多中心放疗试验中基于多参数MRI的前列腺肿瘤勾画:临床勾画评估
该研究分析多中心III期FLAME试验中3家机构260例患者基于多参数MRI的前列腺癌临床勾画,用逻辑回归评估各机构对T2w、ADC和Ktrans的权重差异,并以肿瘤概率模型与临床勾画的AUC分析筛选差异病例。结果显示各机构对mp-MRI解读存在明显差异,ADC和Ktrans的回归系数在机构间有显著差异,AUC中位值为0.92、0.80和0.79,提示需要勾画指南,且AUC可高效识别离群勾画供复核。
要点
- 3家机构260例患者的临床勾画显示对mp-MRI解读存在机构间差异。
- ADC和Ktrans的回归系数在机构间有显著差异,T2w无显著差异。
- AUC分析中位值为0.92、0.80和0.79,可高效识别离群勾画供复核。
核心结论
- 回归系数显示各机构对mp-MRI在前列腺肿瘤勾画中的解读存在相当大差异,表明需要勾画指南。
- 基于AUC值可高效识别离群勾画以供复核。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心III期FLAME试验中3家机构260例患者的临床勾画与临床特征分析。
- 采用逻辑回归分析各机构在勾画肿瘤时对T2w、ADC和Ktrans强度图的权重。
- 基于已发表的肿瘤概率(TP)模型与各机构临床勾画之间的差异,用ROC曲线下面积(AUC)分析筛选病例供专家复核。
主要发现
- 3家机构的回归系数:T2w为-0.07、-0.27和-0.11,ADC为-1.96、-0.53和-0.65,Ktrans为0.15、0.20和0.62。
- ADC和Ktrans的回归系数在机构间有显著差异。
- AUC分析显示中位AUC值为0.92、0.80和0.79。
- AUC值最低的5例患者由泌尿放射科医生复核。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To date no guidelines are available for contouring prostate cancer inside the gland, as visible on multiparametric (mp-) MRI. We assessed inter-institutional differences in interpretation of mp-MRI in the multicenter phase III FLAME trial. METHODS: We analyzed clinical delineations on mp-MRI and clinical characteristics from 260 patients across three institutes. We performed a logistic regression analysis to examine each institute's weighting of T2w, ADC and Ktrans intensity maps in the delineation of the cancer. As reviewing of all delineations by an expert panel is not feasible, we made a selection based on discrepancies between a published tumor probability (TP) model and each institute's clinical delineations using Areas Under the ROC Curve (AUC) analysis. RESULTS: Regression coefficients for the three institutes were -0.07, -0.27 and -0.11 for T2w, -1.96, -0.53 and -0.65 for ADC and 0.15, 0.20 and 0.62 for Ktrans, with significant differences between institutes for ADC and Ktrans. AUC analysis showed median AUC values of 0.92, 0.80 and 0.79. Five patients with lowest AUC values were reviewed by a uroradiologist. CONCLUSION: Regression coefficients revealed considerably different interpretations of mp-MRI in tumor contouring between institutes and demonstrated the need for contouring guidelines. Based on AUC values outlying delineations could efficiently be identified for review.
引用
- van Schie MA, Dinh CV, Houdt PJV, et al. Contouring of prostate tumors on multiparametric MRI: Evaluation of clinical delineations in a multicenter radiotherapy trial. Radiother Oncol. 2018. PMID: 29731160. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2018.04.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。