文献速递放疗物理与技术头颈部肿瘤放疗

VMAT质量保证系统对机器误差敏感性的比较

Comparisons of volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) quality assurance (QA) systems: sensitivity analysis to machine errors.
PubMed 文献 · Radiat Oncol · 2016-11-07

本研究在头颈VMAT计划中模拟机架角、MLC位置和输出误差,比较ArcCheck、Delta4和自研EPID三种QA系统的敏感性。结果显示ArcCheck对机架角误差更敏感,Delta4对MLC位置误差更敏感,三者对模拟输出误差均不敏感。

要点

  • ArcCheck对机架角误差最敏感,Delta4对MLC位置误差最敏感。
  • 三种系统对模拟的输出误差均不敏感,AUC均低于0.70。
  • EPID技术可通过调整ATA参数优化敏感性。

核心结论

  • ArcCheck对机架角误差更敏感,Delta4对MLC位置误差更敏感,三者对模拟输出误差均不敏感。

主要发现

  • 在2%/2mm/2°标准下保持AUC>0.95时,ArcCheck、Delta4和EPID可检测的最小机架角误差分别为2°、3°、3°。
  • 可检测的最小MLC位置误差分别为4mm、2mm、3mm。
  • 即使输出误差达5%,所有系统AUC均低于0.70。
  • γ梯度分析结果与ROC分析一致。

关键数值与推荐

  • ROC分析中AUC>0.95且γ标准为2%/2mm/2°(ATA仅用于EPID)。
  • ArcCheck、Delta4和EPID的机架角γ梯度分别为-5.1、-2.6、-3.6%/°。
  • MLC位置γ梯度分别为-2.6、-7.1、-3.3%/mm。
  • 输出误差γ梯度分别为-0.2、-0.2、-0.3%/%。

临床怎么用

  • 头颈VMAT中机架角QA可优先考虑ArcCheck,MLC位置QA可优先考虑Delta4。
  • 三种系统对输出误差敏感性不足,需注意其局限。
  • EPID技术可通过调整ATA参数优化敏感性,并支持全野高分辨率QA。

局限性

  • 研究仅基于头颈计划,未涵盖其他部位。
  • 误差模拟采用正弦函数,可能不完全代表实际机器误差。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: In volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT), gantry angles, dose rate and the MLC positions vary with the radiation delivery. The quality assurance (QA) system should be able to catch the planning and machine errors. The aim of this study was to investigate the sensitivity of three VMAT QA systems to machine errors. METHODS: Several types of potential linac machine errors unique to VMAT delivery were simulated in sinusoidal function of gantry angle, including gantry angle itself, MLC position and linac output. Two commercial QA systems, ArcCheck and Delta4, and an in-house developed EPID technique were compared in this study. Fifteen full arcs from head and neck plans were selected and modified to include five magnitudes of each type of error, resulting in measurements and γ analyses of 240 arcs on each system. Both qualitative and quantitative comparisons were performed using receiver operating characteristic (ROC), γ pass rate gradient, and overlap histogram methods. RESULTS: In ROC analysis, the area under curve (AUC) represents the sensitivity and increases with the error magnitude. Using the criteria of 2 %/2 mm/2° (angle to agreement, ATA, only for EPID) and keeping AUC > 0.95, the minimum error detectable of ArcCheck, Delta4 and EPID are (2, 3, 3)° in gantry angle and (4, 2, 3) mm in MLC positions for the head and neck plans. No system is sensitive to the simulated output error, the AUC values were all below 0.70 even with 5 % output error. The γ gradient for gantry angle, MLC position and output errors are (-5.1, -2.6, -3.6)%/°, (-2.6, -7.1, -3.3)%/mm and (-0.2, -0.2, -0.3)%/% for ArcCheck, Delta4 and EPID, respectively. Therefore, these two analyses are consistent and support the same conclusion. The ATA parameter in EPID technique can be adjusted to tune its sensitivity. CONCLUSIONS: We found that ArcCheck is more sensitive to gantry angle error and Delta4 is more sensitive to MLC position error. All three systems are not sensitive to the simulated output error. With additional analysis parameter, the EPID technique can be tuned to have optimal sensitivity and is able to perform QA for full field size with highest resolution. In addition, ROC analysis avoids the choice of γ pass rate threshold and is more robust compared with other analysis methods.

来源:Radiat Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Liang B, Liu B, Zhou F, et al. Comparisons of volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) quality assurance (QA) systems: sensitivity analysis to machine errors. Radiat Oncol. 2016. PMID: 27821135

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。