宫颈癌每日计划策略九年经验:与完全在线自适应技术相比计划库仍有效
本中心自2011年起对宫颈癌外照射采用基于计划库的每日计划(PotD)策略,本研究纳入2011年6月至2020年4月接受PotD治疗的376例患者数据,比较当前PotD版本与无自适应及完全在线自适应技术在靶区体积和正常组织保护方面的表现。结果显示当前PotD较无自适应使PTV外扩体积中位减少250 cm3,膀胱-PTV重叠中位从142降至71 cm3、直肠-PTV从39降至16 cm3;完全在线自适应采用5 mm残余误差外扩可进一步使PTV体积减少144 cm3,膀胱-PTV重叠降至35 cm3、直肠-PTV降至11 cm3。作者认为PotD协议较无自适应能有效改善正常组织保护,PotD类协议可被视为完全在线自适应方法的合适替代。
要点
- 当前PotD版本较无自适应使PTV外扩体积中位减少250 cm3。
- 当前PotD使膀胱-PTV重叠中位从142降至71 cm3,直肠-PTV从39降至16 cm3。
- 完全在线自适应采用5 mm外扩可再减少PTV体积144 cm3,膀胱-PTV重叠降至35 cm3、直肠-PTV降至11 cm3。
核心结论
- 当前版本的PotD协议较无自适应是改善正常组织保护的有效技术。
- 完全在线自适应技术可实现进一步保护,但工作流程更复杂且影响可能有限。
- PotD类协议可被视为完全在线自适应方法的合适替代。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究纳入2011年6月至2020年4月按PotD协议治疗的376例宫颈癌患者治疗数据。
- 研究重建了完全在线自适应、无自适应和最新临床版PotD协议三种策略下的PTV大小。
- 正常组织保护通过构建PTV的外扩体积差以及PTV与膀胱、直肠的体积重叠来评估。
主要发现
- 当前PotD版本较无自适应使PTV外扩体积中位减少250 cm3。
- 当前PotD版本使膀胱-PTV重叠中位从142降至71 cm3。
- 当前PotD版本使直肠-PTV重叠中位从39降至16 cm3。
- 完全在线自适应采用5 mm外扩处理残余误差可进一步使PTV体积减少144 cm3。
- 该完全在线自适应场景下膀胱-PTV重叠降至35 cm3,直肠-PTV重叠降至11 cm3。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为PotD类协议可被视为完全在线自适应方法的合适替代。
局限性
- 完全在线自适应技术工作流程更复杂且影响可能有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Since 2011, our center has been using a library-based Plan-of-the-Day (PotD) strategy for external beam radiotherapy of cervical cancer patients to reduce normal tissue dose while maintaining adequate target coverage. With the advent of fully online-adaptive techniques such as daily online-adaptive replanning, further dose reduction may be possible. However, it is unknown how this reduction relates to plan library approaches, and how the most recent PotD strategies relate to no adaptation. In this study we compare the performance of our current PotD strategy with non-adaptive and fully online-adaptive techniques in terms of target volume size and normal tissue sparing. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Treatment data of 376 patients treated with the PotD protocol between June 2011 and April 2020 were included. The size of the Planning Target Volumes (PTVs) was reconstructed for different strategies: full online adaptation, no adaptation, and the latest clinical version of the PotD protocol. Normal tissue sparing was estimated by the difference in margin volume to construct the PTV and the volume overlap of the PTV with bladder and rectum. RESULTS: The current version of our PotD approach reduced the PTV margin volume by a median of 250 cm3 compared to no adaptation. Bladder-PTV overlap decreased from a median of 142 to 71 cm3, and from 39 to 16 cm3 for rectum-PTV. Fully online-adaptive approaches could further decrease the PTV volume by 144 cm3 using a 5 mm margin for residual errors. In this scenario, bladder-PTV overlap was reduced to 35 cm3 and rectum-PTV overlap to 11 cm3. CONCLUSION: The current version of the PotD protocol is an effective technique to improve normal tissue sparing compared to no adaptation. Further sparing can be achieved using fully online-adaptive techniques, but at the cost of a more complex workflow and with a potentially limited impact. PotD-type protocols can therefore be considered as a suitable alternative to fully online-adaptive approaches.
引用
- Reijtenbagh D, Godart J, Penninkhof J, et al. Nine years of plan of the day for cervical cancer: Plan library remains effective compared to fully online-adaptive techniques. Radiother Oncol. 2023. PMID: 37972735. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2023.110009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。