文献速递消化道肿瘤放疗放疗物理与技术

食管癌放疗中基于隆突与基于骨性解剖配准的比较

Comparison of carina-based versus bony anatomy-based registration for setup verification in esophageal cancer radiotherapy.
PubMed 文献 · Radiat Oncol · 2018-03-21

本研究纳入24例食管癌患者共65枚植入标记物,评估CBCT引导下基于隆突配准的可行性与几何精度,并与现行骨性解剖配准比较。基于隆突配准在94.9%的CBCT扫描中可行,靶区覆盖充分率91.1%,低于骨性解剖配准的100%。基于隆突配准的系统误差和随机误差较大,仅中胸部肿瘤可能略优。

要点

  • 基于隆突配准在94.9%的CBCT中可行,靶区覆盖充分率91.1%
  • 骨性解剖配准靶区覆盖充分率为100%
  • 基于隆突配准的Σ和σ较大,需更大各向异性外扩边界

核心结论

  • 与骨性解剖配准相比,基于隆突配准在食管癌IGRT中出现8.9%的靶区覆盖不充分,且系统误差和随机误差较大,需更大各向异性外扩边界;仅完全局限于中胸部的肿瘤可能略优。

研究设计与样本

  • 纳入24例食管癌患者共65枚植入标记物,所有236次CBCT扫描分别与计划CT进行基于骨性解剖和基于隆突的刚性配准,量化标记物位置变化并估计系统误差(Σ)和随机误差(σ)。

主要发现

  • 基于隆突的自动配准在94.9%的CBCT扫描中可行,靶区覆盖充分率为91.1%,而骨性解剖配准为100%。
  • 骨性解剖配准的Σ(σ)在LR/CC/AP方向分别为2.9(2.4)/4.1(2.4)/2.2(1.8)mm,隆突配准分别为3.3(3.0)/3.6(2.6)/3.9(3.1)mm。
  • 中胸部放置的标记物在使用隆突配准时,CC和AP方向的Σ较小,但差异无统计学意义。

临床怎么用

  • 食管癌IGRT中不推荐常规使用基于隆突配准替代骨性解剖配准。
  • 若考虑隆突配准,需注意靶区覆盖不充分风险及更大各向异性外扩边界的需求。
  • 仅对完全局限于中胸部的肿瘤,可谨慎评估隆突配准的潜在获益。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: To investigate the feasibility and geometric accuracy of carina-based registration for CBCT-guided setup verification in esophageal cancer IGRT, compared with current practice bony anatomy-based registration. METHODS: Included were 24 esophageal cancer patients with 65 implanted fiducial markers, visible on planning CTs and follow-up CBCTs. All available CBCT scans (n = 236) were rigidly registered to the planning CT with respect to the bony anatomy and the carina. Target coverage was visually inspected and marker position variation was quantified relative to both registration approaches; the variation of systematic (Σ) and random errors (σ) was estimated. RESULTS: Automatic carina-based registration was feasible in 94.9% of the CBCT scans, with an adequate target coverage in 91.1% compared to 100% after bony anatomy-based registration. Overall, Σ (σ) in the LR/CC/AP direction was 2.9(2.4)/4.1(2.4)/2.2(1.8) mm using the bony anatomy registration compared to 3.3(3.0)/3.6(2.6)/3.9(3.1) mm for the carina. Mid-thoracic placed markers showed a non-significant but smaller Σ in CC and AP direction when using the carina-based registration. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with a bony anatomy-based registration, carina-based registration for esophageal cancer IGRT results in inadequate target coverage in 8.9% of cases. Furthermore, large Σ and σ, requiring larger anisotropic margins, were seen after carina-based registration. Only for tumors entirely confined to the mid-thoracic region the carina-based registration might be slightly favorable.

来源:Radiat Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Machiels M, Jin P, van Gurp CH, et al. Comparison of carina-based versus bony anatomy-based registration for setup verification in esophageal cancer radiotherapy. Radiat Oncol. 2018. PMID: 29562919. doi:10.1186/s13014-018-0986-1

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。