文献速递头颈部肿瘤放疗放疗物理与技术

影像放射肿瘤学核心头颈部认证体模是否为不同解剖部位的有效替代工具

Is the Imaging Radiation Oncology Core Head and Neck Credentialing Phantom an Effective Surrogate for Different Anatomic Sites?
PubMed 文献 · Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys · 2024-10-02

本研究在RayStation中修改Varian加速器的多叶准直器偏移、透射、百分深度剂量及7项束流建模参数,匹配社区数据的5个百分位水平,在25例头颈部体模病例和25例临床病例(头颈、前列腺、肺、间皮瘤、脑)上生成2000个计划扰动,比较体模与临床计划中临床靶区平均剂量和危及器官最大剂量的偏差。结果显示体模对这些参数扰动的敏感性与临床部位相当或更高,体模计划与各解剖部位临床计划中平均多叶准直器间隙最能描述束流建模参数误差的影响。作者结论认为该体模是评估机构跨解剖部位表现的有效替代装置。

要点

  • 多叶准直器偏移和透射参数扰动对体模和临床计划剂量精度影响最大。
  • 体模对这些参数扰动的敏感性与临床部位相当或更高,大体与治疗复杂度一致。
  • 平均多叶准直器间隙最能描述体模及各解剖部位临床计划中束流建模参数误差的影响。

核心结论

  • 与不同解剖部位相比,IROC头颈部认证体模对治疗计划系统误差表现出相似或更高的敏感性,因此是评估机构跨解剖部位表现的有效替代装置。
  • 若机构成功照射体模,该结果可赋予信心:该机构能够成功实施针对广泛解剖部位的调强放射治疗。

研究设计与样本

  • 在RayStation中修改Varian加速器的多叶准直器偏移、透射、百分深度剂量及7项额外束流建模参数,匹配社区数据第2.5、25、50、75和97.5百分位水平。
  • 在25例头颈部体模病例和25例临床病例(头颈、前列腺、肺、间皮瘤、脑)上评估修改,生成2000个计划扰动。
  • 比较体模计划与临床计划中临床靶区平均剂量和危及器官最大剂量的差异,并评估18种复杂度指标与剂量偏差的关系。

主要发现

  • 多叶准直器偏移和透射参数扰动对体模和临床计划(所有解剖部位)的剂量精度影响最大。
  • 体模对这些参数扰动的敏感性与临床部位相当或更高,大体与治疗复杂度一致。
  • 平均多叶准直器间隙最能描述体模计划及各解剖部位临床计划中治疗计划系统束流建模参数误差的影响。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: The Imaging Radiation Oncology Core (IROC) head and neck (H&N) phantom is used to credential institutions for intensity modulated radiation therapy delivery for all anatomic sites where delivery of modulated therapy is a primary challenge. This study evaluated how appropriate the use of this phantom is for varied clinical anatomy by evaluating how closely the IROC H&N phantom described clinical dose errors from beam modeling compared with various anatomic sites. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The multileaf collimator (MLC) offset, transmission, percent depth dose, and 7 additional beam modeling parameters for a Varian accelerator were modified in RayStation to match community data at the 2.5th, 25th, 50th, 75th, and 97.5th percentile levels. Modifications were evaluated on 25 H&N phantom cases and 25 clinical cases (H&N, prostate, lung, mesothelioma, and brain), generating 2000 plan perturbations. Differences in mean dose delivered to clinical target volumes and maximum dose to organs at risk were compared between phantom and clinical plans to assess the relationship between dose deviations in phantom versus clinical target volumes and as a function of 18 different complexity metrics. RESULTS: Perturbations to MLC offset and transmission parameters demonstrated the greatest impact on dose accuracy for phantom and clinical plans (for all anatomic sites). The phantom demonstrated equivalent or greater sensitivity to these parameter perturbations compared with clinical sites, largely aligning with treatment complexity. The mean MLC gap best described the impact of errors in treatment planning system beam modeling parameters in phantom plans and clinical plans from various anatomic sites. CONCLUSIONS: When compared across various anatomic sites, the IROC H&N credentialing phantom exhibited similar or greater sensitivity to errors in the treatment planning system. As such, it is a suitable surrogate device for assessing institutional performance across various anatomic sites. If an institution successfully irradiates the phantom, that result confers confidence that intensity modulated radiation therapy to a wide range of anatomic sites can be successfully delivered by the institution.

来源:Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Brooks FMD, Glenn MC, Hernandez V, et al. Is the Imaging Radiation Oncology Core Head and Neck Credentialing Phantom an Effective Surrogate for Different Anatomic Sites? Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2024. PMID: 39362313. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2024.09.053

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。