多机构随机试验测试交互式三维勾画图谱在放射肿瘤科住院医师中的效用
结果显示,eContour组在高危临床靶区与共识及专家勾画的一致性、对侧腮腺与专家勾画的一致性、知识测试成绩、可用性和满意度方面均优于现有资源组。
要点
- 使用eContour的住院医师高危临床靶区与共识勾画的一致性(0.63 vs 0.52;P=.02)和与专家勾画的一致性(0.58 vs 0.50;P=.01)均显著提高。
- 使用eContour的住院医师对侧腮腺与专家勾画的一致性更高(0.44 ± 0.12 vs 0.56 ± 0.08;P=.003)。
- eContour组知识测试成绩(89% vs 77%;P=.03)、可用性(89 vs 66;P<.0001)和满意度(4.1 vs 3.0;P=.002)均显著优于现有资源组。
核心结论
- 交互式三维勾画图谱能够提高放射肿瘤科住院医师靶区勾画的质量。
- 尚需进一步研究明确易获取的交互式教育参考工具在常规临床实践中改善勾画指南依从性和医疗质量的效用。
研究设计与样本
- 两阶段勾画研究:所有住院医师先使用现有资源勾画一例T1N1鼻咽癌病例,随后随机分组使用现有资源或交互式网页勾画图谱(eContour.org)重新勾画。
- 勾画分析采用 conformation number 和 simultaneous truth and performance level estimation。
- 第二次勾画完成后,住院医师完成多项选择知识测试和10项系统可用性量表(System Usability Scale)。
主要发现
- 与使用现有资源的住院医师相比,使用eContour的住院医师高危临床靶区与共识勾画的一致性更高(0.63 vs 0.52;P=.02)。
- 使用eContour的住院医师高危临床靶区与专家勾画的一致性更高(0.58 vs 0.50;P=.01)。
- 使用eContour的住院医师对侧腮腺与专家勾画的一致性更高(0.44 ± 0.12 vs 0.56 ± 0.08;P=.003)。
- 使用eContour的住院医师在多项选择知识测试中表现出更高的勾画和影像解剖知识(89% vs 77%;P=.03)。
- eContour的可用性(89 vs 66;P<.0001)和满意度(4.1 vs 3.0;P=.002)均高于现有资源。
临床怎么用
- 在住院医师靶区勾画培训中,可考虑引入交互式三维勾画图谱以提升勾画质量和学习效果。
- 交互式图谱可能有助于提高住院医师对勾画指南的依从性,但尚需在常规临床实践中进一步验证。
局限性
- 研究仅基于一例T1N1鼻咽癌病例的勾画任务,结果外推至其他瘤种和临床场景需谨慎。
- 研究未评估该工具对常规临床实践中勾画指南依从性和医疗质量的远期影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: The delivery of safe and effective radiation therapy relies on accurate target delineation, particularly in the era of highly conformal treatment techniques. Current contouring resources are fragmented and can be cumbersome to use. The present study reports on the efficacy and usability of a web-based contouring atlas compared with those of existing contouring resources in a randomized trial. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We enrolled radiation oncology residents into a 2-phase contouring study. All residents contoured a T1N1 nasopharyngeal cancer case using the currently available resources. The participants were then randomized to recontour the case with access to existing resources or an interactive web-based contouring atlas (eContour.org). Contour analysis was performed using conformation number and simultaneous truth and performance level estimation. At completion of the second contouring session, the residents completed a multiple choice question knowledge test and a 10-item System Usability Scale. RESULTS: Twenty-four residents from 5 institutions completed the study. Compared with the residents using currently available resources, the residents using eContour had improved contour agreement with both the consensus (0.63 vs 0.52; P=.02) and the expert (0.58 vs 0.50; P=.01) contours for the high-risk clinical target volume and greater agreement with the expert contour for the contralateral parotid gland (0.44 ± 0.12 vs 0.56 ± 0.08; P=.003). The residents using eContour demonstrated greater knowledge of contour delineation and radiographic anatomy on a multiple-choice knowledge-based test (89% vs 77%; P=.03). Usability (89 vs 66; P<.0001) and satisfaction (4.1 vs 3.0; P=.002) were greater for eContour than for the existing resources. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates the capacity of an interactive 3-dimensional contouring atlas to improve quality of resident target delineation in radiation oncology. Further research is needed to define the utility of easily accessible interactive educational reference tool to improve adherence to contouring-based guidelines and quality of care in routine clinical practice.
引用
- Gillespie EF, Panjwani N, Golden DW, et al. Multi-institutional Randomized Trial Testing the Utility of an Interactive Three-dimensional Contouring Atlas Among Radiation Oncology Residents. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2016. PMID: 28262474. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2016.11.050
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。