全自动放射治疗计划:从扫描到计划的挑战
该挑战评估前列腺及前列腺床放疗从模拟CT到可交付计划的全流程自动化程度。收到13份提交,最佳方案在共识轮廓评估下对所有病例的最低目标依从率为81.8%,在10例中1例满足全部目标;使用自身自动轮廓时达标率为89.5%,10例中4例满足全部目标。结论认为全流程自动化可行,但多数计划仍需少量调整,且使用者对系统缺乏信任,阻碍了完全自动化。
要点
- 最佳方案在共识轮廓下依从81.8%最低目标,10例中1例全达标。
- 同一系统用自身自动轮廓时达标89.5%,10例中4例全达标。
- 尽管有禁止检查或编辑的硬性规则,69%的参与者报告提交前查看过结果。
核心结论
- 前列腺及前列腺床放疗从模拟CT到可交付治疗计划的全流程自动化是可能的。
- 许多生成的计划无需调整或仅需轻微调整即可视为临床可接受,但结果提示对此类系统仍缺乏信任,阻碍完全自动化。
研究设计与样本
- 该研究设立了一项针对前列腺和前列腺床放疗的自动治疗计划挑战。
- 参与者获得模拟CT和处方,被要求使用自动化工具在尽可能少的人工干预下生成可交付的放疗计划。
- 计划使用共识专家轮廓评估时按方案依从性评分。
主要发现
- 共收到13份提交。
- 最佳提交在共识轮廓评估下对所有病例的最低目标依从率为81.8%,在10例中1例满足全部目标。
- 同一系统使用自身自动轮廓评估时达标率为89.5%,在10例中4例满足全部目标。
- 挑战中使用的大多数系统具有监管许可(自动轮廓82.5%,自动计划77%)。
- 尽管有参与者不应检查或编辑轮廓或计划的硬性规则,69%报告在提交前查看过结果。
关键数值与推荐
- 最佳提交在共识轮廓下依从81.8%的最低目标,10例中1例全达标。
- 同一系统用自身自动轮廓时达标89.5%,10例中4例全达标。
- 自动轮廓系统监管许可率82.5%,自动计划系统77%。
- 69%的参与者报告提交前查看结果,违反不应检查或编辑的硬性规则。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Over the past decade, tools for automation of various sub-tasks in radiotherapy planning have been introduced, such as auto-contouring and auto-planning. The purpose of this study was to benchmark what degree of automation is possible. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A challenge to perform automated treatment planning for prostate and prostate bed radiotherapy was set up. Participants were provided with simulation CTs and a treatment prescription and were asked to use automated tools to produce a deliverable radiotherapy treatment plan with as little human intervention as possible. Plans were scored for their adherence to the protocol when assessed using consensus expert contours. RESULTS: Thirteen entries were received. The top submission adhered to 81.8% of the minimum objectives across all cases using the consensus contour, meeting all objectives in one of the ten cases. The same system met 89.5% of objectives when assessed with their own auto-contours, meeting all objectives in four of the ten cases. The majority of systems used in the challenge had regulatory clearance (Auto-contouring: 82.5%, Auto-planning: 77%). Despite the 'hard' rule that participants should not check or edit contours or plans, 69% reported looking at their results before submission. CONCLUSIONS: Automation of the full planning workflow from simulation CT to deliverable treatment plan is possible for prostate and prostate bed radiotherapy. While many generated plans were found to require none or minor adjustment to be regarded as clinically acceptable, the result indicated there is still a lack of trust in such systems preventing full automation.
引用
- Gooding MJ, Aluwini S, Guerrero Urbano T, et al. Fully automated radiotherapy treatment planning: A scan to plan challenge. Radiother Oncol. 2024. PMID: 39222848. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2024.110513
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。