接受放射治疗的头颈癌患者吞咽困难的治疗:一项Meta分析综述
该系统综述检索7个电子数据库至2017年7月12日,纳入20项研究(其中12项为随机对照试验),评估行为性吞咽干预对接受根治性放化疗的头颈癌患者吞咽生理、功能及生活质量的影响;Meta分析显示早期和晚期开始的干预在生理或功能方面有获益,但生活质量无获益,未来需高质量试验明确最佳干预时间、类型和强度。
要点
- 纳入20项研究(12项随机对照试验),吞咽干预类型和开始时间各异,早期(放化疗前或期间)14项,放化疗后立即1项,放化疗后超过3个月5项。
- Meta分析显示早期和晚期开始的干预在生理或功能方面有获益,但生活质量无获益。
- 所有文章均存在偏倚风险,最常见缺乏样本量计算报告(18项)、组间临床医生-参与者互动时间控制(13项)和治疗细节以允许重复(9项)。
核心结论
- 鉴于早期和晚期干预均显示获益,未来需要高质量试验来明确这些头颈癌患者行为性吞咽干预的最有效时间、类型和强度。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索7个电子数据库截至2017年7月12日,纳入任何语言或设计、包含行为性吞咽干预、对照组及吞咽生理、功能和/或生活质量结局的原始研究,由两名盲法评价者判断摘要和全文,分歧由第三名评价者解决,使用Cochrane偏倚风险评估工具进行批判性评价。
- 共检索到1937篇独特摘要,20项研究符合条件,其中12项为随机对照试验。
主要发现
- 吞咽困难治疗按运动类型和开始时间不同:放化疗前或期间开始 n=14;放化疗后立即开始 n=1;放化疗后超过3个月开始 n=5。
- 治疗后结局测量按领域、工具和随访计划不同:治疗后立即 n=6;治疗后3个月内 n=9;治疗后超过3个月 n=12。
- 所有文章均存在偏倚风险,最常见缺乏样本量计算报告(n=18)、组间临床医生-参与者互动时间控制(n=13)和治疗细节以允许重复(n=9)。
- Meta分析显示早期和晚期开始的干预在生理或功能方面有获益,但生活质量无获益。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 所有文章均存在偏倚风险,最常见缺乏样本量计算报告(n=18)、组间临床医生-参与者互动时间控制(n=13)和治疗细节以允许重复(n=9)。
- 未来需要高质量试验来明确最有效的时间、类型和强度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Patients undergoing radiation therapy with or without chemotherapy (C/RT) for head and neck cancer (HNC) often develop dysphagia. Interventions from speech-language pathologists aim to maintain or improve swallow physiology and function. However, it is unclear which interventions provide the greatest benefit. We performed a systematic review to assess the benefit of exercise therapy on swallow physiology, function, and related quality of life (QOL). METHODS AND MATERIALS: We searched 7 electronic databases up to July 12, 2017, for all primary studies of any language or design that included the following: a behavioral swallowing intervention for patients with HNC treated with curative C/RT, a comparison group, and outcomes related to swallow physiology, function, and/or QOL. Two blinded raters judged the abstracts and full articles, with discrepancies resolved by a third rater. Critical appraisal was completed using the Cochrane Risk of Bias. Descriptive analyses were conducted for all outcomes and meta-analyses for outcomes that were identical in type and time relative to C/RT. RESULTS: Of 1937 unique abstracts retrieved, 20 studies qualified. Of these, 12 were randomized controlled trials. Across the studies, dysphagia treatments varied by exercise type and start time (ie, before or during C/RT, n = 14; immediately after C/RT, n = 1; >3 months after C/RT, n = 5). After treatment, the outcomes measured varied by domain, tools, and follow-up schedule (ie, immediately after, n = 6; within 3 months after, n = 9, >3 months after, n = 12). All articles had risks of bias and most often lacked report of sample size calculations (n = 18), controlled clinician-participant interaction time across groups (n = 13), and treatment details to allow duplication (n = 9). The meta-analysis revealed physiological or functional, but not QOL, benefits after interventions with early and late start times. CONCLUSIONS: Given that benefit was identified with both early and late interventions, future high-quality trials are needed to clarify the most effective time, type, and intensity of behavioral dysphagia interventions for these HNC patients.
引用
- Greco E, Simic T, Ringash J, et al. Dysphagia Treatment for Patients With Head and Neck Cancer Undergoing Radiation Therapy: A Meta-analysis Review. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2018. PMID: 29726363. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2018.01.097
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。