计算网格大小对头颈部IMRT剂量学和放射生物学的影响
本研究针对头颈部IMRT患者,比较不同计算网格大小(1-5 mm)对剂量分布及肿瘤控制概率(TCP)和正常组织并发症概率(NTCP)的影响。结果显示靶区平均剂量和TCP随网格增大而降低,危及器官平均剂量和NTCP随网格增大而升高,1 mm网格剂量验证通过率最高。作者建议头颈部计划尤其是小体积结构采用尽可能小的计算网格。
要点
- 靶区平均剂量和TCP随网格增大而降低,危及器官平均剂量和NTCP随网格增大而升高。
- 从1 mm到5 mm网格,靶区均匀性指数升高达60%,适形性指数平均降低3.5%。
- 1 mm网格的3%/3 mm gamma通过率最高,小体积危及器官的NTCP差异更明显。
核心结论
- 头颈部IMRT应使用尽可能小的计算网格以保证剂量计算准确性,小网格可改善TCP并降低NTCP。
研究设计与样本
- 针对头颈部患者生成IMRT计划,采用1-5 mm不同网格大小计算剂量及相关TCP和NTCP。
- 比较D2%、D50%、D98%、均匀性和适形性指数,并与所有IMRT计划的实测剂量进行对比。
主要发现
- 靶区平均剂量和TCP随网格增大而降低,危及器官平均剂量和NTCP随网格增大而升高。
- 靶区平均剂量随网格增大呈线性下降;耳蜗、腮腺和脊髓的平均剂量随网格增大而升高。
- IMRT剂量验证中,满足3%/3 mm gamma标准的点数随网格减小而增加。
- 1 mm至5 mm网格间,靶区均匀性指数升高达60%,适形性指数平均降低3.5%,导致TCP降低和NTCP升高。
- 单尾配对t检验显示各网格大小计算与1 mm网格相比差异有统计学意义。
关键数值与推荐
- 网格大小范围1-5 mm;剂量验证gamma标准为3%/3 mm;均匀性指数升高达60%,适形性指数平均降低3.5%。
临床怎么用
- 头颈部IMRT计划尤其是小体积结构应采用尽可能小的计算网格以准确计算剂量。
- 小网格可改善TCP并降低NTCP,对小体积危及器官的获益更明显。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Small-volume structures usually found in the head and neck may be susceptible to dose-volume averaging, which has not been studied. Here, the impact of calculation grid size on dose distribution for tumor control probability (TCP) and normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) is investigated for head and neck (H&N) intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT). METHODS AND MATERIALS: IMRT plans were generated for H&N patients with different grid sizes (1-5 mm) to calculate dose and related TCP and NTCP. Dose parameters such as D2%, D50%, D98%, and the homogeneity and conformity indices were calculated. The dose distributions were also compared with measured dose for all IMRT plans. A 1-tailed pair t test was used to analyze the data. RESULTS: The mean dose to planning target volume and TCP decreases with increasing grid size, whereas for organs at risk (OARs), mean dose, and NTCP increase with increasing grid size. The average mean dose to planning target volume decreases linearly with grid size, but for OARs such as cochlea, parotid gland, and the spinal cord, mean dose increases with grid size. IMRT dose verification showed that the number of points meeting the gamma criterion of 3%/3 mm increased with decreasing grid sizes. The homogeneity index for the target increased up to 60% and conformity index decreased on average by 3.5% between 1- to 5-mm grid that resulted in decreased TCP and increased NTCP. A 1-tailed pair t test showed significant statistical differences among various grid size calculations compared with 1-mm grids. CONCLUSIONS: Based on our findings, the smallest possible grid size should be used for accurate dose calculation in small-volume structures-especially in H&N planning. A smaller calculation grid provides superior dosimetry with improved TCP as well as reduced NTCP, which is more pronounced for smaller OARs.
引用
- Srivastava SP, Cheng CW, Das IJ, et al. The dosimetric and radiobiological impact of calculation grid size on head and neck IMRT. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2016. PMID: 27847266. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2016.10.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。