持续气道正压辅助呼吸联合仰卧切线野左乳放疗在深吸气屏气放疗无效或不适用时的应用:低成本心脏保护乳腺放疗以减少低资源地区医疗差距的临床意义
十例左乳腺癌患者因深吸气屏气放疗无法重复、心脏剂量超限或机械故障而改用持续气道正压(15 cm H2O)辅助呼吸下的仰卧切线野放疗。与自由呼吸相比,持续气道正压和深吸气屏气均增加左肺体积并降低心脏及左前降支剂量,所有患者均完成持续气道正压放疗。作者认为该技术简单易行,可为低资源地区提供可负担的心脏保护左乳放疗。
要点
- 持续气道正压辅助呼吸使左肺体积较自由呼吸平均增加51%,与深吸气屏气(46%)相当。
- 乳腺切线野心脏平均剂量:自由呼吸2.3 Gy vs 深吸气屏气1.2 Gy vs 持续气道正压0.9 Gy。
- 乳腺+内乳淋巴结宽切线野左前降支平均剂量:自由呼吸15.5 Gy vs 深吸气屏气7.4 Gy vs 持续气道正压3.5 Gy。
核心结论
- 当深吸气屏气放疗无效或不适用时,持续气道正压辅助呼吸联合仰卧切线野(乳腺放疗)或宽切线野(乳腺+内乳淋巴结放疗)可提供有效且实用的心脏和左前降支保护。
- 持续气道正压放疗易于实施且基础设施要求低,可为低资源地区提供可负担的心脏保护左乳放疗,以减少医疗差距。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为在作者所在机构开展的十例左乳腺癌患者研究,患者先接受深吸气屏气下计算机断层扫描模拟定位,随后接受持续气道正压辅助呼吸(15 cm H2O)以制定持续气道正压放疗计划。
- 采用持续气道正压放疗的原因包括:无法重复深吸气屏气(n=5)、深吸气屏气放疗计划心脏剂量超限(n=2)、因机械问题无法按计划进行深吸气屏气放疗(n=3)。
- 放疗靶区和危及器官按已发表图谱数据勾画;在每例患者自由呼吸、深吸气屏气和持续气道正压辅助呼吸的CT模拟定位图像上,分别制定乳腺放疗仰卧切线野和乳腺+内乳淋巴结放疗宽切线野计划,处方剂量为40 Gy分15次。
主要发现
- 计划靶区覆盖在所有放疗计划中均可接受且相当。
- 与自由呼吸相比,深吸气屏气和持续气道正压辅助呼吸均使胸廓膨胀并增加左肺体积,平均分别增加46%和51%(自由呼吸1230 vs 深吸气屏气1802 vs 持续气道正压1860 cc,P<.01)。
- 与自由呼吸相比,深吸气屏气和持续气道正压辅助呼吸分别使PTVeval-乳腺到心脏的最短距离增加5.6±3.0 mm和11.9±3.6 mm(P<.01),到左前降支的最短距离分别增加4.9±2.9 mm和10.8±4.3 mm(P<.01)。
- 乳腺放疗心脏平均剂量:自由呼吸2.3±0.9 Gy vs 深吸气屏气1.2±0.7 Gy vs 持续气道正压0.9±0.4 Gy(P<.01);乳腺+内乳淋巴结放疗:自由呼吸3.2±1.7 Gy vs 深吸气屏气1.7±0.8 Gy vs 持续气道正压1.3±0.5 Gy(P<.01)。
- 乳腺放疗左前降支平均剂量:自由呼吸11±4.5 Gy vs 深吸气屏气5.4±3.2 Gy vs 持续气道正压2.4±0.9 Gy(P<.01);乳腺+内乳淋巴结放疗:自由呼吸15.5±7.8 Gy vs 深吸气屏气7.4±4.1 Gy vs 持续气道正压3.5±1.4 Gy(P<.01)。
关键数值与推荐
- 持续气道正压辅助呼吸压力为15 cm H2O。
- 放疗处方剂量为40 Gy分15次。
- 乳腺放疗采用仰卧切线野,乳腺+内乳淋巴结放疗采用宽切线野。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,当深吸气屏气放疗无效或不适用时,持续气道正压辅助呼吸联合仰卧切线野或宽切线野可提供有效且实用的心脏和左前降支保护放疗。
- 作者认为,持续气道正压放疗易于实施且基础设施要求低,可为低资源地区提供可负担的心脏保护左乳放疗,以减少医疗差距。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To report continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP)-assisted breathing with supine tangential left breast radiation therapy (CPAP-RT) when deep inspiration breath-hold RT (DIBH-RT) was ineffective or unsuitable. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Ten patients with left breast cancer underwent computed tomography simulation scan (CT-sim) under DIBH followed by CPAP-assisted breathing (15 cm H2O) to create CPAP-RT plans in authors' institute. Reasons for CPAP-RT include inability to reproduce DIBH (n = 5), DIBH-RT plan exceeded dose limits to the heart (n = 2), and unable to proceed with planned DIBH-RT due to mechanical issues (n = 3). Radiation target volumes and organs at risk were contoured according to published atlas data. For dosimetric comparison, supine tangential fields for breast only RT (Breast-RT) and wide-tangential fields for breast + internal mammary nodal RT (Breast + IMN-RT) were used with prescription of 40 Gy in 15 fractions on each patients' CT-sim with free-breathing (FB), DIBH, and CPAP-assisted breathing, respectively. RESULTS: Planning target volume (PTV) coverage was acceptable and comparable in all RT plans. Compared with FB, both DIBH and CPAP-assisted breathing inflated the thorax and increased left lung volume on average by 46% and 51%, respectively (FB: 1230 vs DIBH: 1802 vs CPAP-assisted breathing:1860 cc, P < .01), and increased the shortest distance between PTVeval-Breast to the heart by 5.6 ± 3.0 and 11.9 ± 3.6 mm (P < .01) and to LAD by 4.9 ± 2.9 and 10.8 ± 4.3 mm, respectively (P < .01). Compared with FB, both DIBH and CPAP significantly reduced radiation dose to the heart and LAD. A mean dose to the heart (HeartDmean) was FB: 2.3 ± 0.9, DIBH: 1.2 ± 0.7, and CPAP: 0.9 ± 0.4 Gy in Breast-RT (P < .01); FB: 3.2 ± 1.7, DIBH: 1.7 ± 0.8, and CPAP: 1.3 ± 0.5 Gy in Breast + IMN-RT (P < .01). LADDmean was FB: 11 ± 4.5, DIBH: 5.4 ± 3.2, and CPAP: 2.4 ± 0.9 Gy in Breast-RT (P < .01); FB: 15.5 ± 7.8, DIBH: 7.4 ± 4.1, and CPAP: 3.5 ± 1.4 Gy in Breast + IMN-RT (P < .01). A maximum dose to LAD (LADDmax) was FB: 35.8 ± 8.7, DIBH: 22.4 ± 15.4, and CPAP: 7.8 ± 5.3 Gy in Breast-RT (P < .01); FB: 38.7 ± 5.0, DIBH: 25.3 ± 15.2, and CPAP: 10.2 ± 6.8 Gy in Breast + IMN-RT (P < .01). All patients successfully completed CPAP-RT. CONCLUSIONS: CPAP-RT provides efficient and practical heart and LAD sparing RT using simple supine tangential fields for Breast-RT or wide-tangential fields for Breast + IMN-RT when DIBH-RT was ineffective or unsuitable. With its easy accessibility and low infrastructural requirement, CPAP-RT can provide affordable heart-sparing left breast RT to reduce the health care disparities in low-resource settings.
引用
- Kil WJ, Smith W, Herndon C, et al. Continuous Positive Airway Pressure-Assisted Breathing With Supine Tangential Left Breast Radiation Therapy When Deep Inspiration Breath-Hold Radiation Therapy Was Ineffective or Unsuitable: Clinical Implications for an Affordable Heart-Sparing Breast Radiation Therapy to Reduce the Health Care Disparities in Low-Resource Settings. Adv Radiat Oncol. 2024. PMID: 38681888. doi:10.1016/j.adro.2024.101472
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。