磁共振成像对立体定向体部放疗治疗非脊柱骨转移瘤大体肿瘤体积勾画的影响
本研究在本机构选取10例接受SBRT的非脊柱骨转移瘤病例,由6名SBRT放疗肿瘤科医生和1名诊断放射科医生在计划CT上勾画GTV,至少3个月后在CT融合MRI T1及T2序列上重新勾画。融合MRI T1后放疗肿瘤科医生间κ一致性及Dice系数较单纯CT显著提高,且放疗肿瘤科医生与诊断放射科医生之间的Dice一致性也显著提高;增加MRI T2序列未带来进一步显著改善。
要点
- 融合MRI T1使放疗肿瘤科医生间GTV勾画κ一致性由0.6129升至0.7045(P = .042)。
- 融合MRI T1使放疗肿瘤科医生间平均Dice系数由0.7047升至0.7628(P < .001)。
- 放疗肿瘤科医生与诊断放射科医生间Dice一致性在单纯CT时最低(0.6887),融合MRI T1后升至0.7398(P = .003)。
核心结论
- 将MRI T1图像融合至CT可显著降低放疗肿瘤科医生勾画非脊柱骨转移瘤时的观察者间变异,并提高放疗肿瘤科医生与诊断放射科医生所勾画GTV之间的一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究在本机构选取10例接受SBRT治疗的非脊柱骨转移瘤病例,由6名SBRT放疗肿瘤科医生和1名诊断放射科医生在治疗计划CT上勾画GTV。
- 至少3个月后,每例在CT融合MRI T1序列、继而融合MRI T2序列上重新勾画;由放疗肿瘤科医生勾画的体积生成STAPLE共识轮廓,采用κ一致性和Dice系数评估观察者间变异。
主要发现
- 共分析三个数据集(CT、CT+MRI T1、CT+MRI T1+MRI T2)中的180个放疗肿瘤科医生勾画轮廓,平均GTV为16.95 cm3(范围0.12-269.6 cm3)。
- 放疗肿瘤科医生κ一致性在单纯CT为0.6129,在CT+MRI T1显著升至0.7045(P = .042),在CT+MRI T1+MRI T2为0.7017(P = .048)。
- 平均Dice系数在单纯CT为0.7047,在CT+MRI T1显著升至0.7628(P < .001),在CT+MRI T1+MRI T2为0.7544(P = .001)。
- 比较CT+MRI T1与CT+MRI T1+MRI T2数据集时,放疗肿瘤科医生κ一致性(P = .948)或平均Dice系数(P = .573)均无统计学差异。
- 诊断放射科医生与放疗肿瘤科医生体积之间的Dice一致性在单纯CT数据集最低(0.6887),在CT+MRI T1数据集显著升至0.7398(P = .003),在CT+MRI T1+MRI T2数据集为0.7342(P = .008)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: This study investigates the inter-observer variability of contouring non-spine bone metastases using the planning CT alone vs. the addition of MRI T1 and T2 imaging sequences. METHODS AND MATERIALS: 10 cases of non-spine bone metastases treated with SBRT at our institution were selected. The gross tumor volume (GTV) for each case was delineated by six SBRT radiation oncologists (RO) and one diagnostic radiologist (DR) on the treatment planning CT. After a minimum of three months, each case was re-contoured on the CT fused with a MRI T1 sequence followed by a MRI T2 sequence. STAPLE consensus contours were created from the RO volumes and inter-observer variability was measured using both κ agreement and the Dice coefficient (DSC). RESULTS: In total, 180 RO contours were analyzed within three datasets (CT, CT + MRI T1 and CT + MRI T1 + MRI T2). The mean GTV was 16.95 cm3 (range, 0.12-269.6 cm3). The RO κ agreement was 0.6129 based on CT alone, and significantly increased to 0.7045 in the CT + MRI T1 (P = .042) dataset and 0.7017 in the CT + MRI T1 + MRI T2 dataset (P = .048). The mean DSC in the CT alone dataset was 0.7047, and significantly increased to 0.7628 in the CT + MRI T1 dataset (P < .001) and 0.7544 in the CT + MRI T1 + MRI T2 dataset (P = .001). There were no statistical differences in RO κ agreement (P = .948) or mean DSC (P = .573) when comparing the CT + MRI T1 and CT + MRI T1 + MRI T2 datasets. The DSC agreement between DR and RO volumes was lowest (0.6887) in the CT alone dataset and significantly increased to 0.7398 in the CT + MRI T1 dataset (P = .003) and 0.7342 in the CT + MRI T1 + MRI T2 dataset (P = .008). CONCLUSIONS: The fusion of MRI T1 images to CT significantly reduced inter-observer variability amongst RO's in delineating non-spine bone metastases, and improved agreement between GTVs delineated by the RO to the DR.
引用
- Raman S, Chin L, Erler D, et al. Impact of Magnetic Resonance Imaging on Gross Tumor Volume Delineation in Non-spine Bony Metastasis Treated With Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2018. PMID: 29748100. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2018.03.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。