两种经腹超声图像引导技术在前列腺及瘤床放疗中的比较
本研究在同一批41例患者(16例完整前列腺,25例前列腺瘤床)的1428次治疗分次中,直接比较了第一代2.5D经腹超声图像引导与新型全3D经腹超声图像引导的前列腺对准一致性。结果显示两种方法在左右、前后、头脚方向上的平均差异分别为0.4±0.7 mm、0.7±0.9 mm、0.5±0.9 mm,完整前列腺与瘤床患者间无显著差异,表明两种方法高度一致。
要点
- 两种经腹超声图像引导方法在前列腺对准上高度一致,平均差异均小于1 mm。
- 完整前列腺与前列腺瘤床患者之间,两种系统的对准一致性无显著差异。
- 结果表明经腹超声图像引导模态本身具有内部一致性。
核心结论
- 第一代2.5D与新型全3D经腹超声图像引导方法在前列腺对准上显示极好的一致性。
- 经腹超声图像引导模态在不同系统间结果一致,模态内部结果稳定。
研究设计与样本
- 在同批患者、同次治疗分次中直接比较两种经腹超声图像引导方法。
- 共分析41例患者(16例完整前列腺,25例前列腺瘤床)的1428次治疗分次。
- 患者先按纹身使用治疗室激光对准,再依次进行3D和2.5D超声对准并记录偏移差异。
主要发现
- 所有患者两种对准方法的平均差异在左右方向为0.4±0.7 mm。
- 前后方向平均差异为0.7±0.9 mm,头脚方向为0.5±0.9 mm。
- 完整前列腺与瘤床患者之间系统一致性无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 两种经腹超声图像引导方法可互换使用,对准结果高度一致。
- 临床可依据可用性选择2.5D或3D经腹超声系统进行前列腺对准。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Our clinic is a long-term user of a first-generation transabdominal (TA) biplanar (2.5-dimensional [2.5D]) ultrasound image guidance (USIG) system for prostate cancer treatments. We are also an early adopter and development partner for a new, second-generation, fully 3D USIG system that allows for volumetric TA localization of the prostate. This new system has been evaluated at our institution by direct comparison with the previously established first-generation TA method for prostate alignment. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We compared the 2 TA-USIG methods on the same subjects and same treatment sessions. A total of 1428 fractions delivered to 41 treated patients (16 intact prostate, 25 fossa) were analyzed regarding the agreement of alignments between the 2 US positioning systems. Patients were first aligned to tattoos using treatment room lasers. TA-USIG using the 3D system was then performed to align contours derived during the computed tomography simulation process to their corresponding daily US-visualized structures. The US-3D system image guidance shifts were performed and recorded as the "initial" shifts. A 2.5D system alignment was then immediately performed using the same computed tomography derived reference contours and the indicated shifts, relative to the 3D system, were recorded as the difference between the 2 alignment methods. RESULTS: The average difference between the 2 TA-USIG alignments for all patients was 0.4 ± 0.7 mm, 0.7 ± 0.9 mm, and 0.5 ± 0.9 mm in the left-right, anteroposterior, and superoinferior directions, respectively. No significant difference in system agreement between intact prostate versus fossa patients was observed. CONCLUSION: Our comparison of an established 2.5D USIG method with a newer, fully 3D approach for prostate alignment of 41 different patients (1428 fractions) shows excellent agreement with each other, despite the nontrivial difference in imaging approaches. This shows that the 2 specific USIG approaches yield results that are consistent with each other, and that the USIG modality yields consistent results within the modality.
引用
- Salter BJ, Szegedi M, Boehm C, et al. Comparison of 2 transabdominal ultrasound image guidance techniques for prostate and prostatic fossa radiation therapy. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2016. PMID: 28274407. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2016.07.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。