多机构前列腺癌VMAT知识库计划模型评估
本研究在多个放疗科室评估商用知识库计划系统在前列腺癌容积旋转调强放疗中的表现,每个机构评估超过20例。知识库计划与人工优化计划在危及器官和PTV剂量学上无显著差异,但不同机构间V90和V50体积比差异分别超过5.0%和10.0%。模型中的估计剂量上下限与OAR与PTV重叠体积占整个器官体积的比例密切相关,共享模型前需确认其与不同机构计划设计匹配。
要点
- 知识库计划与人工优化计划在前列腺癌VMAT中剂量学无显著差异。
- 不同机构间知识库计划的V90和V50体积比差异分别超过5.0%和10.0%。
- 模型估计剂量上下限与OAR重叠体积比例相关,共享模型前需验证匹配性。
核心结论
- 模型中的危及器官估计剂量上下限与OAR重叠体积比例密切相关,共享知识库计划模型前需确认其与不同机构计划设计匹配。
研究设计与样本
- 多机构评估研究,每个机构评估超过20例前列腺癌VMAT病例,比较知识库计划与人工优化计划,并分析估计剂量与OAR重叠体积比例的关系。
主要发现
- 人工优化计划与知识库计划在危及器官和PTV剂量学上无显著差异。
- 知识库计划中,机构间处方剂量90%和50%体积比(V90和V50)差异分别超过5.0%和10.0%。
- 知识库计划计算剂量位于估计剂量上下限之间或略低于下限。
- 直肠Voverlap/Vwhole为10%时,机构间估计剂量下限的V90和V50最大差异分别为8.2%和53.5%。
- 膀胱Voverlap/Vwhole为10%时,机构间估计剂量下限的V90和V50最大差异分别为15.1%和33.1%。
临床怎么用
- 不同机构共享知识库计划模型前,应验证模型是否匹配本机构的计划设计。
- 关注模型估计剂量上下限与OAR重叠体积比例的关系,以评估模型适用性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to evaluate the performance of a commercial knowledge-based planning system, in volumetric modulated arc therapy for prostate cancer at multiple radiation therapy departments. METHODS: In each institute, > 20 cases were assessed. For the knowledge-based planning, the estimated dose (ED) based on geometric and dosimetric information of plans was generated in the model. Lower and upper limits of estimated dose were saved as dose volume histograms for each organ at risk. To verify whether the models performed correctly, KBP was compared with manual optimization planning in two cases. The relationships between the EDs in the models and the ratio of the OAR volumes overlapping volume with PTV to the whole organ volume (Voverlap/Vwhole) were investigated. RESULTS: There were no significant dosimetric differences in OARs and PTV between manual optimization planning and knowledge-based planning. In knowledge-based planning, the difference in the volume ratio of receiving 90% and 50% of the prescribed dose (V90 and V50) between institutes were more than 5.0% and 10.0%, respectively. The calculated doses with knowledge-based planning were between the upper and lower limits of ED or slightly under the lower limit of ED. The relationships between the lower limit of ED and Voverlap/Vwhole were different among the models. In the V90 and V50 for the rectum, the maximum differences between the lower limit of ED among institutes were 8.2% and 53.5% when Voverlap/Vwhole for the rectum was 10%. In the V90 and V50 for the bladder, the maximum differences of the lower limit of ED among institutes were 15.1% and 33.1% when Voverlap/Vwhole for the bladder was 10%. CONCLUSION: Organs' upper and lower limits of ED in the models correlated closely with the Voverlap/Vwhole. It is important to determine whether the models in KBP match a different institute's plan design before the models can be shared.
引用
- Ueda Y, Fukunaga JI, Kamima T, et al. Evaluation of multiple institutions' models for knowledge-based planning of volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) for prostate cancer. Radiat Oncol. 2018. PMID: 29558940. doi:10.1186/s13014-018-0994-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。