肺部立体定向体部放疗的治疗计划与实施实践:2022年ESTRO物理调查结果
2022年ESTRO向物理师会员发放在线调查,回收244份有效答复,覆盖经验、剂量分割、靶区勾画、剂量计算与计划实践、影像协议及质量保证。调查显示肺部SBRT临床实施在诸多方面存在明显异质性,国际指南与实践规范可能促进统一。
要点
- 多数受访者使用C臂直线加速器VMAT技术并每日治疗前CBCT成像实施肺部SBRT。
- 分割方案与剂量处方协议范围广泛,明确偏好处方至PTV的95%或以上。
- 22%未说明剂量计算算法,24%未说明剂量计算条件;高低经验中心间存在实质性差异。
核心结论
- 调查显示肺部SBRT临床实施在诸多方面存在明显异质性,国际指南与实践规范可能促进统一。
研究设计与样本
- 2022年ESTRO向其物理师会员发放在线调查,覆盖经验、剂量与分割、靶区勾画、剂量计算与计划实践、影像协议及质量保证。
- 数据清洗后收集到244份唯一答复,多数受访者来自欧洲,其中大多数具有超过5年SBRT经验。
主要发现
- 绝大多数受访者使用C臂直线加速器上的VMAT技术并采用每日治疗前CBCT成像实施肺部SBRT。
- 报告了广泛的分割方案以及同样广泛的剂量处方协议,明确偏好处方至PTV的95%或以上。
- 剂量计算算法方面,22%未说明算法,24%未说明剂量计算条件。
- 勾画通常在高强度最大投影或平均强度投影图像上进行,剂量主要在后者上计算。
- 计划均匀性、复杂性和适形性评估未出现明确指征,约40%的受访者在过去五年参与了SBRT的跨中心认证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The use of Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy (SBRT) in lung cancer is increasing. However, there is no consensus on the most appropriate treatment planning and delivery practice for lung SBRT. To gauge the range of practice, quantify its variability and identify where consensus might be achieved, ESTRO surveyed the medical physics community. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An online survey was distributed to ESTRO's physicist membership in 2022, covering experience, dose and fractionation, target delineation, dose calculation and planning practice, imaging protocols, and quality assurance. RESULTS: Two-hundred and forty-four unique answers were collected after data cleaning. Most respondents were from Europe the majority of which had more than 5 years' experience in SBRT. The large majority of respondents deliver lung SBRT with the VMAT technique on C-arm Linear Accelerators (Linacs) employing daily pre-treatment CBCT imaging. A broad spectrum of fractionation schemes were reported, alongside an equally wide range of dose prescription protocols. A clear preference was noted for prescribing to 95% or greater of the PTV. Several issues emerged regarding the dose calculation algorithm: 22% did not state it while 24% neglected to specify the conditions under which the dose was calculated. Contouring was usually performed on Maximum or Average Intensity Projection images while dose was mainly computed on the latter. No clear indications emerged for plan homogeneity, complexity, and conformity assessment. Approximately 40% of the responders participated in inter-centre credentialing of SBRT in the last five years. Substantial differences emerged between high and low experience centres, with the latter employing less accurate algorithms and older equipment. CONCLUSION: The survey revealed an evident heterogeneity in numerous aspects of the clinical implementation of lung SBRT treatments. International guidelines and codes of practice might promote harmonisation.
引用
- Carver A, Scaggion A, Jurado-Bruggeman D, et al. Treatment planning and delivery practice of lung SBRT: Results of the 2022 ESTRO physics survey. Radiother Oncol. 2024. PMID: 38702015. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2024.110318
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。