呼吸训练后呼吸运动对混合与IMRT计划在大分割乳腺放疗中的剂量学影响
呼吸训练后胸壁运动幅度为1.54±0.85 mm,肝脏为13.2±4.6 mm。两种技术靶区稳健性相当,混合计划在低剂量区OAR保护更优,可考虑作为自由呼吸下大分割全乳照射的优选方案。
要点
- 呼吸训练后胸壁运动幅度为1.54±0.85 mm,肝脏为13.2±4.6 mm。
- 形变累积后PTV_V100%仅下降2.5%(混合)与2.1%(IMRT),靶区稳健性相当。
- 混合计划在低剂量区OAR保护优于IMRT。
核心结论
- 在本队列中,呼吸训练后胸壁运动幅度保持在3.1 mm以内。
- 在此条件下,混合与IMRT计划的靶区剂量稳健性相当,混合计划在低剂量区OAR保护更优。
- 基于此比较,自由呼吸下大分割全乳照射可考虑将混合计划作为优于IMRT的选项。
研究设计与样本
- 在3D-CT上生成原始混合计划(O_HY)与IMRT计划(O_IM),映射至10个4D-CT时相重新计算。
- 应用形变图像配准将各时相剂量累积至原始3D-CT,生成含运动的形变混合计划(D_HY)与IMRT计划(D_IM)。
- 量化胸壁与肝脏的呼吸运动幅度,比较靶区与OAR的剂量学参数。
主要发现
- 呼吸训练后肝脏运动幅度为13.2±4.6 mm,胸壁为1.54±0.85 mm。
- 原始计划中两种技术靶区覆盖均良好,热点、均匀性与适形性相当。
- 形变剂量累积后PTV_V100%下降2.5%(混合)与2.1%(IMRT),PTV_D2%基本不变,HI/CI仅轻度变差。
- OAR剂量变化轻微,除IMRT计划Breast_Dmean较低外无显著差异。
- 呼吸运动与多数剂量学参数无有意义相关性,仅肝脏运动与PTV_V95%呈弱相关、与IMRT计划Breast_Dmean呈显著相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 呼吸训练后胸壁运动幅度在3.1 mm以内。
- 形变累积后PTV_V100%下降:混合计划2.5%,IMRT计划2.1%。
- 肝脏运动幅度13.2±4.6 mm,胸壁运动幅度1.54±0.85 mm。
临床怎么用
- 自由呼吸下大分割全乳照射可考虑优先选择混合计划以改善低剂量区OAR保护。
- 呼吸训练后胸壁运动幅度较小者,混合与IMRT靶区稳健性相当,计划选择可侧重OAR保护。
局限性
- 呼吸运动与多数剂量学参数无有意义相关性,仅少数参数呈弱相关或显著相关。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: This study aimed to evaluate the dosimetric impact of respiratory motion after breathing training on Hybrid and IMRT plans in hypofractionated breast radiotherapy, using 4D-CT and deformable dose accumulation. METHODS: Twenty-two postoperative breast cancer patients treated under free breathing underwent both 3D-CT and 4D-CT scanning after abdominal breathing training. Original Hybrid (O_HY) and IMRT (O_IM) plans were generated on 3D-CT. Each plan was mapped onto the ten 4D-CT phases and recalculated. Deformable image registration was applied to accumulate phase-specific doses onto the original 3D-CT, generating motion-inclusive deformed Hybrid (D_HY) and IMRT (D_IM) plans. Respiratory motion amplitudes of the chest wall and liver were quantified. Dosimetric parameters of targets and OARs were evaluated and compared. RESULTS: After breathing training, respiratory motion amplitudes were 13.2 ± 4.6 mm for the liver and 1.54 ± 0.85 mm for the chest wall. Both techniques achieved good target coverage in the original plans, with comparable hotspot, homogeneity, and conformity. Hybrid plans provided superior OAR sparing, particularly in the low-dose regions. After deformable dose accumulation, target coverage exhibited only minor decreases: PTV_V100% decreased by 2.5% for Hybrid and 2.1% for IMRT. PTV_D2% remained largely unchanged, and HI/CI deteriorated only slightly. OAR dose variations were minimal, with no significant differences except for a lower Breast_Dmean in the IMRT plan. Respiratory motion showed no meaningful correlations with most dosimetric parameters, except for weak correlations between liver motion and PTV_V95% and a significant correlation with Breast_Dmean in the IMRT plan. CONCLUSIONS: In this cohort, chest wall motion amplitude after breathing training remained within 3.1 mm. Under these conditions, Hybrid and IMRT plans demonstrate comparable target dose robustness, while Hybrid achieves superior OAR sparing, particularly in the low-dose region. Based on this comparison, Hybrid planning may be considered a favorable option relative to IMRT for hypofractionated whole-breast irradiation under free breathing.
引用
- Hou L, Yan G, Yao S, et al. Assessing respiratory motion effects after breathing training on hybrid and IMRT plans in hypofractionated breast radiotherapy. Radiat Oncol. 2026. PMID: 41803865. doi:10.1186/s13014-026-02821-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。