美国医学物理师HDR近距离放疗实践模式全国调查
2023年针对美国所有IROC-Houston注册站点的医学物理师开展全国调查,收到365份完整回复。结果显示医学物理师参与HDR近距离放疗几乎所有技术环节,妇科近距离放疗最常开展(96%),MRI引导计划的使用率仅略有增加,资源分配与工作负荷仍面临挑战。
要点
- 医学物理师负责HDR近距离放疗几乎全部技术环节,71%有超过10年经验。
- 妇科近距离放疗最常开展(96%),其次为皮肤(34%)、前列腺(33%)、乳腺(23%)。
- 66%使用逆向计划,34%采用自动导管重建,32%开展MRI引导计划但仅14%频繁使用。
核心结论
- 医学物理师参与并负责HDR近距离放疗几乎每个技术环节,资源分配、操作复杂性和后勤需求仍是持续挑战。
- 未来应致力于开发改进的资源分配指标,以根据操作复杂性和病例量优化人员配置。
研究设计与样本
- 2023年针对美国所有IROC-Houston注册站点开展全国性调查,收到365份完整回复。
- 主要目标是分析参与HDR近距离放疗的医学物理师的国家实践模式和工作负荷动态。
主要发现
- 71%的回复者报告有超过10年近距离放疗服务经验,75%执行涉及超过3个通道的复杂妇科治疗。
- 三分之二回复者受雇于非学术机构,53%表示其诊所医学物理全职当量小于1。
- 最常执行的操作是妇科近距离放疗(96%),其次为皮肤(34%)、前列腺(33%)和乳腺(23%)。
- 66%使用逆向计划,34%采用自动导管重建;32%的回复者开展MRI引导计划,其中14%报告频繁使用。
- 在执行复杂妇科治疗的亚组中,38%报告使用MRI;MRI引导计划的采用在过去十年仅略有增加。
关键数值与推荐
- 妇科近距离放疗开展率96%,皮肤34%,前列腺33%,乳腺23%。
- 71%回复者有超过10年近距离放疗服务经验,75%执行超过3个通道的复杂妇科治疗。
- 53%的诊所医学物理全职当量小于1;66%使用逆向计划,34%采用自动导管重建。
- 32%的回复者开展MRI引导计划,14%频繁使用;复杂妇科治疗亚组中38%使用MRI。
临床怎么用
- 医学物理师应关注HDR近距离放疗全流程技术管理,包括计划设计、导管重建和质量保证。
- 在资源有限(全职当量小于1)的机构中,需根据操作复杂性和病例量合理分配物理师人力。
- 复杂妇科近距离放疗中可考虑MRI引导计划,但需注意其频繁使用率仍较低。
局限性
- 调查仅纳入IROC-Houston注册站点,结果外推需谨慎。
- 研究为问卷调查,依赖回复者自我报告,可能存在回忆偏倚。
- 未报告回复率及未回复站点的特征,无法评估无应答偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: High-dose-rate (HDR) brachytherapy (BT) is an effective but resource-intensive treatment modality, demanding a highly skilled workforce, team coordination, and logistics. This study presents findings from a comprehensive national survey conducted in 2023, targeting all registered IROC-Houston (Imaging and Radiation Oncology Core) sites in the United States. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The primary objective was to analyze national BT practice patterns and workload dynamics among medical physicists involved in HDR BT treatments. A secondary aim, explored in a companion publication (part 2), examines work effort, job satisfaction, and challenges faced by medical physicists in this field. RESULTS: The survey received 365 complete responses, revealing an experienced workforce, with 71% reporting over 10 years of BT service and 75% performing complex gynecologic treatments involving more than 3 channels. Two-thirds of respondents were employed at nonacademic institutions, and 53% indicated that the medical physics full-time equivalent was <1 at their clinic. The most frequently performed procedure was gynecologic BT (96%), followed by skin (34%), prostate (33%), and breast (23%). Adoption of advanced planning tools was variable, with 66% using inverse planning and 34% employing automatic catheter reconstruction. Additionally, 32% of all respondents performed magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) based planning, with 14% reporting frequent use. Of the subgroup performing complex gynecologic treatments, 38% reported the utilization of MRIs. Uptake of MRI-based planning appears to have increased only slightly over the past decade. CONCLUSIONS: The survey demonstrated that medical physicists are involved in and responsible for nearly every technical aspect of the HDR BT process. This study presents one of the largest national surveys on medical physics practice patterns to date. The findings highlight ongoing challenges in allocating resources, varying procedure complexity, and logistical demands. Future initiatives should focus on developing improved resource allocation metrics to optimize staffing based on procedure complexity and caseload.
引用
- Meyer J, Zoberi JE, Kim H, et al. A National Survey of Medical Physicists: Part 1-Practice Patterns for High-Dose-Rate Brachytherapy. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2026. PMID: 41690558. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2026.01.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。