减少低危前列腺癌患者骨扫描的质量改进干预:前后对照研究
在退伍军人事务医院开展质量改进干预,利用社会比较和规范呼吁向放疗与泌尿科多学科人员展示同行骨扫描率及指南推荐。
要点
- 干预前低危前列腺癌患者骨扫描率为86.5%(32/37),远高于同期同行约30%的水平。
- 所有回顾的指南均不推荐对低危前列腺癌患者进行骨扫描。
核心结论
- 质量改进干预后,与指南不一致的骨扫描率出现适度下降。
- 结合社会比较与专业规范呼吁的干预措施可能影响骨扫描率。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为在退伍军人事务医院开展的质量改进干预,采用准实验、非对照、前后对照设计。
- 干预对象为放疗科与泌尿科的多学科相关人员,干预形式为利用社会比较和规范呼吁的演示。
- 基线骨扫描率通过回顾性分析无症状新诊断低危前列腺癌病例确定。
主要发现
- 干预前1年期间,37例低危前列腺癌患者中32例(86.5%)接受了骨扫描。
- 同期同行骨扫描率约为30%。
关键数值与推荐
- 所有回顾的专业团体指南均推荐不对低危前列腺癌患者进行骨扫描。
临床怎么用
- 可向多学科团队展示同行骨扫描率及指南推荐,以促进低价值检查的减少。
局限性
- 研究为非对照的前后对照设计,未设同期对照组。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Bone scans (BS) are a low-value test for asymptomatic men with low-risk prostate cancer. We performed a quality improvement intervention aimed at reducing BS for these patients. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The intervention was a presentation that leveraged the behavioral science concepts of social comparison and normative appeals. Participants were multidisciplinary stakeholders from the Radiation Oncology and Urology services at a Veterans Affairs hospital. We determined the baseline rate of BS by retrospectively analyzing cases of asymptomatic men with newly diagnosed low-risk prostate cancer. For social comparison, we presented contemporary peer BS rates in the United States-including Veterans Affairs hospitals. For normative appeals, we reviewed guidelines from various professional groups. To analyze the effect of this intervention, we performed a quasi-experimental, uncontrolled, before-and-after study. RESULTS: During the 1-year period before the intervention, 32 of 37 patients with low-risk prostate cancer (86.5%) received a BS. The contemporary peer rate was approximately 30%. All reviewed guidelines recommended against BS. During the 1-year period after the intervention, the rate of BS was reduced to 65.5% (19 of 29 patients; P = .043 by one-sided Fisher's exact test). CONCLUSIONS: We observed a modest reduction in guideline-discordant BS after the quality improvement intervention. BS rates might be influenced by initiatives that combine social comparisons with appeals to professional norms.
引用
- Ojerholm E, Van Arsdalen KN, Roses RE, et al. Initiative to reduce bone scans for low-risk prostate cancer patients: A quasi-experimental before-and-after study in a Veterans Affairs hospital. Adv Radiat Oncol. 2017. PMID: 29114610. doi:10.1016/j.adro.2017.07.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。