QuADRANT研究:欧洲医学放射程序临床审计采纳与实施的现状及改进建议——放射治疗视角
QuADRANT是由欧盟委员会资助的研究项目,旨在评估欧洲临床审计的采纳与实施情况,重点关注《基本安全标准指令》(BSSD)强制要求的临床审计。项目通过泛欧洲调查、专家访谈和文献综述发现,各国临床审计基础设施发展不均衡,放射治疗领域剂量审计传统深厚且IAEA的QUATRO审计实践成熟,但少有国家建立全面的临床审计 programme 或肿瘤特异性临床审计的国际/国家倡议。结论指出欧洲对BSSD临床审计要求的认知差异很大,亟需确保监管检查纳入临床审计 programme 评估。
要点
- 欧洲各国临床审计基础设施发展不均,放射治疗领域剂量审计传统深厚但全面临床审计 programme 少。
- 有成熟质量审计体系国家的经验可作为国家专业学会推广临床审计实施的榜样。
- 建议患者以积极和正式的角色参与临床审计实践与政策制定。
核心结论
- QuADRANT提供了欧洲临床审计实践及其相关方面的总体视图,但显示对BSSD临床审计要求的认知高度可变。
- 亟需努力确保监管检查也纳入临床审计 programme 的评估,覆盖所有涉及患者电离辐射暴露的临床工作方面和专业。
研究设计与样本
- QuADRANT是由欧盟委员会资助的研究项目,旨在评估欧洲临床审计的采纳与实施情况,重点关注BSSD强制要求的临床审计。
- 项目框架内开展了泛欧洲调查、专家访谈和文献综述。
主要发现
- 泛欧洲调查、专家访谈和文献综述表明,国家临床审计基础设施需要发展。
- 放射治疗领域剂量审计传统深厚且经验丰富,IAEA的QUATRO审计实践成熟,但少有国家建立全面的临床审计 programme 或肿瘤特异性临床审计的国际/国家倡议。
- 即使稀疏,有成熟质量审计体系国家的经验可作为国家专业学会推广临床审计实施的榜样。
- 许多国家需要资源分配和国家对临床审计的优先排序。
- 用于增强临床审计参与度的促进因素未被广泛采用;医院认证 programme 的发展可促进临床审计的采纳。
关键数值与推荐
- 建议患者以积极和正式的角色参与临床审计实践与政策制定。
- 国家和国际学会应主动推广和促进临床审计的培训与资源(指南、专家、课程)。
- 由于欧洲对BSSD临床审计要求的认知持续存在差异,需开展工作改进关于BSSD中临床审计立法要求及检查流程相关信息的传播。
- 目标是确保这些检查纳入临床审计并涵盖所有涉及电离辐射医学应用的诊所和专业。
临床怎么用
- 有成熟质量审计体系国家的经验可作为国家专业学会推广临床审计实施的榜样。
- 许多国家需要资源分配和国家对临床审计的优先排序。
- 国家和国际学会应主动推广和促进临床审计的培训与资源(指南、专家、课程)。
- 医院认证 programme 的发展可促进临床审计的采纳。
- 建议患者以积极和正式的角色参与临床审计实践与政策制定。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: QuADRANT was a research project funded by the European Commission to evaluate clinical audit uptake and implementation across Europe, with an emphasis on clinical audit as mandated within the BSSD (Basic Safety Standards Directive). AIM: Focusing on the QuADRANT objectives - to obtain an overview of European clinical audit activity; identify good practices, resources, barriers and challenges; provide guidance and recommendations going forwards; identify the potential for European Union action on quality and safety focusing on the field of radiotherapy. RESULTS: A pan-European survey, expert interviews and a literature review conducted within the framework of the QuADRANT project indicated that developments in national clinical audit infrastructure are required. While in radiotherapy, there is a strong tradition and high level of experience of dosimetry audits and well-established practice through the IAEA's QUATRO audits, few countries have a well-established comprehensive clinical audit programme or international/national initiatives on tumour specific clinical audits. Even if sparse, the experience from countries with established system of quality audits can be used as role-models for national professional societies to promote clinical audit implementation. However, resource allocation and national prioritisation of clinical audit are needed in many countries. National and international societies should take the initiative to promote and facilitate training and resources (guidelines, experts, courses) for clinical audits. Enablers used to enhance clinical audit participation are not widely employed. Development of hospital accreditation programmes can facilitate clinical audit uptake. An active and formalised role for patients in clinical audit practice and policy development is recommended. Because there is a persisting variation in European awareness of BSSD clinical audit requirements, work is needed to improve dissemination of information on the legislative requirements relating to clinical audit in the BSSD and in relation to inspection processes. The aim is to ensure these include clinical audit and that they encompass all clinics and specialties involved in medical applications using ionising radiation. CONCLUSION: QuADRANT provided an overarching view of clinical audit practice in Europe, with all its related aspects. Unfortunately, it showed that the awareness of the BSSD requirements for clinical audit are highly variable. Therefore, there is an urgent need to dedicate efforts towards ensuring that regulatory inspections also incorporate an assessment of clinical audit program(s), affecting all aspects of clinical work and specialties involved in patient exposure to ionising radiation.
引用
- Jornet N, Strojan P, Howlett DC, et al. The QuADRANT study: Current status and recommendations for improving uptake and implementation of clinical audit of medical radiological procedures in Europe. The radiotherapy perspective. Radiother Oncol. 2023. PMID: 37385381. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2023.109772
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。