直肠癌侧方区域放疗靶区勾画差异:全国指南更新后的多中心研究
研究由15家机构的23名放射肿瘤科医生对1例直肠癌患者的CT图像勾画侧方区域临床靶区,评估勾画者间差异及培训和标准化指南实施的影响。结果显示指南发布前存在显著勾画差异,前区域大于后区域(Dice评分0.66 vs 0.80,P<.01);培训后侧方区域整体95% Hausdorff距离显著改善(0.71 vs 1.02,P=.02),但Dice评分无显著改善(0.76 vs 0.78,P=.31),且前、后区域分别分析时均无显著改善。结论认为指南和培训可减少差异,但特定区域仍需进一步改进。
要点
- 指南发布前侧方区域勾画差异显著,前区域大于后区域(Dice 0.66 vs 0.80,P<.01)。
- 培训后侧方区域整体95% Hausdorff距离显著改善(0.71 vs 1.02,P=.02),Dice评分未显著改善(0.76 vs 0.78,P=.31)。
- 前区域腹侧和外侧勾画差异减小,但尾侧差异增加。
核心结论
- 直肠癌侧方区域临床靶区存在显著勾画者间差异,实施具有清晰解剖边界的勾画指南并进行培训可减少差异。
- 尽管95% Hausdorff距离有所改善,特定区域仍需进一步改进以确保充分勾画。
研究设计与样本
- 来自15家机构的23名放射肿瘤科医生对1例直肠癌患者的CT图像勾画侧方区域临床靶区,同期更新全国共识指南。
- 参与医生完成电子学习和在线培训后,其中12名医生对同一病例重新勾画,采用Dice评分和95% Hausdorff距离评估差异。
主要发现
- 指南发布前存在显著勾画者间差异,前区域大于后区域(Dice评分0.66 vs 0.80,P<.01)。
- 培训后侧方区域整体95% Hausdorff距离显著改善(0.71 vs 1.02,P=.02)。
- 培训后Dice评分无显著改善(0.76 vs 0.78,P=.31),前区域和后区域分别分析时亦均无显著改善。
- 前区域腹侧和外侧勾画差异减小,但前区域尾侧差异增加。
关键数值与推荐
- 指南发布前Dice评分前区域0.66 vs 后区域0.80,P<.01。
- 培训后侧方区域整体95% Hausdorff距离0.71 vs 1.02,P=.02。
- 培训后Dice评分0.76 vs 0.78,P=.31。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出尽管95% Hausdorff距离有所改善,特定区域仍需进一步改进以确保充分勾画。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: In rectal cancer, accurate delineation is crucial for patients with enlarged lateral lymph nodes to minimize lateral local recurrence risk. This study aims to evaluate interphysician variation in delineation of the lateral compartments, and the impact of training and implementation of standardized delineation protocols. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Twenty-three radiation oncologists from 15 institutes delineated the clinical target volume (CTV) on computed tomography scan in 1 example of a patient with rectal cancer. Parallel to this, the national consensus guideline was updated. Participating radiation oncologists completed an e-learning and online training session. Subsequently, 12 radiation oncologists redelineated the same case. Variation was measured with the Dice score and 95% Hausdorff distance. RESULTS: Considerable interphysician variation was present before guideline distribution; and larger in the anterior compartment than the posterior compartment (Dice score 0.66 vs 0.80, P < .01). After training, there was a significant improvement in 95% Hausdorff distance for the lateral compartments together (0.71 vs 1.02, P = .02), but not in Dice score (0.76 vs 0.78, P = .31), and neither for the anterior and posterior compartment separately. Whereas delineation variation in the ventral and lateral sides decreased, the variation in the caudal side of the anterior compartment increased. CONCLUSIONS: Substantial delineation variation in CTV of the lateral compartments in rectal cancer cases exists. This can be reduced by implementation of a delineation guideline with clear anatomic borders and subsequent training. Despite reduction in 95% Hausdorff distance, there is still need for further improvement in specific areas to assure adequate delineation.
引用
- van Geffen EGM, Sluckin TC, Witte MG, et al. Variations in Radiation Therapy Delineation of the Lateral Compartments in Patients with Rectal Cancer: Results After an Updated National Guideline. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2025. PMID: 39971233. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2025.01.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。