头颈部危及器官自动分割手动编辑的多用户纵向变异性分析
该研究对比了1051例头颈部肿瘤患者四个器官的自动分割与临床分割,并纵向分析七年间的编辑模式。结果显示编辑行为随时间及不同放疗技师间差异显著,过度编辑与极少编辑均与较低的临床可接受性评分相关,提示需建立内部共识并常规监测自动分割使用。
要点
- 除声门外,各结构MSD在引入自动分割后下降。
- 从基于图谱转向深度学习分割后nAPL明显降低。
- 编辑程度过少或过多均与较低临床可接受性相关。
核心结论
- 过度编辑与极少编辑均与较低的临床可接受性评分相关,需内部共识以提升勾画一致性并避免不必要的工作量或次优轮廓。
- 应在临床实践中常规开展按用户监测自动分割的使用情况。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性纵向分析,纳入2017年以来治疗的1051例头颈部患者。
- 比较腮腺、颌下腺、口腔和声门的自动分割与临床分割,计算MSD、nAPL和sDSC。
- 按时间及放疗技师分析编辑模式,并对近期部分病例由技师盲法评定所有参与者勾画的临床可接受性。
主要发现
- 引入自动分割后,除声门外所有结构的MSD均下降。
- 从基于图谱的分割切换为深度学习分割后,nAPL明显降低。
- 编辑行为随时间及不同技师间差异显著。
- 编辑极少或极多的勾画均与最低的临床可接受性评分相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 采用MSD、nAPL和sDSC三项指标量化自动分割与临床分割的差异。
- 对近期部分病例由放疗技师盲法评定所有参与者勾画的临床可接受性。
临床怎么用
- 临床应建立内部共识以规范自动分割后的手动编辑,减少不必要的编辑工作量。
- 建议按用户常规监测自动分割的编辑行为,以发现过度或过少编辑的异常模式。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Although auto-segmentation is widely used as a starting point for delineating organs of interest (OOIs), subsequent manual edits, and their variability over time and across users, may compromise workflow efficiency or treatment quality, limiting the intended benefits of auto-segmentation. Yet, longitudinal editing patterns are rarely assessed for clinical acceptability. AIM: To quantify editing of head-and-neck auto-segmentations over seven years, characterize variability among radiation therapy technologists (RTTs), and assess whether user-specific editing behavior aligns with perceived clinical acceptability. MATERIALS AND METHODS: For 1051 head and neck patients treated since 2017, auto- and clinical segmentations of the parotid and submandibular glands, oral cavity and glottis were compared. Mean surface distance (MSD), normalized added path length (nAPL) and surface Dice Similarity coefficient (sDSC) were determined, and the locations of the most prominent edits were visualized, over time and by RTT. For a subset of recent cases, RTTs blindly rated the clinical acceptability of all participants' delineations. RESULTS: MSD decreased for all structures except the glottis following the introduction of auto-segmentation. Switching from atlas-based to deep learning-based segmentation resulted in a marked nAPL reduction. Editing varied substantially over time and between RTTs. Delineations that were edited minimally or extensively were associated with the lowest clinical acceptability scores. CONCLUSIONS: Both excessive and minimal editing were associated with lower clinical acceptability, warranting the need for internal consensus to improve delineation consistency and avoid unnecessary workload or suboptimal contours. These findings underscore the importance of routine, per-user monitoring of auto-segmentation use in clinical practice.
引用
- Simões R, van der Velden S, Gooding MJ, et al. Variability in manual editing of head and neck organs of interest auto-segmentations: a multi-user, longitudinal analysis. Radiother Oncol. 2026. PMID: 42425419. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2026.111684
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。