术后乳腺癌放疗中手术夹与皮肤标记在线摆位验证的靶区覆盖比较
本研究在35例乳腺癌患者中比较手术夹与外部皮肤标记在线摆位验证的准确性,分析155个分次的锥形束CT。两种匹配方法的摆位差异平均<0.5 mm,靶区覆盖相似;23例外部验证显示摆位误差<2 mm。结论为手术夹验证可获得与皮肤标记相当的摆位校正和靶区覆盖,且可避免皮肤标记处急性皮肤毒性。
要点
- 手术夹与皮肤标记在线摆位验证的摆位差异各方向平均<0.5 mm。
- 两种匹配方法的靶区覆盖相似,手术夹验证外部验证摆位误差<2 mm。
- 省略皮肤标记可预防标记处急性皮肤毒性。
核心结论
- 手术夹在线摆位验证可获得与皮肤标记验证相当的摆位校正和靶区覆盖,且省略皮肤标记可预防标记处急性皮肤毒性。
研究设计与样本
- 35例乳腺癌患者每分次采集正交千伏图像,在线基于皮肤标记匹配得出三维摆位误差,回顾性用手术夹重新匹配。
- 155个分次(每患者5-6分次)有锥形束CT可用,分析手术夹可见性、迁移、两种匹配方法的摆位误差及靶区覆盖。
- 外部验证在23例患者中分析治疗后采集的100个分次千伏图像。
主要发现
- 所有类型手术夹均可显影,手术夹至质心距离在治疗过程中平均减少2 mm(标准差1)。
- 两种匹配方法摆位差异各方向平均<0.5 mm。
- 计划CT与锥形束CT上,两种匹配方法的乳房和推量计划靶区接受95%或107%处方剂量的体积及平均剂量标准差相似。
- 23例外部验证显示摆位误差<2 mm。
临床怎么用
- 术后乳腺癌放疗可采用手术夹进行在线摆位验证,以获得与皮肤标记相当的靶区覆盖并避免标记处皮肤毒性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: After changing from offline setup verification to online setup verification using external skin markers in breast cancer patients, we noticed an increase in localized acute skin toxicity beneath the markers. Also, in vivo 3-dimensional dose measurements showed deviations between the delivered and the planned dose distributions; therefore, we investigated the accuracy of setup verification using surgical clips in the tumor bed, with a focus on target coverage of whole breast and tumor bed. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Orthogonal kilovoltage images were acquired before every fraction in 35 breast cancer patients, deriving an online 3-dimensional setup error by matching on external skin markers. In retrospect, a rematch was performed using surgical clips. For 155 fractions (ie, 5-6 fractions/patient), a cone beam computed tomography (CT) scan was available. Analysis concerned: (1) visibility of the clips, (2) migration of the clips, (3) comparison of setup errors according to both match methods, and (4) comparison of target coverage by recalculating the dose on the online setup-corrected cone beam CT scan with the patient setup according to both match methods. External validation of the surgical clip-based online setup verification was performed in 23 patients by analyzing kilovoltage images of 100 fractions, obtained after treatment. RESULTS: All types of surgical clips could be visualized. The clip to center-of-mass distance decreased on average by 2 mm (standard deviation, 1) over the course of treatment. Setup differences between match methods were on average <0.5 mm in all directions. The reconstructed dose distributions showed standard deviations of volumes receiving 95% or 107% of prescribed dose and mean dose of the breast and boost planning target volume were similar for the planning CT and the cone beam CTs, for both match procedures. An external validation in 23 patients showed reassuring setup errors <2 mm. CONCLUSIONS: Online setup verification using surgical clips results in comparable setup corrections and target volume coverage as verification using skin markers. By omitting skin markers acute skin toxicity beneath the markers is prevented.
引用
- van der Salm A, Murrer L, Steenbakkers I, et al. Actual target coverage after setup verification using surgical clips compared with external skin markers in postoperative breast cancer radiation therapy. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2017. PMID: 28666904. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2017.04.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。