无模拟定位姑息放疗临床实施的改良德尔菲共识建议
该改良德尔菲研究邀请5国8家机构的11名专家,经1轮开放问卷和3轮Likert调查,就无模拟定位姑息放疗的12个领域达成共识。95%的陈述达成共识,强烈支持低风险部位采用常规剂量分割的姑息治疗,并推荐近期高质量诊断CT、图像质量保证和多学科监督。
要点
- 强烈支持低风险部位(如胸/腰椎、骨盆)采用常规剂量分割的无模拟定位姑息放疗。
- 推荐 prerequisites 包括近期高质量诊断扫描(层厚≤3 mm,100-140 kVp)、稳健的图像质量保证和多学科监督。
- 对使用旧扫描、颈椎靶区及与IMRT/VMAT计划整合的共识有限。
核心结论
- 无模拟定位放疗可在姑息治疗中安全实施,但需明确适应证、工作流程保障和培训。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲法,纳入放疗肿瘤学家7名、医学物理师2名、放疗治疗师1名和专注于姑息放疗的博士候选人1名,来自5国8家机构。
- 流程包括1轮开放式问卷和3轮Likert量表调查,覆盖12个领域,共识定义为≥75%同意,≥90%为强烈支持。
主要发现
- 9名受访者(代表11名专家)完成所有轮次,95%的陈述达成共识。
- 强烈支持低风险部位(如胸/腰椎、骨盆)采用常规剂量分割的姑息意向治疗使用无模拟定位放疗。
- 共识有限的领域包括使用较旧扫描、应用于颈椎靶区以及与IMRT/VMAT计划整合。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐 prerequisites:近期高质量诊断扫描(层厚≤3 mm,100-140 kVp)、稳健的图像质量保证和多学科监督。
- 共识阈值:≥75%同意为共识,≥90%为强烈支持,67%至74%为趋向同意。
临床怎么用
- 对低风险部位(如胸/腰椎、骨盆)的姑息放疗,可考虑无模拟定位流程以加速治疗并优化资源。
- 实施前应确保近期高质量诊断CT(层厚≤3 mm,100-140 kVp)、图像质量保证和多学科监督。
- 对颈椎靶区、使用旧扫描及与IMRT/VMAT整合应谨慎,因共识有限。
局限性
- 需进一步剂量学验证和在多样实践环境中更广泛评估。
- 专家样本量小(9名受访者代表11名专家),来自5国8家机构。
- 对部分领域(旧扫描、颈椎靶区、IMRT/VMAT整合)共识有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Simulation-free radiation therapy (sim-free RT) uses diagnostic computed tomography scans in place of dedicated computed tomography simulations for treatment planning, potentially expediting palliative radiation therapy (PRT) while optimizing resource utilization. Broader adoption has been limited by the absence of standardized implementation guidance. This study aimed to establish expert consensus on key clinical, technical, and educational considerations for sim-free RT in PRT practice. METHODS AND MATERIALS: A modified Delphi process was conducted with international experts in sim-free RT, including radiation oncologists (n = 7), medical physicists (n = 2), a radiation therapist, and a PhD candidate specializing in PRT. The process included an open-ended first round followed by 3 Likert-scale survey rounds across 12 domains. Consensus was defined as ≥75% agreement; ≥90% agreement indicated strong support. "Trend toward agreement" was defined as 67% to 74%. RESULTS: Nine respondents, representing 11 individual experts from 8 institutions in 5 countries, completed all study rounds. Experts from the same institution responding as a group were considered as 1 participant. Consensus was achieved for 95% of statements. Strong support was observed for sim-free RT in palliative-intent treatments at low-risk sites (eg, thoracic/lumbar spine, pelvis) using conventional dose-fractionation. Recommended prerequisites included recent high-quality diagnostic scans (≤3 mm slice thickness, 100-140 kVp), robust image quality assurance, and multidisciplinary oversight. Areas of limited agreement included the use of older scans, application to cervical spine targets, and integration with intensity modulated radiotherapy/volumetric modulated arc therapy planning. CONCLUSIONS: This Delphi study provides expert-driven recommendations to support safe implementation of sim-free RT in palliative practice. Findings highlight suitable indications, workflow safeguards, and training needs while underscoring the need for further dosimetric validation and broader evaluation across diverse practice settings.
引用
- O'Neil M, Tan VS, Schuler T, et al. Clinical Implementation of Simulation-Free Palliative Radiation Therapy: Consensus Recommendations From a Modified Delphi Study. Adv Radiat Oncol. 2026. PMID: 41705126. doi:10.1016/j.adro.2025.101993
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。