基于人群背景下的可视化放射治疗计划质量评分分诊方法
研究利用111例头颈癌患者数据建立基于百分位数的计划质量评分系统,并以雏菊图可视化;6名医生对60份计划行5分Likert评分验证,医生评分与计划百分位秩的Spearman相关系数为0.53(P<.001),ROC曲线下面积为0.76。
要点
- 基于111例头颈癌患者数据建立按计划和按目标的双层百分位评分系统,并以雏菊图可视化。
- 6名医生对60份计划行5分Likert评分,医生评分与计划百分位秩的Spearman相关系数为0.53(P<.001)。
- ROC分析显示曲线下面积为0.76,可区分可接受与不可接受的计划质量。
核心结论
- 该评分系统与医生评分相关,并提供直观的可视化反馈以识别良好治疗计划质量,提示其可用于质量保证流程。
研究设计与样本
- 使用111例头颈癌患者数据建立基于百分位数的治疗计划质量评分系统,按计划和按目标两个层面评估。
- 招募6名医生对60份计划进行评分验证,采用5分Likert量表(≥3分视为通过)。
- 采用Spearman相关分析评估计划百分位秩与医生评分的关系,采用ROC曲线分析评估评分系统的区分能力。
主要发现
- 医生评分的60份计划中,8份被判定为临床可接受,其评分系统百分位值为89.0±14.5。
- 需小幅修改或判定为不可接受的计划变异更大,分别位于62.6±25.1百分位和35.6±25.7百分位。
- 医生评分与治疗计划百分位之间的估计Spearman相关系数为0.53(P<.001),呈中度但统计学显著相关。
- ROC曲线分析显示可区分可接受与不可接受的计划质量,曲线下面积为0.76。
关键数值与推荐
- Likert评分1分和2分代表临床不可接受计划,3分和4分代表需小幅修改的计划,5分代表临床可接受计划。
- 评分≥3分视为通过。
- 临床可接受计划(8份)的百分位值为89.0±14.5。
- 需小幅修改计划的百分位值为62.6±25.1,不可接受计划的百分位值为35.6±25.7。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出该评分系统与医生评分相关,并提供直观可视化反馈以识别良好治疗计划质量,提示其可用于质量保证流程。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Our purpose was to develop a clinically intuitive and easily understandable scoring method using statistical metrics to visually determine the quality of a radiation treatment plan. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Data from 111 patients with head and neck cancer were used to establish a percentile-based scoring system for treatment plan quality evaluation on both a plan-by-plan and objective-by-objective basis. The percentile scores for each clinical objective and the overall treatment plan score were then visualized using a daisy plot. To validate our scoring method, 6 physicians were recruited to assess 60 plans, each using a scoring table consisting of a 5-point Likert scale (with scores ≥3 considered passing). Spearman correlation analysis was conducted to assess the association between increasing treatment plan percentile rank and physician rating, with Likert scores of 1 and 2 representing clinically unacceptable plans, scores of 3 and 4 representing plans needing minor edits, and a score of 5 representing clinically acceptable plans. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis was used to assess the scoring system's ability to quantify plan quality. RESULTS: Of the 60 plans scored by the physicians, 8 were deemed as clinically acceptable; these plans had an 89.0th ± 14.5 percentile value using our scoring system. The plans needing minor edits or deemed unacceptable had more variation, with scores falling in the 62.6nd ± 25.1 percentile and 35.6th ± 25.7 percentile, respectively. The estimated Spearman correlation coefficient between the physician score and treatment plan percentile was 0.53 (P < .001), indicating a moderate but statistically significant correlation. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis demonstrated discernment between acceptable and unacceptable plan quality, with an area under the curve of 0.76. CONCLUSIONS: Our scoring system correlates with physician ratings while providing intuitive visual feedback for identifying good treatment plan quality, thereby indicating its utility in the quality assurance process.
引用
- Leone AO, Mohamed ASR, Fuller CD, et al. A Visualization and Radiation Treatment Plan Quality Scoring Method for Triage in a Population-Based Context. Adv Radiat Oncol. 2024. PMID: 38993196. doi:10.1016/j.adro.2024.101533
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。