低收入和中等收入国家的放射治疗物理质量保证与管理实践:六国初步试点调查及通过实地走访验证
2020年对6个国家13个放疗中心开展物理质量保证(QA)初步调查,应答率92%;2021年对加纳全部放疗中心实地走访并随访调查17名医学物理师,应答率100%。初步调查显示QA需求与国家人均国民总收入直接相关;实地走访表明教育和培训仍是运行成功QA计划的最重要需求。
要点
- 2020年初步调查覆盖6国13个放疗中心,应答率92%,QA需求与国家人均国民总收入直接相关。
- 2021年加纳实地走访后随访调查17名医学物理师,应答率100%,所有受访者均有患者安全事件记录追踪系统。
- 实地走访审核显示,教育和培训仍是运行成功QA计划的最重要需求。
核心结论
- 初步研究显示QA需求与国家发展指数直接相关,随访调查考察了加纳放疗诊所的运营和物理QA实践。
- 实地走访审核显示,教育和培训仍是运行成功QA计划的最重要需求。
研究设计与样本
- 2020年对6个国家13个选定的放疗中心开展初步调查,2021年对加纳全部放疗中心进行实地走访并向17名医学物理师发送随访调查。
- 加纳放疗中心包括1家私立机构和2家公立机构(记为Public-1和Public-2)。
- 采用定性和描述性方法进行数据分析,运营挑战问题采用5点Likert量表。
主要发现
- 2020年初步调查应答率为92%,QA需求与国家人均国民总收入直接相关。
- 2021年实地走访后调查应答率为100%,私立和Public-1机构各在其放疗中心配备CT模拟机。
- 直线加速器平均每日患者外照射工作量为:私立=25,Public-1=55,Public-2=40;Co-60工作量为:Public-1=45,Public-2=25,私立医院无Co-60。
- Public-1和Public-2缺乏符合Task Group报告(TG)142和198最佳实践所需的设备,Public-2报告了显著的运营挑战。
- Public-1和Public-2设有同行评审病历讨论会,由临床肿瘤学家、医学物理师、医师和物理学员参加;全部17名物理师均表示有患者相关安全事件的记录、追踪和趋势分析系统,但仅1名物理师报告使用国际原子能机构放射肿瘤安全系统。
关键数值与推荐
- 2020年初步调查确定的QA需求包括胶片/阵列探测器、独立剂量计算软件、电离室校准、二极管、热释光二极管(TLD)、验证体模、治疗计划系统(TPS)测试体模、成像测试体模和胶片剂量计、教育和培训。
- Public-1和Public-2缺乏符合TG 142和TG 198最佳实践所需的设备。
- 运营挑战(机器停机、患者相关问题、停电和人员配置)采用5点Likert量表评估。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 初步研究为2020年对6个国家13个选定放疗中心的初步调查。
- 随访调查仅针对加纳的放疗中心。
- 计划开展非洲大陆范围的调查,以聚焦低收入和中等收入国家的QA实践、面临的挑战和经验教训。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Our purpose was to assess physics quality assurance (QA) practices in less resourced radiation therapy (RT) centers to improve quality of care. METHODS AND MATERIALS: A preliminary study was conducted in 2020 of 13 select RT centers in 6 countries, and in 2021, our team conducted onsite visits to all the RT centers in Ghana, one of the countries from the initial survey. The RT centers included 1 private and 2 public institutions (denoted as Public-1 and Public-2). Follow-up surveys were sent to 17 medical physicists from the site visit. Questions centered on the topics of equipment, institutional practice, physics quality assurance, management, and safety practices. Qualitative and descriptive methods were used for data analysis. Questions regarding operational challenges (machine downtime, patient-related issues, power outages, and staffing) were asked on a 5-point Likert scale. RESULTS: The preliminary survey from 2020 had a 92% response rate. One key result showed that for RT centers in lower gross national income per capita countries there was a direct correlation between QA needs and the gross national income per capita of the country. The needs identified included film/array detectors, independent dose calculation software, calibration of ion chambers, diodes, thermoluminiscence diodes (TLDs), phantoms for verification, Treatment Planning System (TPS) test phantoms, imaging test phantoms and film dosimeters, education, and training. For the post survey after the site visit in 2021, we received a 100% response rate. The private and the Public-1 institutions each have computed tomography simulators located in their RT center. The average daily patient external beam workload for each clinic on a linear accelerator was: private = 25, Public-1 = 55, Public-2 = 40. The Co-60 workload was: Public-1 = 45, Public-2 = 25 (there was no Co-60 at the private hospital). Public-1 and -2 lacked the equipment necessary to conform to best practices in Task Group reports (TG) 142 and 198. Public-2 reported significant operational challenges. Notably, Public-1 and -2 have peer review chart rounds, which are attended by clinical oncologists, medical physicists, physicians, and physics trainees. All 17 physicists who responded to the post site visit survey indicated they had a system of documenting, tracking, and trending patient-related safety incidents, but only 1 physicist reported using International Atomic Energy Agency Safety in Radiation Oncology. CONCLUSIONS: The preliminary study showed a direct correlation between QA needs and the development index of a country, and the follow-up survey examines operational and physics QA practices in the RT clinics in Ghana, one of the initial countries surveyed. This will form the basis of a planned continent-wide survey in Africa intended to spotlight QA practices in low- and middle-income countries, the challenges faced, and lessons learned to help understand the gaps and needs to support local physics QA and management programs. Audits during the site visit show education and training remain the most important needs in operating successful QA programs.
引用
- Yorke AA, Williams VM, Elmore S, et al. Radiation Therapy Physics Quality Assurance and Management Practices in Low- and Middle-Income Countries: An Initial Pilot Survey in Six Countries and Validation Through a Site Visit. Adv Radiat Oncol. 2023. PMID: 38405318. doi:10.1016/j.adro.2023.101335
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。