文献速递头颈部肿瘤放疗放疗物理与技术

头颈肿瘤原发灶勾画:冰山一角是否被遗漏?

Primary tumor volume delineation in head and neck cancer: missing the tip of the iceberg?
PubMed 文献 · Radiat Oncol · 2017-06-20

本研究评估头颈部肿瘤邻近含气腔时两种勾画策略的几何与剂量学差异。14例口咽或喉肿瘤患者分别用软组织窗(S)和肺窗(L)勾画GTV/CTV。L窗与S窗勾画的中位三维Hausdorff距离GTV为5.7mm、CTV为9.3mm,Plan_S在13/14例满足CTV_L的验收标准,但8例CTV_Δ覆盖不足;OAR剂量差异在3%以内。作者认为当前实践中L窗勾画似无必要,但在小或零PTV边距的特殊情况下可能影响局部控制。

要点

  • L窗与S窗勾画的中位三维HD:GTV 5.7mm,CTV 9.3mm。
  • L窗与S窗中位体积差异GTV和CTV均为9%。
  • Plan_S在13/14例满足CTV_L验收标准,但8例CTV_Δ覆盖不足。

核心结论

  • 当前头颈放疗计划实践中L窗勾画似无必要,但在小或零PTV边距等特殊情况下可能影响局部控制。

研究设计与样本

  • 对14例口咽或喉肿瘤患者分别用软组织窗(S)和肺窗(L)勾画原发GTV和CTV。
  • 基于两种勾画分别生成目标和优化参数相同的Plan_S与Plan_L并比较剂量学。

主要发现

  • GTV和CTV的中位三维Hausdorff距离分别为5.7mm和9.3mm。
  • L窗与S窗勾画的中位体积差异GTV和CTV均为9%。
  • Plan_S在13/14例满足CTV_L的验收标准,但8例CTV_Δ覆盖不足。
  • Plan_S与Plan_L的OAR剂量体积直方图参数平均和中位差异在3%以内。

关键数值与推荐

  • GTV中位三维HD 5.7mm(±2.6),CTV中位三维HD 9.3mm(±2.8)。
  • GTV中位体积差异9%(±5%),CTV中位体积差异9%(±4%)。
  • Plan_S在13/14例满足CTV_L验收标准,8例CTV_Δ覆盖不足。
  • OAR剂量体积直方图参数差异在3%以内。

临床怎么用

  • 当前常规PTV边距下可继续以软组织窗勾画头颈原发肿瘤。
  • 使用小或零PTV边距时需评估肺窗补充勾画的必要性以保障局部控制。

局限性

  • 样本量仅14例口咽或喉肿瘤患者。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The aim was to evaluate the geometric and corresponding dosimetric differences between two delineation strategies for head and neck tumors neighboring air cavities. METHODS: Primary gross and clinical tumor volumes (GTV and CTV) of 14 patients with oropharynx or larynx tumors were contoured using a soft tissue window (S). In a second strategy, the same volumes were contoured with an extension to include the parts which became visible on lung window (L). For the calculation of Hausdorff-distances (HD) between contoured volumes of the two strategies, triangular meshes were exported. Two radiotherapy plans with identical goals and optimization parameters were generated for each case. Plan_S were optimized on CTV_S, and Plan_L on CTV_L. The dose coverages of CTV_L and CTV_Δ (CTV_L minus CTV_S) were evaluated in Plan_S. OAR doses were compared among Plan_S and Plan_L. RESULTS: Median three-dimensional HD for GTVs and CTVs were 5.7 (±2.6) and 9.3 (±2.8) mm, respectively. The median volume differences between structures contoured using L and S windows were 9% (±5%) and 9% (±4%) for GTV and CTV, respectively. In 13 out of 14 cases, Plan_S met the plan acceptance criteria for CTV_L. In 8 cases CTV_Δ was covered insufficiently in Plan_S. Mean and median differences in OAR dose-volume histogram parameters between Plan_S and Plan_L were within 3%. CONCLUSION: For the current practice in radiotherapy planning for head and neck cancer, the delineation of L-based volumes seems unnecessary. However, in special settings, where smaller or no PTV margins are used, this approach may play an important role for local control.

来源:Radiat Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Elicin O, Terribilini D, Shelan M, et al. Primary tumor volume delineation in head and neck cancer: missing the tip of the iceberg? Radiat Oncol. 2017. PMID: 28633674. doi:10.1186/s13014-017-0838-4

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。