年轻肿瘤科医生从基于深度学习危及器官勾画模型中获益多于专家:一项探索工作经验和机构组风格因素的多机构鼻咽癌放疗临床研究
该多机构临床研究基于机构A的188例鼻咽癌CT数据集建立深度学习勾画系统,纳入三个机构肿瘤学组(每组含初学者和专家),对28个危及器官进行手动勾画和深度学习后编辑两轮试验,各10例测试病例。结果显示深度学习勾画系统可消除经验不一致性,初学者改善的危及器官数量多于专家,初学者满意度率显著高于专家。
要点
- 基于深度学习勾画系统,经验不一致性被消除。
- 初学者改善的危及器官数量多于专家(体积Dice 7 vs 4,表面Dice 5 vs 4)。
- 初学者满意度率在具有经验组显著性的危及器官上均显著高于专家。
核心结论
- 深度学习勾画系统对多种机构均有效,初学者比专家获益更多。
研究设计与样本
- 多机构临床研究,基于机构A的188例鼻咽癌患者CT数据集建模深度学习勾画系统,纳入三个机构肿瘤学组A、B、C,每组含一名初学者和一名专家,对28个危及器官各进行10例测试病例的手动勾画和深度学习后编辑两轮试验。
主要发现
- 基于深度学习勾画系统,经验不一致性被消除;机构内一致性在C组被消除,但在A组和B组仍存在。
- C组从深度学习勾画系统获益最多,改善的危及器官数量最多(体积Dice为8个,表面Dice为10个),B组次之。
- 初学者获得的改善危及器官数量多于专家(体积Dice:7 vs 4;表面Dice:5 vs 4)。
- 体积满意率和表面满意率因机构组而异,但在具有经验组显著性的危及器官上,初学者的满意率均显著高于专家。
- 体积满意率与深度学习后编辑体积Dice之间呈显著正线性关系,系数为0.78。
关键数值与推荐
- 改善的危及器官数量:C组体积Dice 8个、表面Dice 10个;初学者体积Dice 7个 vs 专家4个,初学者表面Dice 5个 vs 专家4个。
- 体积满意率与深度学习后编辑体积Dice的线性关系系数为0.78。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: To comprehensively investigate the behaviors of oncologists with different working experiences and institute group styles in deep learning-based organs-at-risk (OAR) contouring. METHODS: A deep learning-based contouring system (DLCS) was modeled from 188 CT datasets of patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) in institute A. Three institute oncology groups, A, B, and C, were included; each contained a beginner and an expert. For each of the 28 OARs, two trials were performed with manual contouring first and post-DLCS edition later, for ten test cases. Contouring performance and group consistency were quantified by volumetric and surface Dice coefficients. A volume-based and a surface-based oncologist satisfaction rate (VOSR and SOSR) were defined to evaluate the oncologists' acceptance of DLCS. RESULTS: Based on DLCS, experience inconsistency was eliminated. Intra-institute consistency was eliminated for group C but still existed for group A and group B. Group C benefits most from DLCS with the highest number of improved OARs (8 for volumetric Dice and 10 for surface Dice), followed by group B. Beginners obtained more numbers of improved OARs than experts (7 v.s. 4 in volumetric Dice and 5 v.s. 4 in surface Dice). VOSR and SOSR varied for institute groups, but the rates of beginners were all significantly higher than those of experts for OARs with experience group significance. A remarkable positive linear relationship was found between VOSR and post-DLCS edition volumetric Dice with a coefficient of 0.78. CONCLUSIONS: The DLCS was effective for various institutes and the beginners benefited more than the experts.
引用
- Song Y, Hu J, Wang Q, et al. Young oncologists benefit more than experts from deep learning-based organs-at-risk contouring modeling in nasopharyngeal carcinoma radiotherapy: A multi-institution clinical study exploring working experience and institute group style factor. Clin Transl Radiat Oncol. 2023. PMID: 37251619. doi:10.1016/j.ctro.2023.100635
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。