不同四维CT重建图像上肺癌原发灶与淋巴结勾画的观察者间差异
研究比较了七名放疗医生在10例肺癌患者的MIP、Mid-V和Mid-P三种4DCT重建图像上勾画原发肿瘤(GTVp)和淋巴结(GTVln)的观察者间变异。结果显示MIP上勾画的总体平均体积显著更大(p<0.001);GTVp在Mid-P上观察者间变异最低(SD=0.261 cm),GTVln在Mid-V上最低(SD=0.425 cm)。结论认为Mid-P降低了GTVp的观察者间变异,但需改进勾画协议以利用Mid-P对GTVln的改善。
要点
- MIP上勾画的总体平均体积显著大于Mid-V和Mid-P(p<0.001)。
- GTVp在Mid-P上观察者间变异最低(SD=0.261 cm),优于Mid-V和MIP。
- GTVln在Mid-V上观察者间变异最低(SD=0.425 cm),Mid-P最高。
核心结论
- Mid-P降低了GTVp的观察者间变异,但GTVln的勾画协议仍需改进以受益于Mid-P的图像质量。
研究设计与样本
- 七名放疗医生在10例肺癌患者的MIP、Mid-V和Mid-P三种4DCT重建图像上勾画GTVp和GTVln,比较体积、平均标准差(SD)及SD/面积分布。
主要发现
- MIP上总体平均勾画体积显著大于Mid-V和Mid-P(p<0.001)。
- GTVp的观察者间变异:Mid-P(SD=0.261 cm)< Mid-V(SD=0.314 cm)< MIP(SD=0.330 cm)。
- GTVln的观察者间变异:Mid-V(SD=0.425 cm)< MIP(SD=0.477 cm)< Mid-P(SD=0.543 cm)。
- GTVp和GTVln的SD/面积分布在MIP与Mid-P之间、Mid-P与Mid-V之间均有统计学显著差异(p<0.001),离群值提示靠近纵隔的GTVp和GTVln存在判读差异。
临床怎么用
- 对于肺癌原发灶勾画,可优先考虑Mid-P重建以降低观察者间变异。
- 淋巴结勾画仍需依赖改进的勾画协议,不能仅靠Mid-P图像质量提升。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: The study compared interobserver variation in the delineation of the primary tumour (GTVp) and lymph nodes (GTVln) between three different 4DCT reconstruction types; Maximum Intensity Projection (MIP), Mid-Ventilation (Mid-V) and Mid-Position (Mid-P). MATERIAL AND METHODS: Seven radiation oncologists delineated the GTVp and GTVln on the MIP, Mid-V and Mid-P 4DCT image reconstructions of 10 lung cancer patients. The volumes, the mean standard deviation (SD) and distribution of SD (SD/area) over the median surface contour were compared for different tumour regions. RESULTS: The overall mean delineated volume on the MIP was significantly larger (p < 0.001) than the Mid-V and Mid-P. For the GTVp the Mid-P had the lowest interobserver variation (SD = 0.261 cm), followed by Mid-V (SD = 0.314 cm) and MIP (SD = 0.330 cm) For GTVln the Mid-V had the lowest interobserver variation (SD = 0.425 cm) followed by the MIP (SD = 0.477 cm) and Mid-P (SD = 0.543 cm). The SD/area distribution showed a statistically significant difference between the MIP versus Mid-P and Mid-P versus Mid-V for both GTVp and GTVln (p < 0.001), with outliers indicating interpretation differences for GTVp located close to the mediastinum and GTVln. CONCLUSION: The Mid-P reduced the interobserver variation for the GTVp. Delineation protocols must be improved to benefit from the improved image quality of Mid-P for the GTVln.
引用
- Mercieca S, Belderbos JSA, De Jaeger K, et al. Interobserver variability in the delineation of the primary lung cancer and lymph nodes on different four-dimensional computed tomography reconstructions. Radiother Oncol. 2017. PMID: 29208512. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2017.11.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。