文献速递消化道肿瘤放疗放疗物理与技术

三维与四维CT上胰腺癌勾画的观察者间差异显著:一项多中心研究

Considerable interobserver variation in delineation of pancreatic cancer on 3DCT and 4DCT: a multi-institutional study.
PubMed 文献 · Radiat Oncol · 2017-03-23

该多中心研究让6家机构的8名放疗科医生在3DCT和4DCT上勾画4例(交界)可切除胰腺癌患者的肿瘤。结果显示观察者间差异显著,同一患者最大与最小勾画体积比在GTV为6.8、iGTV为16.5,且4DCT的差异大于3DCT,最大局部差异位于胆道支架和可疑病理性增大淋巴结附近。

要点

  • 胰腺癌勾画观察者间差异显著,4DCT的iGTV差异大于3DCT的GTV。
  • 同一患者最大与最小勾画体积比:GTV为6.8,iGTV为16.5。
  • 最大局部差异位于胆道支架和可疑病理性增大淋巴结附近。

核心结论

  • 胰腺癌勾画存在显著的观察者间差异,且4D勾画的差异大于3D勾画。
  • 最大局部观察者间差异出现在胆道支架和可疑病理性增大淋巴结附近。

研究设计与样本

  • 多中心研究,8名放疗科医生来自6家机构,勾画4例(交界)可切除胰腺癌患者的肿瘤。
  • 研究分两阶段:3DCT阶段勾画GTV,4DCT阶段勾画iGTV以计入呼吸运动。
  • 计算(i)GTV体积、重叠度(CIgen)、局部观察者变异(局部SD)和整体观察者变异(整体SD),并比较GTV与iGTV。
  • 观察者填写问卷,评估勾画难度和胰腺肿瘤勾画经验。

主要发现

  • 同一患者最大与最小勾画体积比:GTV为6.8,iGTV为16.5。
  • iGTV平均体积(40.07 cm3)大于GTV平均体积(29.91 cm3)。
  • 所有患者的CIgen在iGTV均大于GTV。
  • 整体观察者变异均值(四名患者所有局部SD的均方根):GTV为0.63 cm,iGTV为0.80 cm。
  • 最大局部观察者变异位于胆道支架和可疑病理性增大淋巴结附近,部分观察者纳入而部分未纳入,该变异在iGTV比GTV更明显。

临床怎么用

  • 胰腺癌勾画需注意观察者间差异,尤其4DCT的iGTV勾画差异更大。
  • 勾画时应特别关注胆道支架和可疑病理性增大淋巴结区域,以减少差异。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The delineation of pancreatic tumors on CT is challenging. In this study, we quantified the interobserver variation for pancreatic tumor delineation on 3DCT as well as on 4DCT. METHODS: Eight observers (radiation oncologists) from six institutions delineated pancreatic tumors of four patients with (borderline) resectable pancreatic cancer. The study consisted of two stages. In the 3DCT-stage, the gross tumor volume (GTV) was delineated on a contrast-enhanced scan. In the 4DCT-stage, the internal GTV (iGTV) was delineated, accounting for the respiratory motion. We calculated the volumes of the (i)GTV, the overlap of the delineated volumes (expressed as generalized conformity index: CIgen), the local observer variation (local standard deviation: SD) and the overall observer variation (overall SD). We compared these results between GTVs and iGTVs. Additionally, observers were asked to fill out a questionnaire concerning the difficulty of the delineation and their experience in delineating pancreatic tumors. RESULTS: The ratios of the largest to the smallest delineated GTV and iGTV within the same patient were 6.8 and 16.5, respectively. As the iGTV incorporates the GTV during all respiratory phases, the mean volumes of the iGTV (40.07 cm3) were larger than those of the GTV (29.91 cm3). For all patients, CIgen was larger for the iGTV than for the GTV. The mean overall observer variation (root-mean-square of all local SDs over four patients) was 0.63 cm and 0.80 cm for GTV and iGTV, respectively. The largest local observer variations were seen close to biliary stents and suspicious pathological enlarged lymph nodes, as some observers included them and some did not. This variation was more pronounced for the iGTV than for the GTV. The observers rated the 3DCT-stage and 4DCT-stage equally difficult and treated on average three to four pancreatic cancer patients per year. CONCLUSIONS: A considerable interobserver variation in delineation of pancreatic tumors was observed. This variation was larger for 4D than for 3D delineation. The largest local observer variation was found around biliary stents and suspicious pathological enlarged lymph nodes.

来源:Radiat Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Versteijne E, Gurney-Champion OJ, van der Horst A, et al. Considerable interobserver variation in delineation of pancreatic cancer on 3DCT and 4DCT: a multi-institutional study. Radiat Oncol. 2017. PMID: 28335780. doi:10.1186/s13014-017-0777-0

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。