PURE-MRI:前列腺MRI上医生勾画前列腺与尿道的准确性国际研究
PURE-MRI是一项国际前瞻性研究,邀请62名来自11个国家的专科医生在T2加权MRI上勾画前列腺和尿道,并与多学科专家共识参考分割及AI自动分割工具比较。医生前列腺勾画总体Dice评分中位数>0.90,但典型病例仍包含至少一个>5 mm的误差;尿道勾画准确性较低,典型覆盖率<40%,而AI>80%。
要点
- 医生前列腺勾画Dice中位数0.92,但最大偏差可>5 mm甚至>10 mm
- 医生尿道勾画Dice中位数仅0.33,覆盖率中位数36%
- AI前列腺勾画准确性可比医生,尿道覆盖率达81%
核心结论
- 医生在MRI上勾画前列腺总体Dice评分>0.90,但典型病例仍包含至少一个>5 mm的误差,有时>10 mm。
- 医生尿道勾画准确性较低,典型覆盖率<40%,而AI工具覆盖率>80%。
- AI工具在前列腺勾画上达到与执业医生相当的准确性,并在尿道覆盖上表现更优。
研究设计与样本
- 国际前瞻性研究,邀请诊断或治疗前列腺癌的医生在标准T2加权MRI(所有平面)上勾画前列腺和尿道。
- 62名来自11个国家的专科医生共创建114个前列腺勾画和110个尿道勾画。
- 将医生勾画与多学科专家小组产生的共识参考分割进行比较,并评估已验证的自动分割AI工具的表现。
- 采用空间和体积分析评估准确性,并使用混合效应模型评估影响勾画表现的可能因素。
主要发现
- 医生前列腺勾画Dice评分中位数(最小,最大)为0.92(0.62,0.95),AI为0.95(0.94,0.96)。
- 医生前列腺内最大偏差中位数为3.4 mm(1.0,12.4),AI为3.0 mm(3.0,3.0);前列腺外最大偏差中位数为5.3 mm(2.4,17.3),AI为3.9 mm(3.1,4.9)。
- 医生前列腺每例平均偏差中位数为1.6 mm(0.9,3.9),AI为1.2 mm(1.1,1.6)。
- 医生尿道勾画Dice评分中位数为0.33(0.03,0.69),AI为0.41(0.35,0.48);覆盖率中位数为36%(3%,96%),AI为81%(80%,91%)。
- 医生尿道外最大(2D)偏差中位数为1.6 mm(1.0,2.3),AI为1.7 mm(1.3,2.1);医生培训学员与经验丰富临床医生的表现相似。
临床怎么用
- 医生前列腺勾画总体准确但需警惕>5 mm的局部误差,可结合AI工具辅助质控。
- 尿道勾画准确性低,建议使用AI工具以提高尿道覆盖,减少漏照。
- 培训学员与经验丰富医生表现相似,提示勾画培训需关注尿道等精细结构。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Precise delineation of genitourinary structures during prostate cancer (PCa) care is critical to optimize treatment delivery while minimizing toxicity and injury. The Prostate and UREthra on MRI (PURE-MRI) study is an international, prospective study to assess physicians' accuracy segmenting prostate and urethra on MRI. METHODS: Physicians who diagnose or treat PCa were invited to contour prostate and urethra on patient cases using standard T2-weighted MRI (all planes). We compared these contours to reference consensus segmentations produced by a multidisciplinary panel of experts. We also evaluated performance of validated auto-segmentation AI tools. Accuracy was assessed with spatial and volumetric analyses. A mixed effects model was used to evaluate potential factors influencing contour performance. RESULTS: 62 specialists from 11 countries created 114 prostate and 110 urethra contours. Prostate median (min, max) accuracy for physicians [vs. AI] was Dice score: 0.92 (0.62, 0.95) [vs. 0.95 (0.94, 0.96)], maximum deviation inside prostate: 3.4 mm (1.0, 12.4) [vs. 3.0 mm (3.0, 3.0)], maximum deviation beyond prostate: 5.3 mm (2.4, 17.3) [vs. 3.9 mm (3.1, 4.9)], mean deviation (per case) from the reference prostate: 1.6 mm (0.9, 3.9) [vs. 1.2 mm (1.1, 1.6)]. Urethra accuracy was Dice score: 0.33 (0.03, 0.69) [vs. 0.41 (0.35, 0.48)], coverage: 36 % (3 %, 96 %) [vs. 81 % (80 %, 91 %)], maximum (2D) deviation beyond urethra: 1.6 mm (1.0, 2.3) [vs. 1.7 mm (1.3, 2.1)]. CONCLUSION: Physicians contour the prostate on MRI with overall Dice score >0.90, though typical cases still include at least one error >5 mm and sometimes >10 mm. Physician urethra contours were less accurate, with typical coverage of <40 % of the reference urethra (compared to >80 % for AI). Physician trainees performed similarly to experienced clinicians. AI tools give comparable accuracy to practicing physicians for prostate contours and achieve better coverage of the urethra.
引用
- Nguyen L, Song Y, Dornisch A, et al. PURE-MRI: An international study assessing physician accuracy in delineating the prostate and urethra on prostate MRI. Radiother Oncol. 2025. PMID: 41412436. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2025.111333
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。