理解乳腺癌大分割放疗使用差异及其特定适应症:一项混合方法研究
该混合方法研究评估了西班牙加泰罗尼亚地区11家公立放疗中心2005至2015年乳腺癌大分割全乳放疗(HWBRT)的使用模式,并对所有科室主任和参考放疗医生进行了25次半结构化访谈。结果显示34,859例符合标准患者中仅12%接受大分割放疗,2015年升至29%(p<0.001);临床医生对证据解读和患者选择存在重要差异,提示放疗科室管理因素在治疗策略推广中起重要作用。
要点
- 34,859例患者中仅12%接受HWBRT,2015年升至29%(p<0.001)。
- 科室内部及科室间对证据解读和特定适应症患者选择存在重要差异。
- 放疗科室管理相关因素在治疗策略推广中起主要作用。
核心结论
- HWBRT采用率的差异不能仅通过理性的循证方法解决,放疗科室管理相关因素在治疗策略推广中起主要作用。
研究设计与样本
- 采用基于解释性序贯设计的混合方法,先收集分析11家公立放疗中心2005-2015年HWBRT(>2.5Gy/次)使用数据,再对全部科室主任和参考放疗医生进行25次半结构化访谈。
主要发现
- 研究期间34,859例符合标准患者中仅12%接受大分割放疗,2015年该比例为29%(p<0.001)。
- 在率先采用大分割的中心,接受常规分割和大分割的患者年龄差距缩小。
- 临床医生对证据解读(如对长期毒性风险的认知)和特定适应症患者选择在科室内部及科室间存在重要差异。
临床怎么用
- 应关注放疗科室管理因素对HWBRT推广的影响,而不仅依赖循证指南。
- 需统一临床医生对证据的解读和特定适应症的患者选择标准以减少实践差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Radiation oncology guidelines favour hypofractionated whole-breast radiotherapy (HWBRT) over more conventional schemes in the conservative treatment of breast cancer, but its adoption still varies in clinical practice. This study assessed the patterns of HWBRT adoption in Catalonia (Spain). MATERIAL AND METHODS: We used a mixed-methods approach based on an explanatory sequential design, first collecting and analysing quantitative data on HWBRT use (>2.5Gy per fraction) in 11 public radiotherapy centres (2005-2015) and then performing 25 semi-structured interviews with all department heads and reference radiation oncologist/s. RESULTS: Of the 34,859 patients fulfiling the study criteria over the study period, just 12% were hypofractionated, reaching a percentage of 29% in 2015 (p<0.001). Our analysis showed a narrowing age gap between patients receiving conventional fractionation and hypofractionation in centres leading adoption. However, there were important differences in clinicians' interpretation of evidence (e.g. regarding the perceived risk of long-term toxicity) and selection of patients for specific indications, both within and between departments. CONCLUSIONS: Differences observed in the rate of adoption of HWBRT could not be tackled only using a rational, evidence-based approach. Factors related to the management of radiotherapy departments play a major role in the diffusion of therapeutic strategies.
引用
- Prades J, Algara M, Espinàs JA, et al. Understanding variations in the use of hypofractionated radiotherapy and its specific indications for breast cancer: A mixed-methods study. Radiother Oncol. 2017. PMID: 28236538. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2017.01.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。