ESTRO ACROP 前列腺癌术后放疗前列腺床勾画指南
ESTRO-ACROP 共识专家组由 11 名放射肿瘤科医生和 1 名放射科医生组成,针对辅助放疗、PSA 进展后挽救放疗及 PSA 持续升高挽救放疗三种场景勾画前列腺床临床靶区,通过热图和 Sørensen-Dice 系数分析争议区域,经邮件和视频会议讨论形成统一共识指南。
要点
- 辅助放疗场景平均 CTV 为 76 cc(SD=26.6),PSA 进展后挽救放疗为 51.80 cc(SD=22.7),PSA 持续升高挽救放疗为 57.63 cc(SD=25.2)。
- 与中位数相比,辅助放疗场景平均 Sørensen-Dice 相似系数为 0.60(SD 0.10),PSA 进展后挽救放疗为 0.58(SD=0.12),PSA 持续升高挽救放疗为 0.60(SD=0.11)。
- 专家组基于热图和问卷识别出前列腺床 CTV 的多个争议区域,经视频会议讨论达成共识,制定统一推荐意见,不依赖于放疗时机。
核心结论
- 由经验丰富的泌尿生殖放射肿瘤科医生和放射科医生组成的专家组中观察到勾画变异性。
- 制定了单一当代 ESTRO-ACROP 共识指南,以解决分歧区域并提高前列腺床勾画的一致性,不依赖于适应证。
研究设计与样本
- ESTRO-ACROP 共识专家组由 11 名放射肿瘤科医生和 1 名放射科医生组成,均具有公认的前列腺癌亚专科专长。
- 参与者在 3 个临床相关场景中勾画前列腺床临床靶区:辅助放疗、PSA 进展后挽救放疗和 PSA 持续升高挽救放疗。
- 这些病例聚焦于手术切缘阳性、包膜外侵犯和精囊腺受累的情况,均无影像学局部复发证据。
- 通过 FALCON 平台共享单一计算机断层扫描(CT)数据集,使用 EduCaseTM 软件勾画。
- 采用热图定性分析争议区域,采用 Sørensen-Dice 相似系数定量分析,并通过病例专用问卷、电子邮件和视频会议讨论达成共识。
主要发现
- 辅助放疗场景平均 CTV 为 76 cc(SD=26.6),PSA 进展后挽救放疗为 51.80 cc(SD=22.7),PSA 持续升高挽救放疗为 57.63 cc(SD=25.2)。
- 与中位数相比,辅助放疗场景平均 Sørensen-Dice 相似系数为 0.60(SD 0.10),PSA 进展后挽救放疗为 0.58(SD=0.12),PSA 持续升高挽救放疗为 0.60(SD=0.11)。
- 为每个临床场景生成了热图。
- 基于热图和问卷识别出前列腺床 CTV 的多个争议区域。
- 专家组同意对所有病例采用统一推荐意见,不依赖于放疗时机。
关键数值与推荐
- 辅助放疗场景平均 CTV 为 76 cc(SD=26.6)。
- PSA 进展后挽救放疗场景平均 CTV 为 51.80 cc(SD=22.7)。
- PSA 持续升高挽救放疗场景平均 CTV 为 57.63 cc(SD=25.2)。
- 辅助放疗场景平均 Sørensen-Dice 相似系数为 0.60(SD 0.10)。
- PSA 进展后挽救放疗场景平均 Sørensen-Dice 相似系数为 0.58(SD=0.12),PSA 持续升高挽救放疗场景为 0.60(SD=0.11)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE: Radiotherapy to the prostate bed is a potentially curative salvage option after radical prostatectomy. Although prostate bed contouring guidelines are available in the literature, important variabilities exist. The objective of this work is to provide a contemporary consensus guideline for prostate bed delineation for postoperative radiotherapy. METHODS: An ESTRO-ACROP contouring consensus panel consisting of 11 radiation oncologists and one radiologist, all with known subspecialty expertise in prostate cancer, was established. Participants were asked to delineate the prostate bed clinical target volumes (CTVs) in 3 separate clinically relevant scenarios: adjuvant radiation, salvage radiation with PSA progression, and salvage radiation with persistently elevated PSA. These cases focused on the presence of positive surgical margin, extracapsular extension, and seminal vesicles involvement. None of the cases had radiographic evidence of local recurrence on imaging. A single computed tomography (CT) dataset was shared via FALCON platform and contours were performed using EduCaseTM software. Contours were analyzed qualitatively using heatmaps which provided a visual assessment of controversial regions and quantitatively analyzed using Sorensen-Dice similarity coefficients. Participants also answered case-specific questionnaires addressing detailed recommendations on target delineation. Discussions via electronic mails and videoconferences for final editing and consensus were performed. RESULTS: The mean CTV for the adjuvant case was 76 cc (SD = 26.6), salvage radiation with PSA progression was 51.80 cc (SD = 22.7), and salvage radiation with persistently elevated PSA 57.63 cc (SD = 25.2). Compared to the median, the mean Sorensen-Dice similarity coefficient for the adjuvant case was 0.60 (SD 0.10), salvage radiation with PSA progression was 0.58 (SD = 0.12), and salvage radiation with persistently elevated PSA 0.60 (SD = 0.11). A heatmap for each clinical scenario was generated. The group agreed to proceed with a uniform recommendation for all cases, independent of the radiotherapy timing. Several controversial areas of the prostate bed CTV were identified based on both heatmaps and questionnaires. This formed the basis for discussions via videoconferences where the panel achieved consensus on the prostate bed CTV to be used as a novel guideline for postoperative prostate cancer radiotherapy. CONCLUSION: Variability was observed in a group formed by experienced genitourinary radiation oncologists and a radiologist. A single contemporary ESTRO-ACROP consensus guideline was developed to address areas of dissonance and improve consistency in prostate bed delineation, independent of the indication.There is important variability in existing contouring guidelines for postoperative prostate bed (PB) radiotherapy (RT) after radical prostatectomy. This work aimed at providing a contemporary consensus guideline for PB delineation. An ESTRO ACROP consensus panel including radiation oncologists and a radiologist, all with known subspecialty expertise in prostate cancer, delineated the PB CTV in 3 scenarios: adjuvant RT, salvage RT with PSA progression, and salvage RT with persistently elevated PSA. None of the cases had evidence of local recurrence. Contours were analysed qualitatively using heatmaps for visual assessment of controversial regions and quantitatively using Sorensen-Dice coefficient. Case-specific questionnaires were also discussed via e-mails and videoconferences for consensus. Several controversial areas of the PB CTV were identified based on both heatmaps and questionnaires. This formed the basis for discussions via videoconferences. Finally, a contemporary ESTRO-ACROP consensus guideline was developed to address areas of dissonance and improve consistency in PB delineation, independent of the indication.
引用
- Dal Pra A, Dirix P, Khoo V, et al. ESTRO ACROP guideline on prostate bed delineation for postoperative radiotherapy in prostate cancer. Clin Transl Radiat Oncol. 2023. PMID: 37251620. doi:10.1016/j.ctro.2023.100638
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。