八种商用放射治疗剂量学系统剂量体积直方图构建一致性的多中心多厂商评估
该研究评估了8种主要商用治疗计划系统和剂量报告系统在构建剂量体积直方图(DVH)时的一致性。选取10例临床治疗计划,在Eclipse中创建并匿名化后导出至其他系统比较。结果显示所有系统与Eclipse相比中位差异在1.0%以内但均存在统计学显著差异,Eclipse报告值普遍低于其他系统;结构体积差异更大,中位差异可达3.0%,平均差异可达10.1%。
要点
- 所有系统与Eclipse相比DVH点中位差异在1.0%以内但均存在统计学显著差异。
- Eclipse报告的DVH值在统计学显著水平上低于所有其他评估系统。
- 结构体积差异更大,中位差异可达3.0%,平均差异可达10.1%。
核心结论
- 所有评估系统间观察到较大变异,Eclipse在统计学显著水平上报告值低于所有其他系统。
- 降低剂量网格分辨率带来的变化无统计学显著性,提示该分辨率可能不如结构三维建模等其他计算方面重要。
研究设计与样本
- 选取10例临床治疗计划(包括大分割、立体定向放疗处方或陡峭剂量梯度如头颈部计划,处方剂量从1次18 Gy到35次70 Gy),在Eclipse中以0.25和0.125 cm网格大小计算并匿名化,导出至其他7个主要治疗计划系统(Pinnacle、RayStation、Elements)和剂量报告系统(MIM、Mobius、ProKnow、Velocity)进行比较。
- 收集每个计划临床重要的剂量体积约束点(D0.03 cc [Gy]、体积和无指定约束结构的平均剂量),将每个报告的约束类型和结构体积归一化至Eclipse值进行配对比较,使用Wilcoxon秩和检验和多变量回归模型调整计划、网格大小和至靶区中心距离。
主要发现
- 对于所有相对于Eclipse的DVH点,所有系统中位值差异在1.0%以内,但均与Eclipse不同。
- 考虑平均值,Pinnacle、RayStation和Elements相对于Eclipse的平均值分别为1.038、1.046和1.024,MIM、Mobius、ProKnow和Velocity分别为1.026、1.050、1.033和1.022。
- 较小的剂量网格大小略微改善系统间一致性但无统计学显著性。
- 对于相对于Eclipse的结构体积,所有系统间差异更大,中位值差异范围可达3.0%,平均值差异可达10.1%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To evaluate dose volume histogram (DVH) construction differences across 8 major commercial treatment planning systems (TPS) and dose reporting systems for clinically treated plans of various anatomic sites and target sizes. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Dose files from 10 selected clinically treated plans with a hypofractionation, stereotactic radiation therapy prescription or sharp dose gradients such as head and neck plans ranging from prescription doses of 18 Gy in 1 fraction to 70 Gy in 35 fractions, each calculated at 0.25 and 0.125 cm grid size, were created and anonymized in Eclipse TPS, and exported to 7 other major TPS (Pinnacle, RayStation, and Elements) and dose reporting systems (MIM, Mobius, ProKnow, and Velocity) systems for comparison. Dose-volume constraint points of clinical importance for each plan were collected from each evaluated system (D0.03 cc [Gy], volume, and the mean dose were used for structures without specified constraints). Each reported constraint type and structure volume was normalized to the value from Eclipse for a pairwise comparison. A Wilcoxon rank-sum test was used for statistical significance and a multivariable regression model was evaluated adjusting for plan, grid size, and distance to target center. RESULTS: For all DVH points relative to Eclipse, all systems reported median values within 1.0% difference of each other; however, they were all different from Eclipse. Considering mean values, Pinnacle, RayStation, and Elements averaged at 1.038, 1.046, and 1.024, respectively, while MIM, Mobius, ProKnow, and Velocity reported 1.026, 1.050, 1.033, and 1.022, respectively relative to Eclipse. Smaller dose grid size improved agreement between the systems marginally without statistical significance. For structure volumes relative to Eclipse, larger differences are seen across all systems with a range in median values up to 3.0% difference and mean up to 10.1% difference. CONCLUSIONS: Large variations were observed between all systems. Eclipse generally reported, at statistically significant levels, lower values than all other evaluated systems. The nonsignificant change resulting from lowering the dose grid resolution indicates that this resolution may be less important than other aspects of calculating DVH curves, such as the 3-dimensional modeling of the structure.
引用
- Penoncello GP, Voss MM, Gao Y, et al. Multicenter Multivendor Evaluation of Dose Volume Histogram Creation Consistencies for 8 Commercial Radiation Therapy Dosimetric Systems. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2023. PMID: 37914082. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2023.09.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。