基于PET和CT的DenseNet在口咽癌结局预测中优于先进深度学习模型
本研究基于HECKTOR 2022数据集(489例口咽癌患者,来自7个中心)及本中心400例接受化放疗的口咽癌患者外部测试数据,比较了DenseNet与三种先进深度学习模型预测无复发生存期的性能。DenseNet81(81层)内部测试C-index为0.69,与先进模型相当;去除GTV后外部测试C-index从0.59提升至0.63;晚期融合CT与PET在内部和外部测试中C-index分别为0.68和0.66,优于仅PET模型。结论认为基础DenseNet架构内部测试性能与先进模型相当,外部测试更优。
要点
- DenseNet81内部测试C-index为0.69,与先进模型相当。
- 去除GTV后外部测试C-index从0.59提升至0.63。
- 晚期融合CT与PET在内部和外部测试C-index分别为0.68和0.66。
核心结论
- 81层基础DenseNet架构在内部测试集上预测性能与架构更复杂的先进模型相当,在外部测试集上表现更优。
- CT与PET影像数据的晚期融合在外部测试中产生更优性能。
研究设计与样本
- 基于HECKTOR 2022挑战赛数据集,包含来自7个不同中心的489例口咽癌患者,随机分为训练集369例和独立测试集120例。
- 额外使用本中心400例接受化放疗的口咽癌患者数据集进行外部测试。
- 每位患者数据包括治疗前CT和PET扫描、原发肿瘤和淋巴结的手工勾画GTV轮廓以及无复发生存期信息。
- 本研究比较DenseNet与基于HECKTOR 2022数据集开发的三种先进模型性能。
主要发现
- 输入CT、PET和GTV采用早期融合时,DenseNet81内部测试C-index为0.69,与先进模型相当。
- 去除GTV后内部测试C-index仍为0.69,外部测试C-index从0.59提升至0.63。
- 与仅PET模型相比,采用晚期融合CT和PET时DenseNet81在内部和外部测试集C-index分别为0.68和0.66;早期融合仅在内部测试集更优。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In the HECKTOR 2022 challenge set [1], several state-of-the-art (SOTA, achieving best performance) deep learning models were introduced for predicting recurrence-free period (RFP) in head and neck cancer patients using PET and CT images. PURPOSE: This study investigates whether a conventional DenseNet architecture, with optimized numbers of layers and image-fusion strategies, could achieve comparable performance as SOTA models. METHODS: The HECKTOR 2022 dataset comprises 489 oropharyngeal cancer (OPC) patients from seven distinct centers. It was randomly divided into a training set (n = 369) and an independent test set (n = 120). Furthermore, an additional dataset of 400 OPC patients, who underwent chemo(radiotherapy) at our center, was employed for external testing. Each patients' data included pre-treatment CT- and PET-scans, manually generated GTV (Gross tumour volume) contours for primary tumors and lymph nodes, and RFP information. The present study compared the performance of DenseNet against three SOTA models developed on the HECKTOR 2022 dataset. RESULTS: When inputting CT, PET and GTV using the early fusion (considering them as different channels of input) approach, DenseNet81 (with 81 layers) obtained an internal test C-index of 0.69, a performance metric comparable with SOTA models. Notably, the removal of GTV from the input data yielded the same internal test C-index of 0.69 while improving the external test C-index from 0.59 to 0.63. Furthermore, compared to PET-only models, when utilizing the late fusion (concatenation of extracted features) with CT and PET, DenseNet81 demonstrated superior C-index values of 0.68 and 0.66 in both internal and external test sets, while using early fusion was better in only the internal test set. CONCLUSIONS: The basic DenseNet architecture with 81 layers demonstrated a predictive performance on par with SOTA models featuring more intricate architectures in the internal test set, and better performance in the external test. The late fusion of CT and PET imaging data yielded superior performance in the external test.
引用
- Ma B, Guo J, Dijk LVV, et al. PET and CT based DenseNet outperforms advanced deep learning models for outcome prediction of oropharyngeal cancer. Radiother Oncol. 2025. PMID: 40118186. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2025.110852
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。