女性盆腔新兴危及器官(OARs)的勾画及观察者间差异:意大利放射治疗与临床肿瘤学协会(AIRO)研究
该两阶段多中心研究由意大利放射治疗与临床肿瘤学协会(AIRO)开展,旨在为女性盆腔新兴危及器官提供勾画指南并评估观察者间差异。15名放射肿瘤科医生参与,第一阶段基于个人知识勾画,第二阶段经网络研讨会和勾画图谱培训后重新勾画,采用Dice相似系数(DSC)等指标与基准比较。结果显示盆腔骨亚结构勾画一致性高(DSC 0.9±0.02和0.91±0.01),卵巢、阴道、膀胱亚结构和肛门外括约肌一致性中等,肛直肠括约肌复合体其他亚结构一致性低。
要点
- 盆腔骨亚结构(髂骨髓、下骨盆骨髓)勾画一致性高,DSC分别为0.9±0.02和0.91±0.01。
- 卵巢、阴道、膀胱亚结构和肛门外括约肌勾画一致性中等,DSC范围0.515±0.08至0.72±0.05。
- 肛提肌、耻骨直肠肌和肛门内括约肌勾画一致性低,DSC分别为0.345±0.07、0.41±0.10和0.4±0.07。
核心结论
- 本研究发现在女性盆腔新兴危及器官勾画中,观察者间一致性为中等至低水平,观察者间变异度高。
- 作者认为应鼓励开发勾画工具以改善这些危及器官的常规勾画,并提高放疗计划的质量和一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 由盆腔影像专家的放射肿瘤科医生和放射科医生根据其知识和临床实践制作包含每个新兴危及器官解剖边界的勾画图谱,作为质量基准。
- 邀请未参与制定勾画图谱且对妇科肿瘤治疗感兴趣的放射肿瘤科医生参与两阶段试验。
- 第一阶段提供一例局部晚期宫颈癌临床病例,参与者基于个人盆腔解剖知识和经验识别新兴危及器官(肛提肌、耻骨直肠肌、肛门内括约肌、肛门外括约肌、膀胱底和三角区、膀胱颈、髂骨髓、下骨盆骨髓、腰骶骨髓)。
- 随后举行网络研讨会和勾画实验室,展示建议的危及器官和勾画流程。
- 第二阶段在网络研讨会后,每位参与研究但未参与制定基准的参与者收到定制的勾画图谱和解剖边界,并被要求使用提供的工具再次勾画危及器官。
主要发现
- 15名来自不同机构的放射肿瘤科医生参与研究。
- 盆腔骨亚结构勾画一致性高,DSC:髂骨髓(IBM)0.9±0.02,下骨盆骨髓(LPBM)0.91±0.01。
- 卵巢勾画一致性中等,DSC:右侧0.61±0.16,左侧0.72±0.05。
- 阴道勾画一致性中等,DSC为0.575±0.13。
- 膀胱亚结构勾画一致性中等,DSC为0.515±0.08;肛门外括约肌(EAS)勾画一致性中等,DSC为0.605±0.05。
关键数值与推荐
- 盆腔骨亚结构勾画一致性高:IBM DSC 0.9±0.02;LPBM DSC 0.91±0.01。
- 卵巢勾画一致性中等:右侧DSC 0.61±0.16;左侧DSC 0.72±0.05。
- 阴道勾画一致性中等:DSC 0.575±0.13。
- 膀胱亚结构勾画一致性中等:DSC 0.515±0.08;EAS勾画一致性中等:DSC 0.605±0.05。
- 肛直肠括约肌复合体其他亚结构勾画一致性低:LAM DSC 0.345±0.07;PRM DSC 0.41±0.10;IAS DSC 0.4±0.07。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为应鼓励开发勾画工具以改善这些危及器官的常规勾画,并提高放疗计划的质量和一致性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To provide straightforward instructions for daily practice in delineating emerging organs-at-risk (OARs) of the female pelvis and to discuss the interobserver variability in a two-step multicenter study. METHODS AND MATERIALS: A contouring atlas with anatomical boundaries for each emerging OAR was realized by radiation oncologists and radiologists who are experts in pelvic imaging, as per their knowledge and clinical practice. These contours were identified as quality benchmarks for the analysis subsequently carried out. Radiation oncologists not involved in setting the custom-built contouring atlas and interested in the treatment of gynecological cancer were invited to participate in this 2-step trial. In the first step all participants were supplied with a selected clinical case of locally advanced cervical cancer and had to identify emerging OARs (Levator ani muscle; Puborectalis muscle; Internal anal sphincter; External anal sphincter; Bladder base and trigone; Bladder neck; Iliac Bone Marrow; Lower Pelvis Bone Marrow; Lumbosacral Bone Marrow) based on their own personal knowledge of pelvic anatomy and experience. The suggested OARs and the contouring process were then presented at a subsequent webinar meeting with a contouring laboratory. Finally, in the second step, after the webinar meeting, each participant who had joined the study but was not involved in setting the benchmark received the custom-built contouring atlas with anatomical boundaries and was requested to delineate again the OARs using the tool provided. The Dice Similarity Coefficient (DSC) and the Jaccard Similarity Coefficient (JSC) were used to evaluate the spatial overlap accuracy of the different volume delineations and compared with the benchmark; the Hausdorff distance (HD) and the mean distance to agreement (MDA) to explore the distance between contours. All the results were reported as sample mean and standard deviation (SD). RESULTS: Fifteen radiation oncologists from different Institutions joined the study. The participants had a high agreement degree for pelvic bones sub-structures delineation according to DICE (IBM: 0.9 ± 0.02; LPBM: 0.91 ± 0.01). A moderate degree according to DICE was showed for ovaries (Right: 0.61 ± 0.16, Left: 0.72 ± 0.05), vagina (0.575 ± 0.13), bladder sub-structures (0.515 ± 0.08) and EAS (0.605 ± 0.05), whereas a low degree for the other sub-structures of the anal-rectal sphincter complex (LAM: 0.345 ± 0.07, PRM: 0.41 ± 0.10, and IAS: 0.4 ± 0.07). CONCLUSION: This study found a moderate to low level of agreement in the delineation of the female pelvis emerging OARs, with a high degree of variability among observers. The development of delineation tools should be encouraged to improve the routine contouring of these OARs and increase the quality and consistency of radiotherapy planning.
引用
- Augurio A, Macchia G, Caravatta L, et al. Contouring of emerging organs-at-risk (OARS) of the female pelvis and interobserver variability: A study by the Italian association of radiotherapy and clinical oncology (AIRO). Clin Transl Radiat Oncol. 2023. PMID: 37854671. doi:10.1016/j.ctro.2023.100688
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。