment Group (N107C/CEC.3) surprisingly found that the local control rate for whole-brain radiation therapy was better than that of stereotactic radiation surgery (SRS). To optimize target delineation, we performed a quantitative analysis of local failure patterns after postoperative SRS. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Patients with brain metastases who were treated with surgery and SRS to the cavity were evaluated. Local failure was defined by pathologic confirmation or magnetic resonance imaging evidence of progression leading to further overlapping radiation therapy. T1 postgadolinium magnetic resonance imaging scans that were taken preoperatively and at recurrence were co-registered to the simulation computed tomography. Three volumes were compared: (1) Preoperative tumors, (2) resection cavities that were originally contoured as clinical target volumes for SRS, and (3) recurrent tumors. Overlap volume histograms quantified the proximity of the three volumes to the meninges. RESULTS: In the cohort of 173 patients, 18 patients experienced local failure in 19 resection cavities. The original SRS target volume overlapped with a median of 69.6% of the recurrent tumor. When the entire preoperative tumor was included, the overlap with the recurrent tumor increased to a median of 76.8%. Recurrent tumors were closer to the meninges than corresponding preoperative tumors (P = .03) but a median 8.2 mm expansion of the target volume from the meninges was needed to increase overlap with the recurrent tumor to 90%. Increases in overlap with the recurrent tumor were achieved most efficiently by uniformly expanding the contoured cavity and a median 2.8 mm expansion covered 90% of the recurrent tumor. CONCLUSIONS: Our quantitative analysis of recurrence patterns suggests that a larger 3 mm uniform expansion of the SRS target volume substantially increases coverage of the volume that is later occupied by the recurrent tumor and may provide improved local control. The extent of the preoperative tumor in the target volume or expanding the target volume from the meninges provides little benefit.
引用
- Gui C, Moore J, Grimm J, et al. Local recurrence patterns after postoperative stereotactic radiation surgery to resected brain metastases: A quantitative analysis to guide target delineation. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2018. PMID: 30029965. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2018.04.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。