头颈癌放疗纵向毒性轨迹的插补方法评估
本研究以头颈癌放疗后四种毒性(口干、吞咽困难、味觉改变、黏唾液)在16个时间点的纵向评分为例,评估九种缺失数据插补方法。结果显示简单插补法表现较差,患者可用时间点低于50%时插补开始恶化,下游模型除简单法外差异可忽略。
要点
- 应避免使用简单插补方法处理纵向毒性数据。
- 患者可用时间点低于50%时插补质量开始恶化。
- 先进插补法在低患者数(150例)时可达良好表现。
核心结论
- 最好避免简单插补方法,并谨慎考虑纳入哪些患者以及数据集是否允许使用更先进的插补方法。
研究设计与样本
- 评估九种纵向数据插补方法,数据为头颈癌放疗后四种毒性在16个时间点(治疗前1个、治疗中7个、治疗后8个)的评分。
- 共纳入1442例患者,平均约有11.6个可用时间点。
- 采用系统性移除策略比较真实值与插补值,并进行患者层面、队列层面和下游模型评估。
主要发现
- 除简单方法表现较差外,各插补方法总体插补质量差异极小。
- 患者可用时间点低于50%时,插补开始恶化。
- 队列层面评估显示先进方法在低患者数(150例)时可达良好表现,但更易受平均时间点可用性低的影响。
- 下游模型评估显示除简单方法导致模型系数不同外,各方法间差异可忽略。
临床怎么用
- 在纵向临床数据插补中避免使用简单插补方法。
- 应用插补时需审慎考虑纳入特定患者,并评估数据集是否支持使用更先进的插补方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Longitudinally collected medical data is often afflicted by missingness, making methods mitigating missingness valuable. This study evaluated nine imputation methods for longitudinal data, using toxicity scores measured at multiple timepoints resulting from head and neck cancer treatment with radiotherapy. METHODS AND MATERIALS: For four toxicities (xerostomia, dysphagia, taste alteration, and sticky saliva), toxicity scores at 16 timepoints (1 prior, 7 during, and 8 after treatment) were collected, resulting in 1442 patients with on average ∼11.6 available timepoints. Imputation methods ranged from simple to deep learning-based. Methods were evaluated using a systematic removal strategy enabling comparison of true and imputed values. Patient-level, cohort-level and downstream model evaluation was done, evaluating inclusion criteria for patients, training data requirement and modelling effect respectively. RESULTS: General imputation quality showed minimal differences between methods, except simple methods, which performed worse. For patient-level evaluation, it was found that when patients had <50% of timepoints available, imputation started to worsen. Cohort-level evaluation showed that advanced methods could reach good performances at low patient counts (150 patients) but were more severely affected by low average timepoint availability. Downstream model evaluation showed negligible differences between methods, other than simple methods which resulted in different model coefficients. CONCLUSIONS: It was found that it is best to avoid simple imputation methods. Furthermore, when applying imputation to longitudinal data practitioners should be conscientious about inclusion of certain patients and if their dataset permits the use of more advanced imputation methods.
引用
- van der Hoek L, de Vette SPM, Neh H, et al. Evaluating imputation methods for longitudinal clinical trajectories: Toxicities in head and neck cancer treatment. Radiother Oncol. 2026. PMID: 42858855. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2026.111815
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。