丹麦乳腺癌协作组基于共识的乳腺癌放疗淋巴结分区自动分割模型的开发与综合评估
本研究由丹麦21位乳腺癌勾画专家依据ESTRO共识指南建立金标准与高质量训练数据集,针对高危乳腺癌患者淋巴结临床靶区按侧别及内乳淋巴结扩展训练四个深度学习自动分割模型。模型在自身测试集及金标准数据集观察者间变异中定量评估,并经全国委员会盲法定性评价。结果显示除一个模型中胸肌间淋巴结外,所有结构中位DSC均大于0.7,模型表现与专家间观察者间变异相当,临床接受度与专家手动勾画相当或更高。
要点
- 依据ESTRO共识指南由丹麦21位专家建立金标准与训练数据集,训练四个淋巴结临床靶区深度学习模型。
- 除一个模型中胸肌间淋巴结外,所有结构中位DSC均大于0.7。
- 定性评价中深度学习结构36%无需修改,手动勾画为34%,模型表现与专家间变异相当。
核心结论
- 深度学习模型基于全国共识队列开发,表现与乳腺癌专家间观察者间变异相当,临床接受度与专家手动勾画相当或更高。
研究设计与样本
- 由丹麦所有放疗中心的21位乳腺癌勾画专家依据ESTRO共识勾画指南建立金标准数据集与高质量训练数据集。
- 按侧别及内乳淋巴结扩展训练四个深度学习自动分割模型,在自身测试集及金标准数据集观察者间变异中进行定量评估。
- 由全国委员会对深度学习与手动勾画进行盲法定性评价。
主要发现
- 除一个模型中的胸肌间淋巴结外,所有结构中位DSC均大于0.7。
- 定性评价中深度学习结构297个(36%)无需修改,手动勾画286个(34%)无需修改。
- 手动勾画中主要修改和从头开始更容易的比例更高。
- 模型表现处于专家组观察者间变异范围内,有两个例外。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: This study aimed at training and validating a multi-institutional deep learning (DL) auto segmentation model for nodal clinical target volume (CTVn) in high-risk breast cancer (BC) patients with both training and validation dataset created with multi-institutional participation, with the overall aim of national clinical implementation in Denmark. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A gold standard (GS) dataset and a high-quality training dataset were created by 21 BC delineation experts from all radiotherapy centres in Denmark. The delineations were created according to ESTRO consensus delineation guidelines. Four models were trained: One per laterality and extension of CTVn internal mammary nodes. The DL models were tested quantitatively in their own test-set and in relation to interobserver variation (IOV) in the GS dataset with geometrical metrics, such as the Dice Similarity Coefficient (DSC). A blinded qualitative evaluation was conducted with a national board, presented to both DL and manual delineations. RESULTS: A median DSC > 0.7 was found for all, except the CTVn interpectoral node in one of the models. In the qualitative evaluation 'no corrections needed' were acquired for 297 (36 %) in the DL structures and 286 (34 %) for manual delineations. A higher rate of 'major corrections' and 'easier to start from scratch' was found in the manual delineations. The models performed within the IOV of an expert group, with two exceptions. CONCLUSION: DL models were developed on a national consensus cohort and performed on par with the IOV between BC experts and had a comparable or higher clinical acceptance than expert manual delineations.
引用
- Buhl ES, Lorenzen EL, Refsgaard L, et al. Development and comprehensive evaluation of a national DBCG consensus-based auto-segmentation model for lymph node levels in breast cancer radiotherapy. Radiother Oncol. 2024. PMID: 39374675. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2024.110567
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。