文献速递放疗物理与技术

关于辐射剂量-体积暴露与毒性关联统计实践的聚焦综述

A focused review of statistical practices for relating radiation dose-volume exposure and toxicity.
PubMed 文献 · Radiat Oncol · 2023-03-24

本文聚焦综述2015至2021年发表于5本放射肿瘤学专业期刊的剂量体积直方图(DVH)与毒性结局关联研究,共纳入325项研究,分析其统计方法、多变量分析、模型报告及多重比较校正等实践,发现当前统计报告存在内部与外部有效性威胁,并提出报告建议。

要点

  • 47.4%的研究使用切点将DVH变量二分类。
  • 多变量统计用于69.5%研究,其中47.8%处理共线性、32.6%报告拟合优度。
  • 仅17.1%的多重比较研究校正显著性阈值,8.6%研究细节不足以复现结果。

核心结论

  • 当前DVH结局研究的统计报告实践提示研究可能易受内部与外部有效性威胁。
  • 本文提供报告建议以防范此类威胁并促进放射肿瘤学结局研究者的一致性。

研究设计与样本

  • 聚焦MEDLINE检索2015至2021年发表于5本放射肿瘤学专业期刊、将剂量学与人类放疗毒性结局关联的研究。
  • 共检索到2300项研究,其中325项符合纳入标准进行分析。
  • 从每篇手稿提取研究结局、危及器官(OAR)、分析的DVH参数、分析方法、多变量统计使用、拟合优度报告、模型报告完整性、共线性评估、多重比较校正及变量二分类方法。
  • 评估每项研究是否报告充分以允许结果复现。

主要发现

  • 154项(47.4%)研究使用切点将DVH变量二分类。
  • 逻辑回归(55.4%的研究)是最常用的统计方法,其次为Cox回归(20.6%)和线性回归(12.0%)。
  • 226项(69.5%)研究进行了多变量统计检验;其中47.8%处理了共线性可能性,32.6%报告了模型拟合优度。
  • 在196项包含多重统计比较的研究中,41项(17.1%)调整了统计显著性阈值以考虑多重比较。
  • 28项(8.6%)研究被归类为缺少复现研究结果所需的必要细节。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Relating dose-volume histogram (DVH) information to patient outcomes is critical for outcomes research in radiation oncology, but this is statistically challenging. We performed this focused review of DVH toxicity studies to characterize current statistical approaches and determine the need for updated reporting recommendations. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We performed a focused MEDLINE search to identify studies published in 5 radiation oncology specialty journals that associated dosimetry with toxicity outcomes in humans receiving radiotherapy between 2015 and 2021. Elements abstracted from each manuscript included the study outcome, organs-at-risk (OARs) considered, DVH parameters analyzed, summary of the analytic approach, use of multivariable statistics, goodness-of-fit reporting, completeness of model reporting, assessment of multicollinearity, adjustment for multiple comparisons, and methods for dichotomizing variables. Each study was also assessed for sufficient reporting to allow for replication of results. RESULTS: The MEDLINE search returned 2,300 studies for review and 325 met the inclusion criteria for the analysis. DVH variables were dichotomized using cut points in 154 (47.4%) studies. Logistic regression (55.4% of studies) was the most common statistical method used to relate DVH to toxicity outcomes, followed by Cox regression (20.6%) and linear regression (12.0%). Multivariable statistical tests were performed in 226 (69.5%) studies; of these, the possibility of multicollinearity was addressed in 47.8% and model goodness-of-fit were reported in 32.6%. The threshold for statistical significance was adjusted to account for multiple comparisons in 41 of 196 (17.1%) studies that included multiple statistical comparisons. Twenty-eight (8.6%) studies were classified as missing details necessary to reproduce the study results. CONCLUSIONS: Current practices of statistical reporting in DVH outcomes suggest that studies may be vulnerable to threats against internal and external validity. Recommendations for reporting are provided herein to guard against such threats and to promote cohesiveness among radiation oncology outcomes researchers.

来源:Radiat Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. McDonald AM, Schneider CS, Stahl JM, et al. A focused review of statistical practices for relating radiation dose-volume exposure and toxicity. Radiat Oncol. 2023. PMID: 36964622. doi:10.1186/s13014-023-02220-9

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。